User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
The whole "Player Disparity" issue was touched on with both GG's '200' idea, and my 'League Fix' idea, where the leagues were set up as High School, then College, and then the Pros/Arena/Semi Pros, where someone was forced to move around the area their skills would be more evened out with everyone out for a set number of seasons, before being forced upwards, removing someone from 'sitting' in a lower league just to pad their stats or whatever. It would hurt people playing on same teams as friends, until later levels that is. At any rate...

This concept, of the new "Super SAs" as I'm calling them, would work very well combined with the H.S., College, Pro/Arena concept I think, but all in all, the Original idea here should be implemented, and I'm basically sure this will happen since Bort's fully endorsed this and wants more ideas here.

GG's ideas, Drifter's ideas, a couple of my ideas, a few others' ideas are all on the level of great - but it's all in the eye of the beholder. For Bort, it's more of a time and effort issue. At this point, he's put so much time and effort into the current system he's reluctant to make any MAJOR alteration to that, such as a complete system-wide respec to every active player to implement the '200' idea, or the League Fix to progress a player through a realistic career starting with High School to the Pros, because that would take resetting and restructuring every League in the game to do. This idea only consists of adding onto the current layout of code, so it's simpler to pull off, and thusly, takes less time and effort to employ.

It's unfortunate, in my personal opinion, but that's just my take on why more complex ideas (and sometimes more wholly sound ideas - again my opinion) are being brushed aside in favor of simpler ideas such as this. The idea isn't 'simple minded' before anyone tries to read into my words - there's nothing to read into, other than the words themselves. This idea is simply done, and simply implemented into this game's current core, so it's favored. It's a decent idea, and I think it would work very well...as something in CONJUNCTION with a core suggestion at the fundamental base of the game, but again...I'm not Bort, and these are only my opinions.
 
healthguyfsu
offline
Link
 
I agree...give us our fix!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
And now, back to the topic of the thread, please....

Drifter has a great idea, Bort acknowledges it, and everyone then tries to post ideas Bort has ignored for good reason, instead of helping to advance Drifter's great idea.

Anything that involves big systemwide changes, I'd oppose with my last breath. I've put too much effort into my players to let it be wiped out.

And now, back to the topic of the thread, please....

Last edited Aug 26, 2008 23:21:52
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Soft Cap Adjusters:

Performance Boosters

Future Coach – Increases entire unit’s vision

Clutch – Increases performance in clutch situations (late in close game, OT)

Sure Tackler – Reduces the chance of a missed tackle when playing on balanced

Helmet on the ball – Increases the chance of a fumble when playing on balanced.

Hard to Beat – Less likely to get fooled by pump fakes and receiver moves

Slippery – Higher chance for a QB to break a tackle on a sack

GoTo Guy – Gives a boost to a receiver’s “open or not” read by the QB

Never Gives Up – Reduces the “downtime” by getting pancaked or beat by a move or a pump fake.


Additionally there was the Professional Backup to give Backup Players fewer required downs played to achieve max playtime and another idea to increase effectiveness when losing.

Some of these ideas are ones which are "position specific" -- earlier on in the thread, someone mentioned that maybe it'd be a good idea if the abilities were more generic so that anyone could get them. Like there isn't really any reason why the QB is the only slippery Player.. any position could get an ability to become more difficult to tackle - but it might require high agility and high vision.

Another way to look at this.. if you wanted to go with position specific abilities -- this would be a perfect place to insert an "audible" ability for QB's. Say that it would give a percentage chance to correctly identify the Defense's intentions and change to a play that is a better mismatch that has the same formation. Obviously this would need VERY high Vision (like 80 or 90). Maybe other Players could get an Option ability that would allow them to throw the ball if they are in the HB or FB position and receive a pitch. Maybe punters and kickers could get a fake punt/kick ability. There are a lot of tactics which people want in the game - but maybe those tactics should only be opened up to high level Players through the use of these new abilities?

Just some thoughts
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 23:01:31
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
How did I know GG was gonna try and market his 200 plan here? This is Bort's game and no he's not going to make a system wide core change because he doesn't want to. That's enough reason. Stick to your own topics if you want to further your agenda.

