Originally posted by rmead
Originally posted by PinTBC
You are correct, except that estimation is a statistical method for predicting the outcome of an event based on any legitimate history (boosting from past seasons). If in previous seasons 60% of the people boosted, then you can predict that a number close to that will do the same this season. It isn't an exact number, but it is far from impossible to get an idea of what might happen.
You are correct in your copy of the definition of estimation but when you have no "legitimate history" to base the estimate on the definition changes to "pulling numbers out of your ass" but again he numbers of who it effects isn't important, the idea that instead of fixing the problem they are pandering these supposed changes that will fix the result of the problem, which it wont even accomplish that.... its like laws that lock people up for the same amount of time for having 1 joint as a pound... in the end the dealer still makes all the money
Sorry, but I didn't copy that definition. I am an Engineer and I use statistics and math every single day in my job. We have had two full seasons, and while that isn't a wealth of history, it is more than enough to use to predict how people can be expected to use their boosts. Granted each and every season, those predictions will get closer to the actuals.
Your bit about getting locked up for one join or a pound isn't even a good analogy. A better one would be that instead of locking you up, they have decided that anyojne caught with a joint (more than 8 levels over median) gets taxed. That tax is relegated on a joint by joint basis though, so if you have one, or one hundered, you still pay the same tax per joint (same penalties for each player over 8 levels above the norm).
Originally posted by PinTBC
See we disagree here. It is the rules, or the actual lack of rules that was exactly the problem. There was NOTHING stopping Joe Schmoe from USA Pro from selling his team and taking all his players to a friend's BBB team. That isn't even gutting. If he is selling the team, then I would hope he would allow anyone that wished to leave, the ability to do so. As long as he didn't give them syonara bonuses like at least one guy did, then he is doing nothing wrong.
With Bort's new rule though, it makes it MUCH less likely that will happen. These rules don't harm those "honest owners" you claim to be sticking up for. They actually protect them from someone wholesale bringing in higher level talent from a higher level league.
Originally posted by Novus
Which is why it's funny that RMead is making so much noise about it anyway.
Originally posted by rmead
they don't accomplish that either... when a team (or in the case in AA #3 -- 3 teams) are gutted and those high level players all come into a NEW low level league and you allow it to happen, you can't impose rules after that also penalize the owners who simply went out and recruited in full compliance with not only the established rules, but the un-written "spirit of the game" rules everyone is so fond of talking about.
Let me repeat that.... its not the rules themselves or even the effect of them, its the fact that owners in the leagues who went out and recruited equal level talent to compete where these asshats have brought stacked teams from gutted teams and/or some lame ass who has 45 boosted/custom fitted high level characters are being PENALIZED TO THE SAME DEGREE as the dicks who caused the problem.
Doesn't matter the rule or the effect, its that honest owners are being lumped in with the assholes.I'm willing to bet that you and I couldn't agree on what the term Gutting means. I'd be willing to bet that it would be VERY difficult to get the people on this bulletin board to agree. If I own a USA Pro team, with 20 of my players, and 10 more of my friend's players on it, and I decide I don't wish to expend the energy or money to keep running the team, is it gutting to explain what is going on to my players, and release those who wish it before I sell the team back to the CPU?
I don't believe it is. Does it make it gutting if I later decide to drag all my players from USA Pro down to my Buddy's team in Africa A? No, it could be something as simple as friends wishing to play together.
With the rules Bort has defined set in place, my players from USA Pro are probably not going to end up in the low level league, or they will take a bunch of penalties. It stops the people you like to keep whining about, and it does it simply so it is easy to follow.
By the way, if you are one of the owners who "recruited nearly equal level talent" then good for you, your team has a heck of advantage over the rest of the league, and those teams you expressly hate, are going to have many of the same problems you will.
Originally posted by PinTBC
I do have experience, and I do have a stake in this issue, and I think Bort's rules are easy to live with, and might even go a VERY long way to removing the "Beat on Newbie" mentality that seems to be permeating his game. If you are 8 levels above your average competition, you really don't have anything coherent to whine about. So don't boost, or be careful with your boosts early in the season. Big deal.
Originally posted by rmead
As i said above i didn't recruit to try and "Beat on Newbie" i recruited to be competitive... the day i got my team in a brand new lowest level African league, there were already not 1.... but 2 stacked level 15 teams that would compete and win in many Pro league conferences... so because i worked my ass off and recruited guys of equal level, none of which i new before the off season began by the way, I am being lumped into these supposed fixes because i successfully put a team together that comes CLOSE to matching these guys...Only if your team exceeds 8 levels above the median level of your league. It is a simple rule really, it doesn't single you out, it simply sets an upper limit, and incentivizes being lower than that limit. Just think, you keep saying that your guys are "close to their level", guess how bad they are going to have it if they try to boost.
Originally posted by rmead
EDIT: BOTTOM LINE FIX THE PROBLEM SUCK IT UP AND LOSE SOME FLEX POINT SALES AND BAN THE PEOPLE GUTTING TEAMS, AT MINIMUM TAKE THEIR TEAMS AWAY THEY OWN
As I said earlier, It isn't "gutting a team" to allow people to play with their friends. It is simply setting a few rules in place to make sure that there is no reason for people to ruin the pyramid league structure.
ALL CAPS DOES NOTHING FOR YOUR ARGUMENT.. Other than helping you look like a fool.
PinTBC