User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by themadhobbit
I was looking to see if maybe there was something I could do to change how my CB returns the ball and I went all the way back to basics and found this...

"Carrying - Don't want to fumble the ball? You better practice your holding ability. The better your Carrying skill, the less you will lose the ball from a good hit. Carrying will also help you make moves to avoid or break tackles."

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=125

It is the last line - "Carrying will also help you make moves to AVOID or break tackles" - that got me thinking (and being a newb I could be way off) that maybe Carrying is at least of equal importance to Vision (if not more) when it comes to avoiding tackles on a return.

So, veterans, please chime in and confirm or deny, please.


Good theory, nice approach, absolutly NOT the problem.

My guy had a base carrying of 26.14, I had trained it pretty well from the get go as he was intended to be a "return specialist" (lol)

The first scrimmage this season he fumbled and did not try to avoid a single tackle.

So I made all strength and carrying gear, got strength to 32 and carrying to 35, he fumbled again, without any atempt to avoid a single defender.

So I spent more money on equipment and pushed carrying to 42, he fumbled again, also without the slightest move to avoid tackles, if anything he ran AT the defense.

He has not returned a single kick since then because my team was a little upset that the last fumble was returned for a TD.

Most RB, even power backs, have carrying around 30, most WRs even less then that, so it would in no way explain the difference in performance either.

This is a flat out bug.




 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Actually any decent RB has carrying well above 30 (not to mention Cover Up)
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 15:16:28
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
I'm sure low carrying is *part* of the overall CBs as Kick Returners problem, because i bet most people neglect Carrying on a Returning CB.

But this still doesn't address the main problem, which is the Return Specialist ability doing nothing but sucking up skill points.

I mean maybe if i didn't have 8 in Return Specialist, i could have used those points in Carrying to begin with.
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 15:19:27
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
I'm sure low carrying is *part* of the overall CBs as Kick Returners problem, because i bet most people neglect Carrying on a Returning CB.

But this still doesn't address the main problem, which is the Return Specialist ability doing nothing but sucking up skill points.

I mean maybe if i didn't have 8 in Return Specialist, i could have used those points in Carrying to begin with.


I'd really like this thread addressed as well as my suggested simple fix of having the SA add to the entire Return team's blocking, agility and vision. That would seem to instantly fix this issue.
 
Moses Rocks
offline
Link
 
You know, I don't even really care if the problem gets fixed, since it appears letting CB's make cuts and such would break the game, just give me my 6 wasted SP on the advertised very important for kick returners return specialist back and I'm good.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Is your WR set to Elusive?

By no means should kick returners have 5+ TDs or anything like that BUT when he has 10 in Return Specialist along with decent other attributes, it's a little questionable.
 
themadhobbit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
Good theory, nice approach, absolutly NOT the problem.
---

This is a flat out bug.

[/QUOTE



Thanks and DANG IT!

I really wanted it to NOT be a bug!
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Have Return Specialist boost blocking of the special teams and make Return specialist as a Pre-req for the start of those "move" trees.


First step - Change Direction - Return Specialist

Return Specialist - Blitz - Closing speed
Return Specialist - Headfake - Spin - Juke
Return Specialist - Lower shoulder - Stiff Arm - Power Through



This is what needs to be done.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Actually any decent RB has carrying well above 30 (not to mention Cover Up)


You are wrong about that, the carrying part, not the cover up obviously.

However, that is a discusion for another time. Your post in the suggestion forums is spot on and our disagreement about how to build a running back does not change the subject at hand.

This is a bug, plain and simple.

Can we PLEASE just get a response on this?
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 18:24:57
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Carrying - I actually have less than 14 in both my return guys - and last week was the first fumble in a collective 115 returns, so I'd never bothered with it.

Nice spot about it helping to avoid tackles though. Although I have to say it's a silly way of implementing tackle avoidance, when there's plenty of other stats that would be more in keeping with such skills.......

Anyway - experiment this week. Set my one of my guys on 'power' for his running style and he actually made MORE moves and broke some tackles - despite only being a 20 strength guy.

Might be worth a go............it's 'wrong' in so many ways, but at least it's better than doing nothing.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
Originally posted by drifter

Actually any decent RB has carrying well above 30 (not to mention Cover Up)


You are wrong about that.

I would say YOU are wrong. If I had a level 20+ HB with less than 30 carrying, he wouldn't be starting.

However, Elusive is clearly bugged and could easily be the issue here.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Originally posted by sxewesley

Originally posted by drifter


Actually any decent RB has carrying well above 30 (not to mention Cover Up)


You are wrong about that.

I would say YOU are wrong. If I had a level 20+ HB with less than 30 carrying, he wouldn't be starting.

However, Elusive is clearly bugged and could easily be the issue here.


You are wrong about the RBs. You are also not contributing anything to this discusion.

Elusive is not the bug here at all, elusive has been broken since day one, CBs returning kicks have only been broken this season.

Try again.
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 18:20:18
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Carrying - I actually have less than 14 in both my return guys - and last week was the first fumble in a collective 115 returns, so I'd never bothered with it.

Nice spot about it helping to avoid tackles though. Although I have to say it's a silly way of implementing tackle avoidance, when there's plenty of other stats that would be more in keeping with such skills.......

Anyway - experiment this week. Set my one of my guys on 'power' for his running style and he actually made MORE moves and broke some tackles - despite only being a 20 strength guy.

Might be worth a go............it's 'wrong' in so many ways, but at least it's better than doing nothing.


My level 7 CB made 2 KR TDs last game on power, broke some tackles too (in a level 13 capped league).

The trouble with this, if you're using power, why even bother with CBs? There's no point in CB returner who depends on power, you might as well just use a power back or DE/OT who is built on str/speed/agility. The CB will get his return specialist, but HBs get their own tackle-breaking moves-not to mention power returning doesn't really depend on ridiculous speed.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Agree with this, making me think I wasted a lot of time, building a Return Specialist corner for nothing.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pestface
The trouble with this, if you're using power, why even bother with CBs? There's no point in CB returner who depends on power, you might as well just use a power back or DE/OT who is built on str/speed/agility. The CB will get his return specialist, but HBs get their own tackle-breaking moves-not to mention power returning doesn't really depend on ridiculous speed.


That's my point - not only does the return specialist SA do nothing, there's obviously something far more underlying that's not working correctly, as me changing my less-than-14-power return 'specialists' into 'power' reurners makes NO sense at all in terms of reality - yet it performs better than the 'realistic' setting.

You have to ask why such things are only now coming to light, when there's been people charged with finding these loopholes for over 4 seasons??

Perish the thought that they HAVE been finding these loopholes but have been keeping them to themselves in order to exploit the game??

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.