There has actually been some decent discussion here. I have to say I'm kind of surprised. Maybe something good can come out of this in the long run.
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Larry Roadgrader
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dee
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai
I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.
I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility
Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)
Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.
People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.
Live and learn.
"Football sim".
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai
I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.
I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility

Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)
Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.
People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.
Live and learn.
"Football sim".
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 18:09:05
LordEvil
offline
offline
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is a freebie
No one said you couldn't put a range on a random number. Mainly because anyone who knows even vaguely what they're talking about knows you HAVE to put a range on a random number for it to be meaningful; random numbers are usually generated as incredibly massive numbers (in the trillions and higher) and are reduced in size by a variety of methods (modulus being one common method) to yield a useful number.
The idiocy in your statement is the suggestions that A) anything in a simulation should be hardcapped, and B) the game decides ahead of time how many times a random event is going to occur.
Harcapping a simulation defeats the entire purpose. If you limit the bounds to "reasonable" numbers, you'll never be able to draw meaningful data from the simulation.
And your missing my point. My WRS all 3 of them went two season unequipted, not 1 but 2, I lead 3 different teams in receptions yards and TDs, explain that one, Won awards with a couple of them. If it's all about random numbers being generated, then the stuff I mentioned before is pointless.
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is a freebie
No one said you couldn't put a range on a random number. Mainly because anyone who knows even vaguely what they're talking about knows you HAVE to put a range on a random number for it to be meaningful; random numbers are usually generated as incredibly massive numbers (in the trillions and higher) and are reduced in size by a variety of methods (modulus being one common method) to yield a useful number.
The idiocy in your statement is the suggestions that A) anything in a simulation should be hardcapped, and B) the game decides ahead of time how many times a random event is going to occur.
Harcapping a simulation defeats the entire purpose. If you limit the bounds to "reasonable" numbers, you'll never be able to draw meaningful data from the simulation.
And your missing my point. My WRS all 3 of them went two season unequipted, not 1 but 2, I lead 3 different teams in receptions yards and TDs, explain that one, Won awards with a couple of them. If it's all about random numbers being generated, then the stuff I mentioned before is pointless.
wombat killer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dee
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai
I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.
I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility
Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)
Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.
People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.
Live and learn.
Just because it happened doesn't mean it is a good thing. Maybe the "death spiral" is so unrealistic it needs to be looked at. Or maybe other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it.
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai
I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.
I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility

Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)
Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.
People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.
Live and learn.
Just because it happened doesn't mean it is a good thing. Maybe the "death spiral" is so unrealistic it needs to be looked at. Or maybe other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it.
Serenity
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?
Dee
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Dee
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai
I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.
I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility
Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)
Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.
People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.
Live and learn.
"Football sim".
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
It does when your QB sucks. And the more he sucks, the more he wants to blow too. So then you have a mixture of Sucking and Blowing, and thats only in the first quarter. Then he drops his pants and takes it in the....
Originally posted by Dee
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai
I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.
I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility

Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)
Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.
People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.
Live and learn.
"Football sim".
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
It does when your QB sucks. And the more he sucks, the more he wants to blow too. So then you have a mixture of Sucking and Blowing, and thats only in the first quarter. Then he drops his pants and takes it in the....
Just for comparisons sake...
