User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BoogerEyeJones
I can't emphasize enough what people have said regarding the reallocation of skill points. When changes are introduced that break builds that have been planned out over 2 seasons we should have a chance to reallocate those sp's. Yeah yeah yeah we are stupid cause we spent all our sp's in "x".

Like a lot of people mentioned above, mmorpg's do this in Beta and on occasion in live releases. Use WoW as an example, when changes are introduced that change the basic play characteristics of a certain class, the class' spent SP's are reset to zero and the player has the opportunity to reallocate the sp's.

I think this a lot more reasonable then saying retire/reroll your player because this is a beta as a number of players are saying here.


I really don't know how bad your builds must be to have been completely nerfed by the changes...and if you're a good team, you can adapt and correct.

That said, while I am generally against a respec, I think a 3-6 level (15-30) point respec would probably be fair in this case, but I'm also fine if it doesn't happen.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by BoogerEyeJones

I can't emphasize enough what people have said regarding the reallocation of skill points. When changes are introduced that break builds that have been planned out over 2 seasons we should have a chance to reallocate those sp's. Yeah yeah yeah we are stupid cause we spent all our sp's in "x".

Like a lot of people mentioned above, mmorpg's do this in Beta and on occasion in live releases. Use WoW as an example, when changes are introduced that change the basic play characteristics of a certain class, the class' spent SP's are reset to zero and the player has the opportunity to reallocate the sp's.

I think this a lot more reasonable then saying retire/reroll your player because this is a beta as a number of players are saying here.


I understand your pain, but realistically, why would you think that putting SP into ONE category would be a viable build?


Fortunately I never put all of my points into one skill. My players are far from stellar. The point of a respec has nothing to do with how poor or good MY builds are. My point is that by looking at an established successful business model such as WoW, Bort et. al. can learn something. A fair approach to nerfing attributes is to allow reallocation of skill points. Maybe not everytime an attribute's effectiveness is diminished but maybe when an attribute's effectiveness is diminished to the point where the player's build is no longer viable.

Where that point is exactly I don't know, I don't have access to the coding.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I guess that is my point...a build would have had to be completely lopsided to one or two attributes to be rendered no longer viable in the game. And if that is the case, should we really have sympathy for those who built that way? Plus, they can fix it with boosts/levels, so I don't think any build (minus ones that lack any common sense) would be considered "no longer viable" after the changes.
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
I guess that is my point...a build would have had to be completely lopsided to one or two attributes to be rendered no longer viable in the game. And if that is the case, should we really have sympathy for those who built that way? Plus, they can fix it with boosts/levels, so I don't think any build (minus ones that lack any common sense) would be considered "no longer viable" after the changes.


I guess my question is why NOT allow a re-allocation of points? As many before me have mentioned...this is a Beta. For all the complaints about people using speed whores to take advantage of a vulnerability, weren't they experimenting, and providing a service to Bort, et al by showing them something that needed to be fixed? Isnt that our collective job as a Beta tester?

There may be some unknown nuance to the coding that makes an all-speed/agility/punting build a stud OT at level 60. But if you get penalized for building something like that to test it out, no one will test it out until it is too late?

This game is in Beta. It isn't about winning. It is about testing the game. Period.

IMO as soon as it's about money, it's about winning.
As soon as it's about winning, people will try and master the current system, not experiment with it and expect changes.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nancywhiskey
This game is in Beta. It isn't about winning. It is about testing the game. Period.

IMO as soon as it's about money, it's about winning.


That's why I'm suggesting that Bort should split the two. Give the paying customers a stable product (not one that's perfect - we know that it's not even Beta quality, let alone release quality) - one that isolates changes to the offseason, where only code that has been extensively tested is brought in. Those people are paying money - let them play to win.