Back to the topic at hand.

What if certain abilities were only unlocked by playing in the Pro Leagues for a significant amount of time? Like after 40 days of playing in the Pro Leagues you unlock some new Prestige abilities. After 80 days you unlock more, etc. It'd help more in convincing people to try at get to the Pro Leagues and for people there to try and stay.

How about special Team based prestige SA's added to players of level that both stick with a team and win championships with said team?
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Others have said it before - and I've come to think that they were right - Bort made a mistake by accepting money for the game.

If Bort discovered what he thought was an "ideal" design for the game that would be of interest to new and veteran Players, but it required that all current players be "reset".. how do we think that the Agents in the game would respond? There would be mass hysteria because "I spent money on this game!!!! blah blah blah" .. so of course we know that any idea that requires a complete reset is out the window - regardless how perfect the idea might turn out to be.

I suppose it doesn't matter, because the game is what the game is, but it means that idea like the one presented in the thread will be limited in their scope (not to mention the dozens of other ideas, like the 200 idea, floating around). One comment in this thread was to the effect of "If we have some of these new abilities unlocked at level 25 - how do we compensate Players that have already exceeded this level?" The answer is - we really can't.. and since that would cut those Players short, it'd be best to start this idea off of a level that is in front of the Players.. Well there are already plenty of level 31's and 32's... by the end of the season there will probably be some 33's. So does that mean that this new system wouldn't kick in until level 34 or 35?

Accepting money gave an assumed promise to not completely change the game.. regardless how explicitly the Admin has said that changes are coming - those who have spent the most on the game will be the ones least likely to accept changes; and they happen to be the ones who are most likely to spend more in the future as long as they are happy.

Shrug.


wise words. and the end result is that any ideas that bort does implement will end up being compromized, different, (ie less) than the original idea itself, as bort would probably try to band-aid a way to bring something in without 'messing up' the existing system in place. And round and round in a vicious circle it goes, avoiding the "re-set" or "re-spec" situation.

Anyway, i dont want to derail threads. But I am explaining in this thread why im not so much against the ideas in the OP, but against them being implemented without forethought to "re-do" the foundation first because that's never going to go away. In terms of this idea being implemented right now....again, im all for specialization etc etc, but the ideas mentioned here are only addressing the vet player and therefore creating more disparity in the wash-up. It's only for this reason that Im adverse to it. More than anything, ideas around parity need to happen, not disparity.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 23:55:47
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phaedron

I think you have a problem with the game of Football, not with GLB.

No matter how hard the Detroit Lions play, if all they have is rookies and 50-yr old QBs, they aren't going to beat the Patriots, Cowboys, and other elite teams in the NFL. If your team is a bunch of rookies, it's always going to be a rebuilding season.


Big difference between Detroit vs Dallas, and some DIII team vs Dallas. The crux is not making noobs = children. But making noobs = pro rookies.

Also, Detroit still wins games, still competes fairly equally. You have your occasional 42-3 score in NFL, but for the most part bad teams like Oakland still compete against good teams like Indy or San Diego. Scores like 24-10 and realistic stats. That realism is only possible INSIDE GLB by leveling the playing field more. By looking at a way to make a brand new player fairly equal to a vet BUT still not as good that they will still lose more games than win----but at least competitively and realistically. You just cannot have that if a brand new player is a child at 11 strength and speed and the process of the game is by gaining more pts to make him have 60 speed and strength. Whilever that model is in place you will get massive disparity. Even level 25 vs level 20 is a huge enough difference to mean 80-3 scores 90% of the time.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 23:58:10
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
the ideas mentioned here are only addressing the vet player and therefore creating more disparity in the wash-up. It's only for this reason that Im adverse to it. More than anything, ideas around parity need to happen, not disparity.


Actually, that was the big part of why I wanted to bring the idea that these new abilities would only be active while playing in the PROs. I felt that it would provide an incentive for high level Players to play in the Pros without giving them any disadvantage to remaining in lower leagues. Just adding the incentive to play in the PROs could go a ways to decreasing the disparity within leagues.

