User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
One solution might be to just quarantine all of the testers into one league, like oh I don't know Canada. They can own teams and players but they just have to play in Canada. I seriously doubt the loldot crowd would mind if there were testers in their leagues.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:30:43
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atingwald


so you are saying that he built this random generating program for all these teams, but he couldn't do it for say 100 teams of his own... with special builds built in to each of those 100 teams??

Those 100 teams could play each other over and over on a random loop, and the statistical anomalies could not be determined thru statistical analysis??? So a computer is slower than the humans?? LOL

I find that very hard to believe.... in 100 teams, you could generate millions upon millions of matchups, and the oddities would expose themselves in two weeks, guaranteed.... every two weeks, you can adjust those 100 teams, and that would lead to new tests...

how long do you think a game truly lasts??? with a random generator, it takes minutes at most... you can run millions of games in two weeks....


I agree, why couldn't everything just be ported over...and then the sim ran?

Then find the outliers?

Did we need a bunch of people to test?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Still unacceptable. Any report would go through a filtering process. If they have access to raw data, so should we.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chester101
Originally posted by Binestar

Originally posted by tpaterniti



It is fair. If you have a question, ask me. If I know, I'll tell you no matter who you are. Seems pretty simple.


How much is the vision change affecting WR's? 2 Weeks worth of games will give you a very good idea of the exact vision you'll need to get back to S7 reactions from the WR's.



Dont worry I asked that question. Top of the page. We will wait together for this info.


I honestly don't know.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
wow! just wow.

i think everything has been mentioned already in this thread.

let me just put in a small thing that needs to be added here: chemistry. and how it is tested against builds and gameplay.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:29:56
 
VietCampo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Why are you working on D plays when there's still the problem of crazy agility DE's getting 5 sacks a game. Wouldn't these new create a play make it worse?
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Yet people are still freaking out like it's 9/11 2.0.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by Nuge20

Republicans: Understand whats going on, game needs testers
Democrats: ITS NOT FAIR TO ME...THEY HAVE MORE INFO...EVERYONE IS EQUAL




That is funny.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Not unless we get names.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by Nuge20


Republicans: Understand whats going on, game needs testers
Democrats: ITS NOT FAIR TO ME...THEY HAVE MORE INFO...EVERYONE IS EQUAL




That is funny.


and true
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Best Solution:
Give everyone tester access so we can learn what everyone else is learning. This is the only fair thing to do.


added... although this does mean that more test servers would need to be brought online to handle the load, and not everyone could expect to have the immediate ear of bort.

[POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS]
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers
- hire paid testers (that aren't also players)
- screenshots/details of testing interface
- current testers give up teams/etc
- dismiss current testers, bring back testers willing to be public
- give everyone access to test server
other
- hire public relations person
- revisit why initial threads were summarily locked/moved/etc
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Would the report include exploits that were fixed, or detailed information found out about attributes and SA's?
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atingwald

so you are saying that he built this random generating program for all these teams, but he couldn't do it for say 100 teams of his own... with special builds built in to each of those 100 teams??

Those 100 teams could play each other over and over on a random loop, and the statistical anomalies could not be determined thru statistical analysis??? So a computer is slower than the humans?? LOL

I find that very hard to believe.... in 100 teams, you could generate millions upon millions of matchups, and the oddities would expose themselves in two weeks, guaranteed.... every two weeks, you can adjust those 100 teams, and that would lead to new tests...

how long do you think a game truly lasts??? with a random generator, it takes minutes at most... you can run millions of games in two weeks....


I think you misunderstand what the "easier said than done part" is. You're assuming that all bugs can be found through statistical analysis. Unfortunately, that is not the case. There's no guarantee that a particular bug will show up as a statistical anomaly, and further more writing the logic in code to detect any possible bug would take longer than just sitting down and watching every single play of every single sim.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:30:32
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
One solution might be to just quarantine all of the testers into one league, like oh I don't know Canada. They can own teams and players but they just have to play in Canada. I seriously doubt the loldot crowd would mind if there were testers on their servers.


There's no reason to punish the testers...this isn't their fault. They're trying to help the game for the most part.

Knowing things about the sim is an added bonus, but we can't quarantine this people.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort


So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


What would this prove? If they find exploits you fixed them right? You're asking for thousands of people wanting flex back if you do that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.