Outside of that, establish a test server with one league (32 teams should be more than enough). Take some number of volunteers and populate that test league with owners and agents. Turn them lose with the expectation that game sims will run a few times a day. Give them the ability to respec their players whenever they want so that they can try tons of different options without having to plan out a build over two seasons. Introduce new code, features and bug fixes on that server first. When Bort and the testers have worked out the kinks and bugs and balancing issues - the code gets prepped to move to the public servers in the next offseason - with detailed explanations of the changes.

And most importantly - if you make major changes to the balancing, you give out a free respec to each paying customer on the public server.

As a paying customer of a product that clearly has a disclaimer that it's in Beta (it's really not yet, but that's a different discussion - I'm not sure that I would even agree that it's in Alpha as Bort is still thinking of new features to add), I can live with bugs in the product so long as I know that there are busy little beavers in the background fixing them (and testing the fixes). What I am less tolerant of is wantonly introducing NEW bugs while you are fixing the old bugs, because you aren't really testing the bug fixes properly.

Whether or not Bort likes it - this is now a business. He's got to treat it like one.
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by nancywhiskey

This game is in Beta. It isn't about winning. It is about testing the game. Period.

IMO as soon as it's about money, it's about winning.


That's why I'm suggesting that Bort should split the two. Give the paying customers a stable product (not one that's perfect - we know that it's not even Beta quality, let alone release quality) - one that isolates changes to the offseason, where only code that has been extensively tested is brought in. Those people are paying money - let them play to win.


I can't agree with your two servers idea. That is way more work for the Devs, because there will be problems on the gaming servers too (ask Blizzard, etc...), and it would distract them from the Beta.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nancywhiskey
I can't agree with your two servers idea. That is way more work for the Devs, because there will be problems on the gaming servers too (ask Blizzard, etc...), and it would distract them from the Beta.


Of course there will be problems on the game servers too. The problem is that there are currently problems on the game servers AND nothing is actually getting Beta tested.

I'm more interested in getting this game up to snuff than I am in insulating the Devs from working.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Two issues:

1) With all of the changes occuring in rapid succession, it makes it very hard to get a baseline on what corrections should be made to builds in order to make them more effective. Example - the DEs were going nuts with the AGI boost, so it appeared the OTs needed more AGI (more than they needed to be effective last season...), then Bort decides to give OTs a boost to compensate. Throw in pathing issues against a 3-4 and one wonders if an OL that was very successful last season suddenly needs AGI, VIS etc to compete at its best this season. Hard to know if it's the AI or build, and then with daily changes those build tweaks can suddenly become inefficient.

2) To DD's comment about 'listening to the majority'.. How can you be so sure that you're not listening to a very vocal minority? For example, the "nerf DT" plea seemed like it came out of nowhere by a handful of people.. and was done in haste.

Accepting that this is a pay-to-play Beta, I can definitely see how tough it must be to keep pace with the requirements as the player levels progress and expose more mismatches.. especially with all the new AI thrown in (which rocks btw, thank you.. can't wait until the O can specify which specific player becomes an intended target and more formations become available).

Even so, the Beta banner is being used as an excuse to do anything at any time. Which on the one hand is part of the bargain but on the other hand doesnt take into the consideration of many players. Imo it would make more sense to have FREEZE periods, even for just a week.. to allow some time for accurate data gathering. It can be tough when going against gutted teams to know if anything a team has done has made them more effective, let alone when AI tweaks (like the QB nerf and the CB nerf) are thrown in the mix.

Say: 1 week anything goes tweaks, changes etc.. 1 week Freeze.. 1 week anything goes.. etc. Just enough time for folks to catch their breath a little

That being said, Bort and company are doing an AMAZING job with an phenomenally fun game, that we can expect to become a legend as it grows (which it will). I just think a little consideriation could be thrown back towards those that have put in a few hundo into the game to help it through it's adolescent phase. Not asking for a respec, just consideration on the "Freeze" idea or some variation thereof.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Ok, I never said "if you dont like it, quit". I said its beta and changes should be expected daily. This is beta, it should be expected to find bugs, not 95% bug free. I dont know of any game that has even launched 95% bug free. Every one I've ever seen goes live, and then has to take the servers back down usually within a couple hours of the launch because a major bug was released that was never discovered but was game altering.

