User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Yeah, and its hard to ban people for doing something a game allows them to do, remember, its a beta game for players too.

As far as I can tell, (and PLEASE correct me if im wrong, id love to find it) there is no official RULES section. If there were, there would be a lot less questions to admins and moderators (and I might understand chemistry for the first time ever). Its pretty harsh to ban someone for violating rules that havent been officially established.

And whats a VCR?
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 12:21:04
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Originally posted by James1985

I think bort should just start banning people who cheat and try to find lupe holes to get ahead.


Man, people sure are ban-happy around here.

Just because lots of people on the forums think someone is a cheater doesn't make them a cheater.

But let's say Bort decides to ban a cheater. How do you go about it? Refund the money they spent on the game? That's money out of Bort's pocket, and it punishes him for defending the integrity of his own game.

So, no refunds. But now the banned player gets mad. He paid for a product that he no longer gets to use fully. He files a small-claims lawsuit against Bort to get his money back, and then Bort either has to waste his time in a courtroom explaining online football MMORPGs to a bored judge in his 60s who can't get his VCR at home to stop blinking 12:00, or he skips the court date, automatically loses, and has to refund the money anyway.

And that's just for one banned player.

Banning is not a magical cure-all panacea. It closes the door on one problem and opens the door on two more problems. There are still clear-cut cases where it should and must be done, but you'd better make sure it's the sort of situation where the facts are 100% airtight and indisputable. And that's very, very rare.


True

 
SharpyDave
offline
Link
 
Eventually this new rule will even things out. The only other way would to calc each teams level average and re-align all the leagues...could you imagine the uproar if they did that.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SharpyDave
Eventually this new rule will even things out. The only other way would to calc each teams level average and re-align all the leagues...could you imagine the uproar if they did that.


Im not so sure that would make TOO many people mad. Id like it, I think....
 
K9fiend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Originally posted by James1985

I think bort should just start banning people who cheat and try to find lupe holes to get ahead.


Man, people sure are ban-happy around here.

Just because lots of people on the forums think someone is a cheater doesn't make them a cheater.

But let's say Bort decides to ban a cheater. How do you go about it? Refund the money they spent on the game? That's money out of Bort's pocket, and it punishes him for defending the integrity of his own game.

So, no refunds. But now the banned player gets mad. He paid for a product that he no longer gets to use fully. He files a small-claims lawsuit against Bort to get his money back, and then Bort either has to waste his time in a courtroom explaining online football MMORPGs to a bored judge in his 60s who can't get his VCR at home to stop blinking 12:00, or he skips the court date, automatically loses, and has to refund the money anyway.

And that's just for one banned player.

Banning is not a magical cure-all panacea. It closes the door on one problem and opens the door on two more problems. There are still clear-cut cases where it should and must be done, but you'd better make sure it's the sort of situation where the facts are 100% airtight and indisputable. And that's very, very rare.







Actually if anybody were to be banned for cheating it's already in the terms of service that no refunds are given. We all agreed to the TOS when we made our accounts. So sure you could file a small claims case but it would have no teeth.

And Sorry, but those who are cheating are more likely to scare/piss off legit customers who won't come back if pushed to far and nothing is done. So if it takes getting a rid of the few to better the business so be it.

I don't know of 1 MMORPG where anybody would be granted ANY kind of refund if a person is caught cheating.


I agree banning is not a "magical cure all," but there are people who do cheat or act stupid enough to warrant the ban hammer striking them on the dome.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 12:34:11
 
rmead
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC

Sorry, but I didn't copy that definition. I am an Engineer and I use statistics and math every single day in my job. We have had two full seasons, and while that isn't a wealth of history, it is more than enough to use to predict how people can be expected to use their boosts. Granted each and every season, those predictions will get closer to the actuals.


So you are saying you went through the 1st 2 seasons looked at all the players in this game and 60% of them boost? Either you just made up the 60% bit or these guys are making a hell of a lot more then I thought on this game and any minute EA will be scooping it up and we won't have to worry about any of this bullshit... or more likely you just threw out the number 60% thinking a percentage sign would lend credence to your claims...

I don't care if you are an engineer or the lead clown in the Barnum & Bailey circus... when you make up numbers and post them as a part of your formula, be it an estimation or actual its called pulling numbers out of your ass...

Originally posted by PinTBC

I'm willing to bet that you and I couldn't agree on what the term Gutting means. I'd be willing to bet that it would be VERY difficult to get the people on this bulletin board to agree. If I own a USA Pro team, with 20 of my players, and 10 more of my friend's players on it, and I decide I don't wish to expend the energy or money to keep running the team, is it gutting to explain what is going on to my players, and release those who wish it before I sell the team back to the CPU?

I don't believe it is. Does it make it gutting if I later decide to drag all my players from USA Pro down to my Buddy's team in Africa A? No, it could be something as simple as friends wishing to play together.