Imagine this scenario: PRO team becomes gutted.. How many 30+ level Players would be willing to play in the gutted PRO team now? Their choice is to play in AAA (or below) and not get to use the new abilities - or play in the PRO league and get to use them (not to mention increased Fame and whatever else there is different).. It would help to rebuild to a somewhat competitive level, teams which have been gutted in the PRO league, as well as removing those Players from the lower leagues as they try to get onto a PRO team.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Ok, well I was trying to think of other perks to add to this idea, and I came up with one. After thinking about it for a while though, I'm not sure if it would be better off as its own separate idea.

Anyway, I was thinking of something along the lines of a "threat level". It would increase your performance very slightly (maybe a boost to vision and confidence?), but it would also increase the amount of attention you receive.

For example, a WR with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to force double coverage on the WR (if they have an extra player to cover), if it doesn't trigger double coverage, the WR gets a slight increase to his attributes for the play.

For QBs, a high "treat level" will trigger the other team to play the pass (unless in an obvious run situation), if it doesn't trigger the pass play, the QB gets an increase in attributes for the play.

For RBs, a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to play the run (unless it is an obvious pass situation), if it doesn't trigger the run play, the RB gets an increase in attributes for the play. Also, the "threat level" could trigger the other team to force a LB to cover the RB on passing plays (a lot of teams don't cover the backs), and if they don't, the RB gets the increase in attributes for the play.

I'm not sure how it could apply to FBs and TEs though since they are often two way players.

On defense, a DE (or DT/NT) with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to force two blockers on the DE (if they have an available lineman/TE/FB/HB to block), if it doesn't trigger the double team, the DE gets a slight increase to his attributes for the play.

A LB with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to pass or run plays away from him, if it doesn't, the LB gets the increase for the play.

A CB/Safety with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to avoid passing in his direction, if it doesn't trigger, the defensive back gets the increase in attributes for the play.

When I say trigger, I mean that it would work like a SA, more points means it has a higher likelihood to trigger.

These "threat levels" make it so the player has a higher likelihood of getting more attention (or less in the LB/CB/S cases) and thus less stats. It also makes it more likely that if the other team doesn't account for you, you'll perform better on that play. Finally, while the "threat level" puts the attention on you, it also opens up opportunities for other players.

If the WR forces double coverage, it'll help another player get open.

If the DE/DT forces a double team, it'll help another lineman or blitzer get a better shot at the QB or the runner.

Etc., etc.

"Threat level" could also be something that is implemented in a scouting report. That way teams have a way of knowing what they should be doing to account for the player when coming up with AI and gameplans.

Thinking about it though, the "threat level" could just be something entirely separate (maybe even performance based). It's just something off the top of my head.

Either way, great original idea though Drifter.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Xiong Yoshi...

Like I said, Im for the general ideas in the OP. They're a good idea in themself that address the vet player experience. That's all acknowledged. But implementing them 'as is' into the current system without addressing the foundation itself as well, will still spell trouble. This Drifter idea is good, but it needs to be tied in with another idea that addresses the foundation itself. Whether it's '200' or turnerhero's idea, or a completely Bort-made idea, it doesnt matter. Everyone likes their own ideas, but the bottom-line is the foundation needs to be addressed first before implementing this great idea by Drifter. No point implementing great ideas on top of flawed foundations. In the short term and long term.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 23:22:28
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Phaedron


I think you have a problem with the game of Football, not with GLB.

No matter how hard the Detroit Lions play, if all they have is rookies and 50-yr old QBs, they aren't going to beat the Patriots, Cowboys, and other elite teams in the NFL. If your team is a bunch of rookies, it's always going to be a rebuilding season.


Big difference between Detroit vs Dallas, and some DIII team vs Dallas. The crux is not making noobs = children. But making noobs = pro rookies.

Also, Detroit still wins games, still competes fairly equally. You have your occasional 42-3 score in NFL, but for the most part bad teams like Oakland still compete against good teams like Indy or San Diego. Scores like 24-10 and realistic stats. That realism is only possible INSIDE GLB by leveling the playing field more. By looking at a way to make a brand new player fairly equal to a vet BUT still not as good that they will still lose more games than win----but at least competitively and realistically. You just cannot have that if a brand new player is a child at 11 strength and speed and the process of the game is by gaining more pts to make him have 60 speed and strength. Whilever that model is in place you will get massive disparity. Even level 25 vs level 20 is a huge enough difference to mean 80-3 scores 90% of the time.


only way to fix those scores is to fix the leagues that have gutted teams each season. Promotion relagation has to be expanded.

