Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
No, but enough to say "Oh wow, this skill is more effective when this stat it high, and that REALLY makes a big difference" is it not?
Yeah because without testing I would have no idea if 0 in a SA was better or worse than 10 in a SA.
Try using common sense please. The test conditions would not for example tell me that the SP invested in moving the SA were any more or less effective than if they were invested anywhere else, nor will it tell me if it consistently over poweres 'Build type X' etc.
I am posting to help spread some understanding, and ease concerns, as no one else really seemed to want to be the one to take all the stick.
You have any idea how many SA's are held in common knowledge to be all but useless? You want to be the guy who spends 3 seasons worth of SP to get a 4th level SA up to 10 to test it, thus makeing your player useless if it doesn't work out?
How about getting your confidence up to 80 to test it in conjunction with an SA that is rumored to be a function of confidence, then trying it without the confidence to gauge the difference?
I wrote this whole thing up when you were here before but you conveniently avoided answering. The "I already know everything about GLB so I couldn't learn anything from rapid fire tests with my chocie of parameters" defense doesn't fly.
Sorry for the long post, Azure I assume this is the one I missed?
OK from what I'm reading, your saying that a lot of SAs are regarded to be broken/underpowered/useless?
And your saying that by having the access to test this I could know it earlier than anyone with out that access?
As such I could avoid wasting SP in it?
Is that the issue or did I miss something? I'll assume it is and if not let me know.
Well the only answer to that is Yes, absolutely, I would have the information that SA "X" is broken/underpowered/useless etc.
Because of the structure of testing that information would be public knowledge To other Testers and Bort himself, (Ok not a good use of 'Public' but its not possible that ONLY I would know)
Otherwise the test wouldnt take place.
By bringing this to light, it would bring it to the stage of requiring a fix, so what I would now know is SA "X" was poor and is probably getting better at some point.
When where and how it improves I wouldnt know until bort announces it on the Changelog.
There is no way to defend that there is not some element of me having advanced warning there.
But, for the test to occur, it would really need to be a known bug, and one thats heavily reported already, OR a bug in something that has not been released into the Live site.
So for me personally, the benefit gained from Fixing the SA for everyone outweighs the possibility of prior knowledge.
I understand that some people will not agree with this point of view.
Not exactly. The issue is you can test that SA and find out whether it is actually useless. I'll re-iterate my earlier example as I remember it.
You decide to take 3 linebackers on your team and set them all at some control stat-line. Then you give them 20 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 0 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 20 confidence, 12 trash talk. Go through 2 sims. Then give them 90 confidence, 12 trash talk and go through 2 more sims.
You've just figured out the relative worth of confidence and trash talk for LB's as well as the effect confidence has on trash talk. And you did it in 2 days without having to spend a single SP of your players.