With the rules Bort has defined set in place, my players from USA Pro are probably not going to end up in the low level league, or they will take a bunch of penalties. It stops the people you like to keep whining about, and it does it simply so it is easy to follow.

By the way, if you are one of the owners who "recruited nearly equal level talent" then good for you, your team has a heck of advantage over the rest of the league, and those teams you expressly hate, are going to have many of the same problems you will.


How about this...
You have 3 teams... A, B and C

Account #1 is GM of Team A and Team B has players on Team A, B and C
Account #2 is GM of Team C and has players on B and C
Account #3 has players on A and B

Accounts 1 and 2 renegotiate all the contracts of level 15 and above players they control along with Account #3's players and sign them each to huge signing bonuses...

Account #3 when the new teams are released he gets a team... within the hour all 30 or so of the players from Teams A, B and C who had their contracts re-done are now signed to the new low level team by Account #3 at the minimum salaries and bonuses... and accounts 1 and 2 are made GM's...

let me ask you is that gutting? or is that just 3 buddies wanting to play together?

You are right we cant agree on anything until you know what the hell we are talking about.... my argument has been on a specific situation, one that led to these rule changes... go figure that out then come back...

Originally posted by PinTBC

Only if your team exceeds 8 levels above the median level of your league. It is a simple rule really, it doesn't single you out, it simply sets an upper limit, and incentivizes being lower than that limit. Just think, you keep saying that your guys are "close to their level", guess how bad they are going to have it if they try to boost.

As I said earlier, It isn't "gutting a team" to allow people to play with their friends. It is simply setting a few rules in place to make sure that there is no reason for people to ruin the pyramid league structure.


I'm not sure if they didn't teach you comprehension in engineer school, the same teacher taught you reading comprehension as taught you mathematical theory or you just blindly like to argue...

I don't care what the rule is, who it effects or how it effects them, the cause of the problem is still there... you allow these people to gut teams and stay in the low level leagues they went to and whatever rules you put in place effect everyone in the game... of course a few bad apples ruin things for everyone, but at least get rid of the bad apples while you are putting these stop gaps in place to prevent it from happening in the future.

Originally posted by PinTBC

EDIT: BOTTOM LINE FIX THE PROBLEM SUCK IT UP AND LOSE SOME FLEX POINT SALES AND BAN THE PEOPLE GUTTING TEAMS, AT MINIMUM TAKE THEIR TEAMS AWAY THEY OWN

ALL CAPS DOES NOTHING FOR YOUR ARGUMENT.. Other than helping you look like a fool.


thanks... so when you in return use caps to highlight the foolish use of caps... that makes you look brilliant? just trying to keep up with you bro...
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xeef
That stated, having a bonus for not having more than 3 guys on a team is the EXACT same thing as getting penalized for having more.... just symantics and point of view.

While I see how some people think it could be considered semantics, let's look at it from the other point of view. I have four players on the same team. From what I've read, I'll continue to see the same XP I've been getting for each of them, where as if I move one of them to another team, I'll start seeing a bonus to my sportsmanship score.

So, if I do nothing, I earn the same as before. Therefore, I'm not being penalized at all - in order to be penalized, I would have to see a reduction.

The real difference is the point of view. As long as you view bonuses as an entitlement (which they aren't), then yes, I can see why you think you're being penalized. But look at the first and fifth definition of bonus here:

Originally posted by http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/bonus

1. something given or paid over and above what is due.
2. a sum of money granted or given to an employee, a returned soldier, etc., in addition to regular pay, usually in appreciation for work done, length of service, accumulated favors, etc.
3. something free, as an extra dividend, given by a corporation to a purchaser of its securities.
4. a premium paid for a loan, contract, etc.
5. something extra or additional given freely: Every purchaser of a pound of coffee received a box of cookies as a bonus.

Bonuses are NOT an entitlement. Not receiving a bonus is not a penalty in any way, shape or form.

Yes, that's a pet peeve of mine, because I see that attitude a lot amongst young people (and even some older ones) in the work place.

Last edited Jun 10, 2008 12:59:41
 
MichN18
offline
Link
 
Can't be bothered to read this thread, but let me say:

Way to go, Bort. Bring the hammer down. Nothing like XP penalties to force gutters and the like to reap what they've sown.
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rmead
How about this...
You have 3 teams... A, B and C

Account #1 is GM of Team A and Team B has players on Team A, B and C
Account #2 is GM of Team C and has players on B and C
Account #3 has players on A and B

Accounts 1 and 2 renegotiate all the contracts of level 15 and above players they control along with Account #3's players and sign them each to huge signing bonuses...

Account #3 when the new teams are released he gets a team... within the hour all 30 or so of the players from Teams A, B and C who had their contracts re-done are now signed to the new low level team by Account #3 at the minimum salaries and bonuses... and accounts 1 and 2 are made GM's...

let me ask you is that gutting? or is that just 3 buddies wanting to play together?

I wouldn't consider that gutting a team. Scamming it's bank accounts, yes. If I were team A, B & C's owners, I'd be screaming as well.

