User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns


If even one person got the slightest advantage out of this, it's worse than the holocaust. There I said it.


hahaha
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
I'd really like to have someone go through this thread, find everything said by any tester, everything said by any mod and everything said by Bort or any other admin and compare and contrast their assertions to see if everything fits together.


 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Mike is just trying to shed some light on things....which he should be appreciated for....not hung for...


Im not having a go at Mike per se, but all the spokespersons. They're just mollifying the more they try to spin-it like it wasnt such a big thing. The only way GLB can repair this is by just fessing up and admitting blame and stupidity and immediately offering full disclosure on those who were testers etc and granting everyone access to the test servers, giving full respecs, making everyone test what they want, and provide feedback. and actually therefore makes the BUGS forum useful and used like it was originally fucking intended to.

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 23:22:18
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
Originally posted by thebigcali

I'd really like to have someone go through this thread, find everything said by any tester, everything said by any mod and everything said by Bort or any other admin and compare and contrast their assertions to see if everything fits together.




who has that time?
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by thebigcali

Originally posted by thebigcali


I'd really like to have someone go through this thread, find everything said by any tester, everything said by any mod and everything said by Bort or any other admin and compare and contrast their assertions to see if everything fits together.




who has that time?


In a literal sense, any of us. In a 'does anyone care that much' sense, probably none of us
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Originally posted by GG


Originally posted by cowtesticles2001




dude look at the turmoil in the world....


Exactly my point. Any organization (govt, institution, or company) that is run like that only brings turmoil and problems. Just because the "rest of the world" does something doesnt mean it's good to do yourself as a company/business, etc. There are many companies that do not operate like this and succeed. GLB is not following their lead, but "doing what the rest of the world does" and is therefore shooting itself in the foot.

It's indisputable.


See I'd like to think that this coming to light now vs coming to light 2 seasons from now is a good thing....can't we just leave it at that....not much of an advantage right now if you ask me as we sit in this off season....info like always will be out there...you just have to find it...that's the "game" part of it....IMO


It's not about "how much damage was done" or "how much an advantage was gained". It's that it happened at all, and deliberately so, another to add to the list of such actions. It wouldve kept on going if it wasnt leaked. All that's beside the point. The fact is they did it. Another deceptive action.

It's like the Bush administration.


....you're just in it for the conversation...I get it now....
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Originally posted by Azure Dreams




Not exactly. The issue is you can test that SA and find out whether it is actually useless. I'll re-iterate my earlier example as I remember it.

You decide to take 3 linebackers on your team and set them all at some control stat-line. Then you give them 20 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 20 confidence, 12 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 12 trash talk and go through 2 more sims.

You've just figured out the relative worth of confidence and trash talk for LB's as well as the effect confidence has on trash talk. And you did it in 2 days without having to spend a single SP of your players.



The justification for that type of test would be pretty hard to make though, it falls under "What is the best build type" and thats not what testing is for.

I could test as I said, to see if it works as intended or not.
But seeing what combination of build best supports a SA, nope that doesnt roll.


Congratulations, you just provided plenty of justification. Seeing whether trash talk actually does something, whether confidence does, and whether the two work in concert (because they are supposed to be linked in SOME fashion) is doing just what you said.


Tests need to have some measure or predictable out come.

What you suggesting would be something like....

"I want to test if a player performs better with a high amount of 'Aura of Int' than the exact same build without any 'Aura of Int'.

The need and validity of this test is very low, and would not garner very good information.

The logical conclusion is 'Yes' which tells me nothing other than its working, and if the answer is No, then it will become a Fixed required issue, and we go round the loop again. Something was broken for everyone, Testing fixed it.

As long as what is being tested and why is known, there should be no reason to object.

But I couldnt justify "I want to test if having higher Confidence makes 'Aura of Int' work better".
Bort knows the answer, and we dont need to.


From what I've seen there are a lot of things about the sim that Bort doesn't know.

And the trash talk/aura of int/etc. SA's have been ones that since season 1 no one has known quite what to make of. I don't buy that it couldn't be justified pretty easily that you'd want to know whether the QB is affected an appropriate amount with a high level of it.

