User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
too many posts to read, im going to bed lol
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
It's reprehensible that the only time an effort is made to do the right things is made only after some scandal has occured, some information has leaked that wasnt meant to be.

And this habit will only continue it seems because there's a history of it being done like that, and not done upright, from the get-go, transparently.

Just more mollifying spin-doctoring, patting on the head, "yes, run along now, and play".


that's the way of the world....get used to it if you're untraveled as far as age goes...
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
You decide to take 3 linebackers on your team and set them all at some control stat-line. Then you give them 20 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 20 confidence, 12 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 12 trash talk and go through 2 more sims.

You've just figured out the relative worth of confidence and trash talk for LB's as well as the effect confidence has on trash talk. And you did it in 2 days without having to spend a single SP of your players.


I think what I'm hearing from the testers is that that's not how the testing process works, and what I've been hearing from Bort is that we'll soon have more insight into how testing does work.

I'm in favor of giving the whole process a chance, and giving Bort a chance to show us in an orderly fashion sometime in the next coupla days instead of trying to get dribs and drabs of info by throwing out strawmans of what we don't want to be happening.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by superman8456

Also, if it was never supposed to be secret, you should have no problem giving me a list of testers/tests done...

Didn't he say he was almost done with getting ready to do this?

It is understandable that the comment was missed by some amidst the last 150 pages.

Or, or, other idea. What if people informed themselves before posting?


without a search function, GLBers are forced to inform themselves via posting.


Really, so you can't search for Bort's posts?
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer

Nothing so sinister. Apparently cowtesticles is bothered by people posting who only have one player.


Well, cowtesticles is being silly then. Everyone has a right to an opinion.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 22:59:32
 
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by superman8456





Also, if it was never supposed to be secret, you should have no problem giving me a list of testers/tests done...


Didn't he say he was almost done with getting ready to do this?


It is understandable that the comment was missed by some amidst the last 150 pages.



Or, or, other idea. What if people informed themselves before posting?


Or, or, you're insane


BUUUURN!
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
I have no idea what is going on in this thread

But still I don't give a fuck regardless

+1

Oh, no post counts?



Knowledge not required, just an opinion.
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
I'm already planning my next scandal to be wrought with disillusions, propaganda, and a parrot mob. Just need to scrounge around for a potential weakness
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
I have no idea what is going on


Knew that already
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Originally posted by GG

It's reprehensible that the only time an effort is made to do the right things is made only after some scandal has occured, some information has leaked that wasnt meant to be.

And this habit will only continue it seems because there's a history of it being done like that, and not done upright, from the get-go, transparently.

Just more mollifying spin-doctoring, patting on the head, "yes, run along now, and play".


that's the way of the world....get used to it if you're untraveled as far as age goes...


Is that why the world is fucked up then? All the companies and govts who operate like this are proof why it doesnt work.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Sorry for the long post, Azure I assume this is the one I missed?

OK from what I'm reading, your saying that a lot of SAs are regarded to be broken/underpowered/useless?
And your saying that by having the access to test this I could know it earlier than anyone with out that access?

As such I could avoid wasting SP in it?

Is that the issue or did I miss something? I'll assume it is and if not let me know.

Well the only answer to that is Yes, absolutely, I would have the information that SA "X" is broken/underpowered/useless etc.

Because of the structure of testing that information would be public knowledge To other Testers and Bort himself, (Ok not a good use of 'Public' but its not possible that ONLY I would know)
Otherwise the test wouldnt take place.

By bringing this to light, it would bring it to the stage of requiring a fix, so what I would now know is SA "X" was poor and is probably getting better at some point.

When where and how it improves I wouldnt know until bort announces it on the Changelog.

There is no way to defend that there is not some element of me having advanced warning there.

But, for the test to occur, it would really need to be a known bug, and one thats heavily reported already, OR a bug in something that has not been released into the Live site.

So for me personally, the benefit gained from Fixing the SA for everyone outweighs the possibility of prior knowledge.

I understand that some people will not agree with this point of view.


While i'm not going to read all of these pages but have read more than a few in the last day , then this is a problem. Why not just REMOVE the non working SA's so people can stop wasting money by using sp's in them UNTIL they are fixed. Because honestly the community itself knows how long it takes to fix things and as for reporting bugs ? we also know how long it ever gets around to being done.

Bottom line is the game needs a wipe with all fixes installed up to that point and use a better system in making future fixes.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Not exactly. The issue is you can test that SA and find out whether it is actually useless. I'll re-iterate my earlier example as I remember it.

You decide to take 3 linebackers on your team and set them all at some control stat-line. Then you give them 20 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 20 confidence, 12 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 12 trash talk and go through 2 more sims.

You've just figured out the relative worth of confidence and trash talk for LB's as well as the effect confidence has on trash talk. And you did it in 2 days without having to spend a single SP of your players.



The justification for that type of test would be pretty hard to make though, it falls under "What is the best build type" and thats not what testing is for.

I could test as I said, to see if it works as intended or not.
But seeing what combination of build best supports a SA, nope that doesnt roll.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

You decide to take 3 linebackers on your team and set them all at some control stat-line. Then you give them 20 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 20 confidence, 12 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 12 trash talk and go through 2 more sims.

You've just figured out the relative worth of confidence and trash talk for LB's as well as the effect confidence has on trash talk. And you did it in 2 days without having to spend a single SP of your players.


I think what I'm hearing from the testers is that that's not how the testing process works, and what I've been hearing from Bort is that we'll soon have more insight into how testing does work.

I'm in favor of giving the whole process a chance, and giving Bort a chance to show us in an orderly fashion sometime in the next coupla days instead of trying to get dribs and drabs of info by throwing out strawmans of what we don't want to be happening.


Well i've heard from testers via PM that they can change stats at will however they'd like (though this only started like 4 days ago, before then they had a fixed 40 levels worth of SP to allot) and set games up with each other at multiple sim times per day.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Originally posted by GG


It's reprehensible that the only time an effort is made to do the right things is made only after some scandal has occured, some information has leaked that wasnt meant to be.

And this habit will only continue it seems because there's a history of it being done like that, and not done upright, from the get-go, transparently.

Just more mollifying spin-doctoring, patting on the head, "yes, run along now, and play".


that's the way of the world....get used to it if you're untraveled as far as age goes...


Is that why the world is fucked up then? All the companies and govts who operate like this are proof why it doesnt work.


dude look at the turmoil in the world....
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Not exactly. The issue is you can test that SA and find out whether it is actually useless. I'll re-iterate my earlier example as I remember it.

You decide to take 3 linebackers on your team and set them all at some control stat-line. Then you give them 20 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 20 confidence, 12 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 12 trash talk and go through 2 more sims.

You've just figured out the relative worth of confidence and trash talk for LB's as well as the effect confidence has on trash talk. And you did it in 2 days without having to spend a single SP of your players.



The justification for that type of test would be pretty hard to make though, it falls under "What is the best build type" and thats not what testing is for.

I could test as I said, to see if it works as intended or not.
But seeing what combination of build best supports a SA, nope that doesnt roll.


Congratulations, you just provided plenty of justification. Seeing whether trash talk actually does something, whether confidence does, and whether the two work in concert (because they are supposed to be linked in SOME fashion) is doing just what you said.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.