For NFL playoffs:
Most Turnovers, Game
9
NFC: Washington vs. Chi. Bears, 1940
NFC: Detroit vs. Cleveland, 1954
AFC: Houston vs. Pittsburgh, 1978
SB: Buffalo vs. Dallas, 1992
8
NFC: N.Y. Giants vs. Chi. Bears, 1946
NFC: Los Angeles vs. Cleveland, 1955
NFC: Cleveland vs. Detroit, 1957
SB: Denver vs. Dallas, 1977
NFC-D: Minnesota vs. Philadelphia, 1980
NFC-D: Green Bay vs. St. Louis, 2001
7
In many games
...mind you, the most interceptions thrown in one playoff game by an individual is:
Most Passes Had Intercepted, Game
6
Frank Filchock, NFC: N.Y. Giants vs. Chi. Bears, 1946
Bobby Layne, NFC: Detroit vs. Cleveland, 1954
Norm Van Brocklin, NFC: Los Angeles vs. Cleveland, 1955
Brett Favre, NFC-D: Green Bay vs. St. Louis, 2001
5
Frank Filchock, NFC: Washington vs. Chi. Bears, 1940
George Blanda, AFC: Houston vs. San Diego, 1961
George Blanda, AFC: Houston vs. Dall. Texans, 1962 (OT)
Y.A. Tittle, NFC: N.Y. Giants vs. Chicago, 1963
Mike Phipps, AFC-D: Cleveland vs. Miami, 1972
Dan Pastorini, AFC: Houston vs. Pittsburgh, 1978
Dan Fouts, AFC-D: San Diego vs. Houston, 1979
Tommy Kramer, NFC-D: Minnesota vs. Philadelphia, 1980
Dan Fouts, AFC-D: San Diego vs. Miami, 1982
Richard Todd, AFC: N.Y. Jets vs Miami, 1982
Gary Danielson, NFC-D: Detroit vs. San Francisco, 1983
Jay Schroeder, AFC: L.A. Raiders vs. Buffalo, 1990
Rich Gannon, SB: Oakland vs. Tampa Bay, 2002
Just for comparisons sake.
For NFL playoffs:
Most Turnovers, Game
9
NFC: Washington vs. Chi. Bears, 1940
NFC: Detroit vs. Cleveland, 1954
AFC: Houston vs. Pittsburgh, 1978
SB: Buffalo vs. Dallas, 1992
8
NFC: N.Y. Giants vs. Chi. Bears, 1946
NFC: Los Angeles vs. Cleveland, 1955
NFC: Cleveland vs. Detroit, 1957
SB: Denver vs. Dallas, 1977
NFC-D: Minnesota vs. Philadelphia, 1980
NFC-D: Green Bay vs. St. Louis, 2001
7
In many games
...mind you, the most interceptions thrown in one playoff game by an individual is:
Most Passes Had Intercepted, Game
6
Frank Filchock, NFC: N.Y. Giants vs. Chi. Bears, 1946
Bobby Layne, NFC: Detroit vs. Cleveland, 1954
Norm Van Brocklin, NFC: Los Angeles vs. Cleveland, 1955
Brett Favre, NFC-D: Green Bay vs. St. Louis, 2001
5
Frank Filchock, NFC: Washington vs. Chi. Bears, 1940
George Blanda, AFC: Houston vs. San Diego, 1961
George Blanda, AFC: Houston vs. Dall. Texans, 1962 (OT)
Y.A. Tittle, NFC: N.Y. Giants vs. Chicago, 1963
Mike Phipps, AFC-D: Cleveland vs. Miami, 1972
Dan Pastorini, AFC: Houston vs. Pittsburgh, 1978
Dan Fouts, AFC-D: San Diego vs. Houston, 1979
Tommy Kramer, NFC-D: Minnesota vs. Philadelphia, 1980
Dan Fouts, AFC-D: San Diego vs. Miami, 1982
Richard Todd, AFC: N.Y. Jets vs Miami, 1982
Gary Danielson, NFC-D: Detroit vs. San Francisco, 1983
Jay Schroeder, AFC: L.A. Raiders vs. Buffalo, 1990
Rich Gannon, SB: Oakland vs. Tampa Bay, 2002
Just for comparisons sake.
hambone77us
offline
offline
ten interceptions is unrealistic but not if you dont pull your quarterback, i have seen plenty of games that a quarterback would have thrown that many if he wasnt pulled, and you have to take into account the fact the other team is not subing thier guys like you would if you got five interceptions on a qb. i think the reall problem would be a sub qb lets say if he throws three or four interceptions it is time to hit the bricks for that game
Larry Roadgrader
offline
offline
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?
Not even "bad" PLAYOFF QB's throw TEN in a game. Not in the pros, not in college.
Today's sim was a bad joke.
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.
Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?
Not even "bad" PLAYOFF QB's throw TEN in a game. Not in the pros, not in college.
Today's sim was a bad joke.
For a team intercepting another team, it looks like this:
Most Interceptions By, Game
8 NFC: Chi. Bears vs. Washington, 1940
7 NFC: Cleveland vs. Los Angeles, 1955
6
NFC: Green Bay vs. N.Y. Giants, 1939
NFC: Chi. Bears vs. N.Y. Giants, 1946
NFC: Cleveland vs. Detroit, 1954
AFC: San Diego vs. Houston, 1961
AFC: Buffalo vs. L.A. Raiders, 1990
NFC-FR: Philadelphia vs. Detroit, 1995
NFC-D: St. Louis vs. Green Bay, 2001
So, Chicago intercepted the Redskins QBs 8 times in 1940 for instance.