And to GG: I'm glad you approve, but for the record, I don't bear Mike any ill will, nor do I accuse him of any malicious intent. That said, I think what he's saying glosses over some things and denies utility that is pretty clear.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

So my answer to you is to stop buying flex and start killing off your players....if you're so unhappy with the state of affairs....there isn't much else you can do but suck it up....and prepare for the information highway that is about to be unleashed....


I already started doing that a season ago once i realized GLB wasnt actually trying to make itself better, and make good decisions and run uprightly. But that doesnt mean I dont have a right to still voice my objections and opinions on this game whilever i still do play it etc.

 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Originally posted by GG


Originally posted by wombat killer




Nothing so sinister. Apparently cowtesticles is bothered by people posting who only have one player.


Well, cowtesticles is being silly then. Everyone has a right to an opinion.


...are you guys jumping to conclusions?

I stated that they had one player and said that recreational GLB vs addictive GLB is different....they can say whatever the FUCK they want....

If you're just hear to bash perhaps you should head to FFA....I'm looking for info on whether or not I'd like to invest any more $$$ into this game!


PERIOD

So far Mike has had some soothing answers IMO....but there needs to be a soothing answer put up for all to see....in a 1 post locked thread...by the man himself....


You are delusional. You are the one that started in on people with one player and asking why they are even bothering to post.



....why are you still here? If you enjoy the game that much perhaps your $100 in flex would have gotten the test server knowledge out there when it was suppose to be out there....WTG!
 
NSab
offline
Link
 
Why do we pay for a game that we have to guess what will change from season to season? We get no prewarning and waste money to be Borted over and over again.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSab
Why do we pay for a game that we have to guess what will change from season to season? We get no prewarning and waste money to be Borted over and over again.


I agree but this is something we all hate yet accepted around midseason 2
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001


So my answer to you is to stop buying flex and start killing off your players....if you're so unhappy with the state of affairs....there isn't much else you can do but suck it up....and prepare for the information highway that is about to be unleashed....


I already started doing that a season ago once i realized GLB wasnt actually trying to make itself better, and make good decisions and run uprightly. But that doesnt mean I dont have a right to still voice my objections and opinions on this game whilever i still do play it etc.



Yeah but everyone bashing a game where they spend a lot of their waking moments....


....can't we help the cause instead of feed the fire?
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

And to GG: I'm glad you approve, but for the record, I don't bear Mike any ill will, nor do I accuse him of any malicious intent. That said, I think what he's saying glosses over some things and denies utility that is pretty clear.


That's what i meant as well. Im not trying to attack Mike per se etc. Just that the right course of action here is not continuing to spin it, deflect, and try to mop up aisle three by glossing over stuff etc. People see thru it all. It's all BS and needs to be admitted, fixed, and full accountability taken---including respecs, wipes, full access granted to everyone etc etc.

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
GG, go back read my posts from scratch.

'Next Shift' ????

Goddamn it, I have been fending off questions all friggin day, 'bout 12 hours minimum.

Including in two threads that were Nuked by god knows who that were actually very productive, and put a lot of the answers to question in one place, to stop all this round and round in a circle arguing. I was so pissed aboiut that I was screaming bloody murder along with the rabble.

Its now 6:20am in England, I am in hospital (again) and ward rounds are at 6:30.

This is my last post.

I want to thank everyone who has posted positive comments about their previous dealings with me, and also those people who strongly dislike the idea of testers, but were at the least, not completely attacking everything I posted.

I hope this has in some way calmed some of the concerns of a few of you, and if your not reassured, I honestly dont believe that anyone can do anything more to help other than Bort himself.

Good night all.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Originally posted by GG

Originally posted by cowtesticles2001



So my answer to you is to stop buying flex and start killing off your players....if you're so unhappy with the state of affairs....there isn't much else you can do but suck it up....and prepare for the information highway that is about to be unleashed....


I already started doing that a season ago once i realized GLB wasnt actually trying to make itself better, and make good decisions and run uprightly. But that doesnt mean I dont have a right to still voice my objections and opinions on this game whilever i still do play it etc.



Yeah but everyone bashing a game where they spend a lot of their waking moments....


....can't we help the cause instead of feed the fire?


That's just the thing CT, I view myself as someone helping, as does GG and so on and so forth.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.