I have an idea. Let the testers review game data only, not builds. Let them watch the replay of the game. Let them send you notes on what they see. You could have anyone test or review that data and relay what they see to you. Keep build data away from testers. Only stats and replays.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
SteelCity Mafia
offline
offline
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.
I don't understand. Why would they want free points if they give up their teams and whatnot? Are they going to still be playing? If so, same informationl issue exists, although perhaps of limited time span.
But I don't care who they are, I just want to have the chance to learn what they may have learned.
That's fair. Tester's blog. TPat and others, maybe elected others, write about what is found.
Trust is broken, don't think a blog will solve the problem.
LOL @ testers blog. Then you only get told what they want you to know. And the testers will still have more knowledge about what was tested. Terrible idea tbh.
You have to make it viewable to all. And if exploits happen, find a way to fix them. In the long run, it's better for the game anyhow if all exploits get closed off.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.
I don't understand. Why would they want free points if they give up their teams and whatnot? Are they going to still be playing? If so, same informationl issue exists, although perhaps of limited time span.
But I don't care who they are, I just want to have the chance to learn what they may have learned.
That's fair. Tester's blog. TPat and others, maybe elected others, write about what is found.
Trust is broken, don't think a blog will solve the problem.
LOL @ testers blog. Then you only get told what they want you to know. And the testers will still have more knowledge about what was tested. Terrible idea tbh.
You have to make it viewable to all. And if exploits happen, find a way to fix them. In the long run, it's better for the game anyhow if all exploits get closed off.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Animalmother
What about a sign up for the server your using already?
That'll be $1000 please.
What about a sign up for the server your using already?
That'll be $1000 please.
VietCampo
offline
offline
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
77racing
offline
offline
Originally posted by byrongame21
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by Saris
One solution might be to just quarantine all of the testers into one league, like oh I don't know Canada. They can own teams and players but they just have to play in Canada. I seriously doubt the loldot crowd would mind if there were testers on their servers.
this.
or create a whole new league with different tier in levels
There's a solution. A damn good one at that.
Agreed move the testers /cheaters to the moon league
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by Saris
One solution might be to just quarantine all of the testers into one league, like oh I don't know Canada. They can own teams and players but they just have to play in Canada. I seriously doubt the loldot crowd would mind if there were testers on their servers.

this.
or create a whole new league with different tier in levels
There's a solution. A damn good one at that.
Agreed move the testers /cheaters to the moon league
ress5609
offline
offline
Originally posted by atingwald
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by atingwald
so you are saying that he built this random generating program for all these teams, but he couldn't do it for say 100 teams of his own... with special builds built in to each of those 100 teams??
Those 100 teams could play each other over and over on a random loop, and the statistical anomalies could not be determined thru statistical analysis??? So a computer is slower than the humans?? LOL
I find that very hard to believe.... in 100 teams, you could generate millions upon millions of matchups, and the oddities would expose themselves in two weeks, guaranteed.... every two weeks, you can adjust those 100 teams, and that would lead to new tests...
how long do you think a game truly lasts??? with a random generator, it takes minutes at most... you can run millions of games in two weeks....
I think you misunderstand what the "easier said than done part" is. You're assuming that all bugs can be found through statistical analysis. Unfortunately, that is not the case. There's no guarantee that a particular bug will show up as a statistical anomaly, and further more writing the logic in code to detect any possible bug would take longer than just sitting down and watching every single play of every single sim.
team A plays team B 100 times... results should be pretty similar over 100 games...
team C plays team B 100 times.. again, these results should be pretty similar over those 100 games
team A has guys with 20 points more confidence than team C... wouldn't you be able to see a statistical difference??
you don't have to write that into code... you can print out data and see the % difference....
The problem is that example is so far over simplified that it doesn't just work that way.
For example, the results of each game are already stored. Comparing all of those results together isn't going to tell you why the TE sometimes runs the wrong direction in the middle of a play. You might be able to see where it happens but it doesn't tell you why.
Additionally if the coordinates of that TE are still within an acceptable area of movement (i.e. the field), then it wouldn't show up as an anomaly. So then you'd have to setup a list of parameters for every scenario.
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by atingwald
so you are saying that he built this random generating program for all these teams, but he couldn't do it for say 100 teams of his own... with special builds built in to each of those 100 teams??
Those 100 teams could play each other over and over on a random loop, and the statistical anomalies could not be determined thru statistical analysis??? So a computer is slower than the humans?? LOL
I find that very hard to believe.... in 100 teams, you could generate millions upon millions of matchups, and the oddities would expose themselves in two weeks, guaranteed.... every two weeks, you can adjust those 100 teams, and that would lead to new tests...
how long do you think a game truly lasts??? with a random generator, it takes minutes at most... you can run millions of games in two weeks....
I think you misunderstand what the "easier said than done part" is. You're assuming that all bugs can be found through statistical analysis. Unfortunately, that is not the case. There's no guarantee that a particular bug will show up as a statistical anomaly, and further more writing the logic in code to detect any possible bug would take longer than just sitting down and watching every single play of every single sim.
team A plays team B 100 times... results should be pretty similar over 100 games...
team C plays team B 100 times.. again, these results should be pretty similar over those 100 games
team A has guys with 20 points more confidence than team C... wouldn't you be able to see a statistical difference??
you don't have to write that into code... you can print out data and see the % difference....
The problem is that example is so far over simplified that it doesn't just work that way.
For example, the results of each game are already stored. Comparing all of those results together isn't going to tell you why the TE sometimes runs the wrong direction in the middle of a play. You might be able to see where it happens but it doesn't tell you why.
Additionally if the coordinates of that TE are still within an acceptable area of movement (i.e. the field), then it wouldn't show up as an anomaly. So then you'd have to setup a list of parameters for every scenario.
byrongame21
offline
offline
Originally posted by kimimar0
Make every owner a tester immediately or this is complete bs.
That seems kind of impossible to say the least
Make every owner a tester immediately or this is complete bs.
That seems kind of impossible to say the least
cbarge
offline
offline
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nobody wanted Bob Dole in office.
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nobody wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nuge20
offline
offline
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
alright
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
alright
VietCampo
offline
offline
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nobody wanted Bob Dole in office.
i did.
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nobody wanted Bob Dole in office.
i did.
Krunchy
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
There will not be an open public test server for everyone to test with willy-nilly. Even ignoring exploit-city problems, the live site uses over 30 servers just to run the website, and there are separate sim servers as well. I'd need the same to support a test server open to the public, and there is no way we have the resources for that. Besides, it's far easier to deal with focused reports from a small group of testers than 50,000 people screaming about the game they just ran where the RB went left instead of right.
Then give me my money back, shyster. I didn't pay so you and your buddies can have your own set or rules and advantages.
There will not be an open public test server for everyone to test with willy-nilly. Even ignoring exploit-city problems, the live site uses over 30 servers just to run the website, and there are separate sim servers as well. I'd need the same to support a test server open to the public, and there is no way we have the resources for that. Besides, it's far easier to deal with focused reports from a small group of testers than 50,000 people screaming about the game they just ran where the RB went left instead of right.
Then give me my money back, shyster. I didn't pay so you and your buddies can have your own set or rules and advantages.
cbarge
offline
offline
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nobody wanted Bob Dole in office.
i did.
Yep, nobody.
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Viet
I want my flex back.
Are you a democrat, you sound like a democrat
depends, i wanted Bob Dole in office.
Nobody wanted Bob Dole in office.
i did.
Yep, nobody.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