My definition of gutting has been owners who completely strip a team of all players for one reason or another. Some of them do it with good intentions before they sell it back, so as not to "trap" players on a team with a new owner. Some of them do it so they can move the players elsewhere, usually to dominate a different league. I'm sure tehre are other reasons it happens as well.

 
Patricoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
So, no refunds. But now the banned player gets mad. He paid for a product that he no longer gets to use fully. He files a small-claims lawsuit against Bort to get his money back, and then Bort either has to waste his time in a courtroom explaining online football MMORPGs to a bored judge in his 60s who can't get his VCR at home to stop blinking 12:00, or he skips the court date, automatically loses, and has to refund the money anyway.

And that's just for one banned player.

Banning is not a magical cure-all panacea. It closes the door on one problem and opens the door on two more problems. There are still clear-cut cases where it should and must be done, but you'd better make sure it's the sort of situation where the facts are 100% airtight and indisputable. And that's very, very rare.


You would fail at the court case. That's being ejected for reason of your own fault. You can't sue a private school for previous years of tuition where you misbehave and get expelled. You can't sue a bar for the drinks you bought after you got thrown out for being a jerk. You can't sue a game where paid for dozens of players, cheated, and got banned.

You could... effectively... try, but all the owner of this game has to do is prove your offense was worthy of banning and he'd win outright. Open shut case. It's something that should be typically easy to do, even if he **was** using abuse of power.

Your point is generally correct, but I just wanted to note that. And sound important.


 
jaytda4th
offline
Link
 
alright. so does this mean we are going to have a sportsmanship bar.. and when it is at 100 we will get our max xp?.. and will that max xp be more xp than we currently get now..?

is this about how this will be done?
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by g3t 0wn3d n00bs
Originally posted by seven7

we all know that a lv 8 playing against a lv 18 is not fair , bort, is just trying to balance out the leagues and make it fair for everyone , good rule and i hope more fair rules come to players and owners alike.


Hey retard, life isn't fair. Get over it and take away the the XP cap you tards. That's like saying covering Randy Moss isn't fair. You still have to do it. WTF is wrong with people. Randy Moss doesn't loss his experience for playing dumbasses so why should high levels in GLB?


This is to keep Randy Moss playing in Pro Leagues where there is no penalty instead playing on a BBB team to avg. 55yds./rec.

 
MichN18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaytda4th
alright. so does this mean we are going to have a sportsmanship bar.. and when it is at 100 we will get our max xp?.. and will that max xp be more xp than we currently get now..?

is this about how this will be done?


Based on my reading, no one will get any more XP then they are currently getting. You can only get less for being a poor sport.
 
rmead
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
Originally posted by rmead

How about this...
You have 3 teams... A, B and C

Account #1 is GM of Team A and Team B has players on Team A, B and C
Account #2 is GM of Team C and has players on B and C
Account #3 has players on A and B

Accounts 1 and 2 renegotiate all the contracts of level 15 and above players they control along with Account #3's players and sign them each to huge signing bonuses...

Account #3 when the new teams are released he gets a team... within the hour all 30 or so of the players from Teams A, B and C who had their contracts re-done are now signed to the new low level team by Account #3 at the minimum salaries and bonuses... and accounts 1 and 2 are made GM's...

let me ask you is that gutting? or is that just 3 buddies wanting to play together?

I wouldn't consider that gutting a team. Scamming it's bank accounts, yes. If I were team A, B & C's owners, I'd be screaming as well.

My definition of gutting has been owners who completely strip a team of all players for one reason or another. Some of them do it with good intentions before they sell it back, so as not to "trap" players on a team with a new owner. Some of them do it so they can move the players elsewhere, usually to dominate a different league. I'm sure tehre are other reasons it happens as well.



I guess i can agree that it happens other ways but how anyone could justify the senario above is beyond me, its like saying cancer isn't a bad thing look at all the research jobs it supports...

BTW when Bort decides to state in public that all the players involved have had there wallets lowered to $5 and the owner is "getting a nasty PM from me for wasting my time" I think that pretty much nails that it is indeed gutting... yet team remains in play and around double the level of 28 of the 32 teams in its division.
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Favre4Ever
Originally posted by demonicangel

Originally posted by g3t 0wn3d n00bs


Oh well, more and more non payers will start to play and this game will be no more. I'm kinda happy. Bort said it the best. Karma is a bitch.


You really think that this will only intice non paying members to play? Lets put it this way. Like I mentioned earlier I have spent well over a 100 dollars last season on this game. If I had just started playing this game, there is no way in hell I would spend that much cash to play a game I get pulverized.

I bet there are many with that same train of thought out there. Give the players a chance to win and have fun, and they will get more money from players waiting for there chance.


Chance to win..?

My team just had two 15-1 teams enter our conference. Don't tell me that we have a fair shot at the title. The only thing we have a fair shot at is getting our asses handed to us.


Weren't those teams from lower levels... once they start playing at your level they will probably become middle o the pack!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.