Also, GLB DOES NOT charge people. NONE of us HAVE to pay a penny to play this beta. If YOU CHOOSE to pay $$, then you cant blame the admins/devs for your choice to spend $$ on a game still in BETA.

Yes I've spent lots of $$ myself, but that was my choice. Because I have also been part of many betas including MMORPG betas, I know not to expect anything except bugs and changes on a daily basis.

Once again, this is the entire point of a open beta. To stress test the servers and see what flaws the game has, with more than just 100 people testing it. The more people there are testing it, the more bugs you can find before the launch.

However I do agree, since this IS BETA, we should have free respecs available every season to compensate for the new changes to and test the new changes.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
No, I absolutely oppose free respecs.

This season was so large of a change that a 5 or even 10 point respec during the offseason might have been in order. But never, ever during a season, rendering scouting useless. And never, ever, respecs (even limited ones) every offseason unless the cost is something like 7 SP's spent to move 5 (and limited to one such move).

Someone called S4 a "throwaway season." No. Season 3 was the throwaway season. Even while GMing a team to the conference finals of a Pro league, I disliked Season 3, usually hating it.

And even though the teams I GM have as many losses as wins this season (more losses than wins, if you count scrimmages), I've loved Season 4 all the way through. The game is looking more and more like football, not the Season 3 version of speed and defense total domination and no long drives, especially no long TD drives.

If they ever make changes for a season this big again, which I actually doubt will be necessary, then maybe allowing up to 10 points to be moved, at some FP cost (as it hit me, I really don't want freeloaders to be able to fix their builds-- or at least it should only come if one has at some point bought FP's), in the offseason, might be necessary.

If they choose to allow it this coming offseason, due to all the Season 4 changes, I could live with that. But that should never be a permanent feature, unless it were both highly limited and came with a penalty of like 7:5. And never, ever, during any season.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
Ok, I never said "if you dont like it, quit". I said its beta and changes should be expected daily. This is beta, it should be expected to find bugs, not 95% bug free. I dont know of any game that has even launched 95% bug free. Every one I've ever seen goes live, and then has to take the servers back down usually within a couple hours of the launch because a major bug was released that was never discovered but was game altering.

Also, GLB DOES NOT charge people. NONE of us HAVE to pay a penny to play this beta. If YOU CHOOSE to pay $$, then you cant blame the admins/devs for your choice to spend $$ on a game still in BETA.

Yes I've spent lots of $$ myself, but that was my choice. Because I have also been part of many betas including MMORPG betas, I know not to expect anything except bugs and changes on a daily basis.

Once again, this is the entire point of a open beta. To stress test the servers and see what flaws the game has, with more than just 100 people testing it. The more people there are testing it, the more bugs you can find before the launch.

However I do agree, since this IS BETA, we should have free respecs available every season to compensate for the new changes to and test the new changes.

I'll say it. If you don't like it, quit. IT wasn't hidden from you that this game is a BETA in development, therefore by paying money you made a conscious choice to support further development of this game by monetary means.

If respecs would be beneficial in any way toward testing I'm sure Bort would consider it. The people who have dumped tons of cash into this thing just because they want to be "winners" during the Beta phase can only blame themselves when the rug is pulled out from under them. He isn't going to respec people because they made bad choices on their builds intending to exploit weakness or gaps in the code and are upset because they aren't winning now.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
i see this train wreck of a thread still has life. Kleenex is making a mint off you guys...lol.
 
Longhorn1976
offline
Link
 
BETA!!!

WoW never gave out respecs to the Beta testers, so that example doesn't work.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
i see this train wreck of a thread still has life. Kleenex is making a mint off you guys...lol.


I don't masturbate that often...*

























*Ok, that was a lie.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Why would Bort care if the whiners leave?

Changes were announced halfway through season 3, if you ignored it then you deserve to suck! Take your computer and go home already
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.