User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Why cant we just have anyone involved in testing unable to own or gm a team and force them to keep open builds? This would allow them to play and us to see any specific adjustments they may have made.

The game needs to be improved and tested...we all agree on that. It doesnt need to come at the expense of my $1000 bucks though. I dont want to play anyone on an unbalanced playing field. If they keep there builds open and the game gets tested I have nothing to lose?
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by awesome


Originally posted by Bort



So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Why are you working on D plays when there's still the problem of crazy agility DE's getting 5 sacks a game. Wouldn't these new create a play make it worse?


Build more agile OT's and stop complaining.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Best Solution:

Give everyone tester access so we can learn what everyone else is learning. This is the only fair thing to do.


Life is not fair --- and sometimes it sucks.
 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by atingwald



so you are saying that he built this random generating program for all these teams, but he couldn't do it for say 100 teams of his own... with special builds built in to each of those 100 teams??

Those 100 teams could play each other over and over on a random loop, and the statistical anomalies could not be determined thru statistical analysis??? So a computer is slower than the humans?? LOL

I find that very hard to believe.... in 100 teams, you could generate millions upon millions of matchups, and the oddities would expose themselves in two weeks, guaranteed.... every two weeks, you can adjust those 100 teams, and that would lead to new tests...

how long do you think a game truly lasts??? with a random generator, it takes minutes at most... you can run millions of games in two weeks....


You realize that you only need one question mark, right?


In spanish you need 2...maybe his language needs 2 as well


you sir, are correct!!!! extra exclamations, too
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820

Best Solution:
Give everyone tester access so we can learn what everyone else is learning. This is the only fair thing to do.


added... although this does mean that more test servers would need to be brought online to handle the load, and not everyone could expect to have the immediate ear of bort.

[POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS]
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers
- hire paid testers (that aren't also players)
- screenshots/details of testing interface
- current testers give up teams/etc
- dismiss current testers, bring back testers willing to be public
- give everyone access to test server
other
- hire public relations person
- revisit why initial threads were summarily locked/moved/etc
- Delete GeneralMakaveli's account and pay him to help you with the sim testing.


 
jeffpap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


I think as long as testers aren't actively playing that is enough...They can fix the bugs they find, and everyone is good. No advantage given. If enough people are testing and they know what they are doing, more than 1 person will find the major anomalies
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:32:10
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Bort

So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


added.

[POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS]
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers
- hire paid testers (that aren't also players)
- screenshots/details of testing interface
- current testers give up teams/etc
- dismiss current testers, bring back testers willing to be public
other
- hire public relations person
- revisit why initial threads were summarily locked/moved/etc


You got it here by adding the bolded..
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:31:25
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ThaOutlaw
Originally posted by Saris

One solution might be to just quarantine all of the testers into one league, like oh I don't know Canada. They can own teams and players but they just have to play in Canada. I seriously doubt the loldot crowd would mind if there were testers on their servers.


There's no reason to punish the testers...this isn't their fault. They're trying to help the game for the most part.

Knowing things about the sim is an added bonus, but we can't quarantine this people.


Canada=Punishment lol
 
tshizzle
offline
Link
 
i mean wow - how Bort and others dont see that being a tester is a HUGE advantage is truly mind-boggling to me....


that last 3000 FP i bought will definitely be the last until things are evened out around here... its really starting to make sense as to why some teams just seem to be head and shoulders better than the rest - its not tactics, its having inside knowledge and knowing the things that always give them an advantage over everyone else....


really disheartening, without a doubt the worst worst news that could ever happen to this game - testers playing with the public without anyway for the public to know what they know - JUST FUCKING WOW
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Won't work. It still gives them an unfair advantage as some won't announce anything. Bort if you want to run a business you can't play favorites you have to give EVERYONE the same opportunity. Even if you right up a blog about it the testers still have an unfair advantage. Is it ok to allow some players to have an unfair advantage over others? Nope bc we're paying customers just like them and we are getting cheated.

 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Any of the Testers should out themselves now. Because if it comes out at the end of next season and all of them magically win championships shits going to get ugly real fast.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
One more potential solution...

More information on how SA's work. We know how much blocking is boosted by some of the VA's, give us info on how much of a bonus we get with Run Block, etc.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viet
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by awesome


Originally posted by Bort



So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Why are you working on D plays when there's still the problem of crazy agility DE's getting 5 sacks a game. Wouldn't these new create a play make it worse?


For the most part, agility DEs suck this year. If players are getting 5 sacks a game, it's because of the Offense's builds or gameplan.

 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by Nuge20


Republicans: Understand whats going on, game needs testers
Democrats: ITS NOT FAIR TO ME...THEY HAVE MORE INFO...EVERYONE IS EQUAL






 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Eminently fair in my opinion, and would alleviate any concerns of unfair competitive advantages, especially when coupled with previous proposal of having non-competing gamers test it, such as Deathblade for instance.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.