User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
okay, but that's partially what i'm getting at. the fact that mods have insider information that they're not supposed to communicate is both halves of the problem:
- why are a select few players given insider information?
- why is there also a tradition of them keeping that insider information secret?

Like I said to AD, it depends on your definition of inside information. In regards to sim information that isn't public knowledge, no ones knows that except Bort, and possibly Thorn now. Mods, having access to Bort via PM and the mod forum, may know something sooner than the general public (not often), or be able to get a quicker response to an issue, but nothing more. Until now. Which is the issue, of course.


okay, but it hardly needs to be a qualitative issue at all.

maybe it's surprising to some people, but GLB is hardly a unique business. i'd suggest looking at how countless other businesses have sailed right past these hurdles.

if you want to shore up the test server so none of this is even slightly an issue, i'd be happy to draw up a double-blind schema. it's pathetically simple and has been used in scientific inquiry for centuries.

again, there's no reason why this even needs to be an issue at all, providing bort is willing to have an admin devote some hours to coordinating the testing (as opposed to what seems to be the current setup of just having people randomly have at).
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


Mike are you always under supervision while in there? What's to say that another tester doesn't test it at 0 then 1 all the way to 11 and see if this SA is worthwhile at higher levels. Say a tester has a Power HB and he wants to know how effective one of the Power SAs is, is it not out of the realm of possibility that he could test it to see without notifying Bort or any of you? That's why people are worried then the people saying they received insider info(whether it be true or not) set them off. BTW don't give me the sim is SOOO different so it wouldn't help them BS. I am sorry but if the sim is SO different that you can't compare the results then there is no reason to test anything that might be broken on GLB as you have changed too many variables and testing wouldn't prove that something does or doesn't work if the test sim is SO different than the normal sim. It's Science 101 that if you change too many variables, you won't get reliable results.



Just in case you missed this Mr. Rogers.



(Cut a lot out of the quote, to keep it neat)

All the tests are reviewable, and its impossible to 'Hide' something.
Its possible that over a long period of time, you could maybe sneak a bit of that type of test in here or there and hope no one notices.

But the difficulty is that Bort controls the background rules, and he changes them based on what he wants tested.

You would therefore need to test it all as quickly as possible to get anything close to useful data for THAT type of testing.

Testing times are controlled, and it would be obvious that someone was doing something wrong.

I know that nobody has any reason to believe any of this, but I hope that those who know me feel a little more comfortable after all the info I have given out.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
sure, but that's a qualitative defense... along the lines of claiming that insider knowledge from the test server must not be all that problematic if the testers aren't dominating their leagues.

My point was that, until now, mods haven't ever been privy to what I consider inside information (inner workings of the sim).


inner workings of the sim, maybe... but crucial information about the timing of nerfs/etc that drastically effect builds/tactics? yes.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
All this from mods and testers in this thread is just spin-doctoring and trying to mop up aisle three.

Maybe it can deceive or convince a bunch of people, but a lot see thru it all. It's BS.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 22:39:57
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
again, there's no reason why this even needs to be an issue at all, providing bort is willing to have an admin devote some hours to coordinating the testing (as opposed to what seems to be the current setup of just having people randomly have at).

This. Infinitely, emphatically, a thousand times this.

You've just described my main frustration with being a moderator, and a large reason of why I stepped down.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
inner workings of the sim, maybe... but crucial information about the timing of nerfs/etc that drastically effect builds/tactics? yes.

Not in my experience. Bort may say that something is being addressed in a future update in response to a query, but nothing very explicit/specific.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
again, there's no reason why this even needs to be an issue at all, providing bort is willing to have an admin devote some hours to coordinating the testing (as opposed to what seems to be the current setup of just having people randomly have at).

This. Infinitely, emphatically, a thousand times this.
You've just described my main frustration with being a moderator, and a large reason of why I stepped down.


ha, i think you just talked your way up to a 20% cut.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
All this from mods and testers in this thread is just spin-doctoring and trying to mop up aisle three.

Maybe it can deceive or convince a bunch of people, but a lot see thru it all. It's BS.


why you so worked up?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
inner workings of the sim, maybe... but crucial information about the timing of nerfs/etc that drastically effect builds/tactics? yes.

Not in my experience. Bort may say that something is being addressed in a future update in response to a query, but nothing very explicit/specific.


hmmm... i must be on a different information path than you. it seems a lot of definitive/timely information that comes my way is legitimized by a Moderator Stamp of Approval™.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by jrry32



Mike are you always under supervision while in there? What's to say that another tester doesn't test it at 0 then 1 all the way to 11 and see if this SA is worthwhile at higher levels. Say a tester has a Power HB and he wants to know how effective one of the Power SAs is, is it not out of the realm of possibility that he could test it to see without notifying Bort or any of you? That's why people are worried then the people saying they received insider info(whether it be true or not) set them off. BTW don't give me the sim is SOOO different so it wouldn't help them BS. I am sorry but if the sim is SO different that you can't compare the results then there is no reason to test anything that might be broken on GLB as you have changed too many variables and testing wouldn't prove that something does or doesn't work if the test sim is SO different than the normal sim. It's Science 101 that if you change too many variables, you won't get reliable results.



Just in case you missed this Mr. Rogers.



(Cut a lot out of the quote, to keep it neat)

All the tests are reviewable, and its impossible to 'Hide' something.
Its possible that over a long period of time, you could maybe sneak a bit of that type of test in here or there and hope no one notices.

But the difficulty is that Bort controls the background rules, and he changes them based on what he wants tested.

You would therefore need to test it all as quickly as possible to get anything close to useful data for THAT type of testing.

Testing times are controlled, and it would be obvious that someone was doing something wrong.

I know that nobody has any reason to believe any of this, but I hope that those who know me feel a little more comfortable after all the info I have given out.


Actually you would only truly need 1 test if you were trying to see how strong a SA is at 10.(I know it wouldn't be exact since you aren't comparing it to anything but if it's as strong as you want it to be, I figure they'll be able to tell) Also Bort has already admitted to losing/getting rid of old data so it's feasible that something like that could slip by him. These are all assumptions of course but they are a little worrisome.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 22:43:07
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
(stamina is pointless)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by Catullus 16

inner workings of the sim, maybe... but crucial information about the timing of nerfs/etc that drastically effect builds/tactics? yes.

Not in my experience. Bort may say that something is being addressed in a future update in response to a query, but nothing very explicit/specific.


hmmm... i must be on a different information path than you. it seems a lot of definitive/timely information that comes my way is legitimized by a Moderator Stamp of Approval™.


People like to seem in control when they aren't. This is not news.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
hmmm... i must be on a different information path than you. it seems a lot of definitive/timely information that comes my way is legitimized by a Moderator Stamp of Approval™.

That may well be. I'm not the favored son around these parts, as it were.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
(stamina is pointless)


Shhh don't tell SI!
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by Asheme


Originally posted by Catullus 16


inner workings of the sim, maybe... but crucial information about the timing of nerfs/etc that drastically effect builds/tactics? yes.

Not in my experience. Bort may say that something is being addressed in a future update in response to a query, but nothing very explicit/specific.


hmmm... i must be on a different information path than you. it seems a lot of definitive/timely information that comes my way is legitimized by a Moderator Stamp of Approval™.


People like to seem in control when they aren't. This is not news.


Beat Bastard Sons next time....(to avoid conspiracy theories)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.