All playoff teams should be awarded bids for promotion relegation. Each rounds losers should enter a mini tourny to play for the highest bid available to them. Bids shouldn't matter conference either. Teams shouldn't be stuck in Alpha/zeta for this method.

At the end of each season the league Median can be determined or caps can be set. All teams that are well below the median get relegated regardless of how well they recruited after a mid season gutting. And the teams with the highest bids should be first in line for promotion.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 23:29:26
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG


And the other real big problem with GLB is that true tactics and game-planning has too less a say in game results (and that's partly due to lack of customization, specialization, individualization in player builds), but also to due to the very disparity in player levels. No matter what a level 20 team does, it will get beaten silly by a level 25 team.


I read this whole thread and I feel GG is right on most aspects about the state of the game and this point here is by far the worst flaw in this game. The Gut problem and promotion/relegation system is right behind it.

I think the 200 idea makes a lot of sense. I also think the high level players are so upset at the slowing of leveling for them because it takes away their advantage over the competition. The BBB leagues are catching even the Pro leagues due to that which is as it should be because the game should be about the strategy and builds deciding the games rather than who had the higher levels.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
Originally posted by GG



And the other real big problem with GLB is that true tactics and game-planning has too less a say in game results (and that's partly due to lack of customization, specialization, individualization in player builds), but also to due to the very disparity in player levels. No matter what a level 20 team does, it will get beaten silly by a level 25 team.


I read this whole thread and I feel GG is right on most aspects about the state of the game and this point here is by far the worst flaw in this game. The Gut problem and promotion/relegation system is right behind it.

I think the 200 idea makes a lot of sense. I also think the high level players are so upset at the slowing of leveling for them because it takes away their advantage over the competition. The BBB leagues are catching even the Pro leagues due to that which is as it should be because the game should be about the strategy and builds deciding the games rather than who had the higher levels.


the box should read.... strategies not included..
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by -drifter

For example, a player hits level 31. He continues to get 25XP per day and 90 XP per game on his way to level 32 and so on. However, at the same time he is getting 100 Prestige XP per day and 600 Prestige XP per game towards Prestige Level 2 and so on. By the time the player hits Player Level 32, he'll probably be somwhere are Prestige Level 6 or 7. Boosting will continue to effect Player level but will have no effect on Prestige Level.

Each gain in prestige level will give the player Prestige Skill Points to assign to Prestige attributes


Just so people understand im addressing the OP. Im quoting the VERY thing that is a problem here. It creates disparity. Further disparity. The idea itself on its own is great, and helps break the chain of boredom for vets, which is important (i agree), but if this is brought in on top of the existing system it's only going to exasperate the existing problems in GLB. It only looks to address one side of the coin, without offering a solution to the other side. This idea NOT COUPLED with an idea that seeks to create player parity at the BASE ATTRIBUTES is what I have a problem with.
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by -drifter


For example, a player hits level 31. He continues to get 25XP per day and 90 XP per game on his way to level 32 and so on. However, at the same time he is getting 100 Prestige XP per day and 600 Prestige XP per game towards Prestige Level 2 and so on. By the time the player hits Player Level 32, he'll probably be somwhere are Prestige Level 6 or 7. Boosting will continue to effect Player level but will have no effect on Prestige Level.

Each gain in prestige level will give the player Prestige Skill Points to assign to Prestige attributes


Just so people understand im addressing the OP. Im quoting the VERY thing that is a problem here. It creates disparity. Further disparity. The idea itself on its own is great, and helps break the chain of boredom for vets, which is important (i agree), but if this is brought in on top of the existing system it's only going to exasperate the existing problems in GLB. It only looks to address one side of the coin, without offering a solution to the other side. This idea NOT COUPLED with an idea that seeks to create player parity at the BASE ATTRIBUTES is what I have a problem with.


I initially supported drifters suggestion but have had a change once reading your counter-points GG.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.