User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by Mike Rogers



Originally posted by cowtesticles2001




Hey Mike...

so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?


Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)

Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.


if you can tell it is working as intended you have more knowledge than we do

obviously you won't have a % on how much more effective it is, how the hell would you come to that anyway? no one is accusing testers of developing statistical conclusions


Err what, these ambush attempt are getting steadily worse and worse.

Did you really just accuse a Tester of Testing???

Knowing that something works is more knowledge than avaialble to the Public at large?

If you have a problem with a Tester taking a Users assertion that a SA is broken, testing it, and then making the findings public then your basically asking for a continually broken SA to go untested until Bort happens to notice a post in Bugs???

Sorry I came into this thread to help stop some of the Bs rumours flying around, and stop people pretending to be Testors from maliciously damaging others builds by spreading misinformation.
But posts like this will be ignored from now on, its a losing battle, with people who obvious care nothing for the game.


Mike are you always under supervision while in there? What's to say that another tester doesn't test it at 0 then 1 all the way to 11 and see if this SA is worthwhile at higher levels. Say a tester has a Power HB and he wants to know how effective one of the Power SAs is, is it not out of the realm of possibility that he could test it to see without notifying Bort or any of you? That's why people are worried then the people saying they received insider info(whether it be true or not) set them off. BTW don't give me the sim is SOOO different so it wouldn't help them BS. I am sorry but if the sim is SO different that you can't compare the results then there is no reason to test anything that might be broken on GLB as you have changed too many variables and testing wouldn't prove that something does or doesn't work if the test sim is SO different than the normal sim. It's Science 101 that if you change too many variables, you won't get reliable results.



Just in case you missed this Mr. Rogers.

 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
:ignores Azure:
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16

right. so i'm going to stick with my original response...

But I maintain that they don't communicate insider information (mods, that is), at least not with admin knowledge (it's happened, and mods duly reprimanded).



It *ALWAYS* happens. There has never been an issue I can think of where there weren't non-mods aware of what was going on almost as soon as the mods were.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
right. so i'm going to stick with my original response...

But I maintain that they don't communicate insider information (mods, that is), at least not with admin knowledge (it's happened, and mods duly reprimanded).


okay, but that's partially what i'm getting at. the fact that mods have insider information that they're not supposed to communicate is both halves of the problem:
- why are a select few players given insider information?
- why is there also a tradition of them keeping that insider information secret?

put differently, why are there elite groups (mods and now testers) that are given this unfair advantage?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Originally posted by Mike Rogers



Originally posted by cowtesticles2001




Hey Mike...

so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?


Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)

Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.


No, but enough to say "Oh wow, this skill is more effective when this stat it high, and that REALLY makes a big difference" is it not?


Yeah because without testing I would have no idea if 0 in a SA was better or worse than 10 in a SA.

Try using common sense please. The test conditions would not for example tell me that the SP invested in moving the SA were any more or less effective than if they were invested anywhere else, nor will it tell me if it consistently over poweres 'Build type X' etc.

I am posting to help spread some understanding, and ease concerns, as no one else really seemed to want to be the one to take all the stick.


You have any idea how many SA's are held in common knowledge to be all but useless? You want to be the guy who spends 3 seasons worth of SP to get a 4th level SA up to 10 to test it, thus makeing your player useless if it doesn't work out?

How about getting your confidence up to 80 to test it in conjunction with an SA that is rumored to be a function of confidence, then trying it without the confidence to gauge the difference?

I wrote this whole thing up when you were here before but you conveniently avoided answering. The "I already know everything about GLB so I couldn't learn anything from rapid fire tests with my chocie of parameters" defense doesn't fly.


 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
It *ALWAYS* happens. There has never been an issue I can think of where there weren't non-mods aware of what was going on almost as soon as the mods were.

Depends on your definition of inside information, I suppose.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Originally posted by cowtesticles2001



If the test server had been around for 2 seasons I can see there being a problem....when was the first public tester allowed in?

Once that is put out there and some kind of official post put out this issue can be put to rest....

BORT YOU'RE THE MAN!!! BTW....




User Name: Bort
Signed Up: Jan 28, 2009 20:07:57
Last Action: Feb 15, 2009 22:00:34
Admin User
Send Message | Add to Friends
If you need customer support, please
submit it through the Customer Support Form



Other then Admins/Mods


Pretty sure the next couple of days a few people were granted access, I was one of the very first to go on it, I think, probably only because i had more free time than most right now being back in hospital,

Signed Up: Jan 29, 2009 00:11:19

^^^ Thats the earliest None Admin I can find right now.

What I dont know is if the sign up date is when they first entered the site or not, as It was a preassigned, by invite only type situation. that might just be when the invite was sent, have to ask Bort.

My reason for posting Borts start date, was NO ONE signed up before he did.



Sorry to hear you're back in the hospital....

There was a 5 day window for people to test things before day 40 games....not saying anyone abused the test servers or anything....but the possibility was there for a hardcore dot watcher correct?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
:ignores Azure:


FUCK YOU TOO KENNY IM GONNA GO INTO ALL YOUR PLAYERS LOOKING FOR TEAM THREADS AND CONVINCE PEOPLE THAT YOURE A "DRESSING" ROOM CANCER

o wait thats you
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GG

Me a troll? Have I ever been a troll? I post my honest opinion always.


I've seen the term "filibuster" thrown at you, which is usually quite accurate. As for a troll? Meh.


filibuster is more strictly trying to prevent a course of action from occuring by endlessly debating. My endless debates are just because people debate back and it becomes like a "no it isnt", "yes it is" thing. Things that go around in circles and neither party really likes. If I suggest or debate or discuss anything it is TO GET a course of action happening....proactive, admin pulling their fingers out and doing something to fix something.

I give up a lot of the time suggesting stuff because so little ever gets done and often admin dont see the pitfalls ahead in the specific bad decisions they make. Im not saying im perfect and see all. But a lot of stuff they decide on----game wise or otherwise, are more often bad decisions than good. And MANY people have made endless good suggestions and urgings that get fobbed off.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
okay, but that's partially what i'm getting at. the fact that mods have insider information that they're not supposed to communicate is both halves of the problem:
- why are a select few players given insider information?
- why is there also a tradition of them keeping that insider information secret?

Like I said to AD, it depends on your definition of inside information. In regards to sim information that isn't public knowledge, no ones knows that except Bort, and possibly Thorn now. Mods, having access to Bort via PM and the mod forum, may know something sooner than the general public (not often), or be able to get a quicker response to an issue, but nothing more. Until now. Which is the issue, of course.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
It *ALWAYS* happens. There has never been an issue I can think of where there weren't non-mods aware of what was going on almost as soon as the mods were.

Depends on your definition of inside information, I suppose.


sure, but that's a qualitative defense... along the lines of claiming that insider knowledge from the test server must not be all that problematic if the testers aren't dominating their leagues.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
FUCK YOU TOO KENNY IM GONNA GO INTO ALL YOUR PLAYERS LOOKING FOR TEAM THREADS AND CONVINCE PEOPLE THAT YOURE A "DRESSING" ROOM CANCER

o wait thats you

Did that work btw?
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Replying to someone's posts is the best way to let them know you're ignoring them
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
sure, but that's a qualitative defense... along the lines of claiming that insider knowledge from the test server must not be all that problematic if the testers aren't dominating their leagues.

My point was that, until now, mods haven't ever been privy to what I consider inside information (inner workings of the sim).
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Replying to someone's posts is the best way to let them know you're ignoring them

Right. And following that logic, where does it take you?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.