Most Interceptions By, Game
8 NFC: Chi. Bears vs. Washington, 1940
7 NFC: Cleveland vs. Los Angeles, 1955
6
NFC: Green Bay vs. N.Y. Giants, 1939
NFC: Chi. Bears vs. N.Y. Giants, 1946
NFC: Cleveland vs. Detroit, 1954
AFC: San Diego vs. Houston, 1961
AFC: Buffalo vs. L.A. Raiders, 1990
NFC-FR: Philadelphia vs. Detroit, 1995
NFC-D: St. Louis vs. Green Bay, 2001
So, Chicago intercepted the Redskins QBs 8 times in 1940 for instance.
Clinton Esquire
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
As many here will attest, I've been one of the more ardent defenders of Goal Line Blitz--I've argued against crappy suggestion after crappy suggestion because I've trusted the developers had a vision for the game that would in time make it great.
But not any more.
Our 11-5 team (seeded sixth overall) just played a 13-3 team (seeded third overall) in an opening round playoff game. We lost 45-0.
But I'm just getting started.
Our starting QB threw only 15 INTs all season long. He threw NINE in today's game.
Our backup QB threw another, putting us at TEN INTs for the day.
Add in 3 sacks and 7 hurries.
Add in a "running game" that amassed 17 yards on 18 carries ("Yes", I already backed out the sack yardage--"Yes", even with the sacks removed, we averaged less than a yard a carry).
In short, Season #3's sims have demonstrated all year long that they are far from acceptable when it comes to realism. Myself and others have documented in other threads that the offensive side of the sim is BROKEN--that neither the run nor the pass works well when 2 "roughly similar" teams square off in the higher level leagues. And I went on record more than once pointing out that it would be a MISTAKE to allow this nonsense to continue on thru the playoffs without fixing the offenses.
But to pretend that our entire team (which nearly every member of paid to boost the entire 3 levels for this season, last season, and the innaugural one) is supposed to be satisified with such a BULLSHIT playoff sim as being the end to our "season" is an absolute joke.
Sorry Bort, I tried to support you. But you should have stepped in and fixed the sims before it ever got to the PLAYOFFS of "Season 3". 10 freaking interceptions in a game belongs nowhere in your coding--particularly so when its a playoff game between 2 teams with roughly similar records and roughly similar levels.
You owe Nashville a refund--and not in flex points that could only be spent on a BROKEN sim. Cash please--no "sim" worth paying pretends that a PLAYOFF TEAM throws 10 picks in a single game. There's not an excuse you can offer as to why we're supposed to be happy having our "season" end with TEN interceptions in a SINGLE GAME--NINE of them by our starter who threw only 15 all season.
Must.... not.... kick... a... man... while... he... is... down...
F'it though, nothing about kicking a girl when she's down!
Neenerneener JamyP!
As many here will attest, I've been one of the more ardent defenders of Goal Line Blitz--I've argued against crappy suggestion after crappy suggestion because I've trusted the developers had a vision for the game that would in time make it great.
But not any more.
Our 11-5 team (seeded sixth overall) just played a 13-3 team (seeded third overall) in an opening round playoff game. We lost 45-0.
But I'm just getting started.
Our starting QB threw only 15 INTs all season long. He threw NINE in today's game.
Our backup QB threw another, putting us at TEN INTs for the day.
Add in 3 sacks and 7 hurries.
Add in a "running game" that amassed 17 yards on 18 carries ("Yes", I already backed out the sack yardage--"Yes", even with the sacks removed, we averaged less than a yard a carry).
In short, Season #3's sims have demonstrated all year long that they are far from acceptable when it comes to realism. Myself and others have documented in other threads that the offensive side of the sim is BROKEN--that neither the run nor the pass works well when 2 "roughly similar" teams square off in the higher level leagues. And I went on record more than once pointing out that it would be a MISTAKE to allow this nonsense to continue on thru the playoffs without fixing the offenses.
But to pretend that our entire team (which nearly every member of paid to boost the entire 3 levels for this season, last season, and the innaugural one) is supposed to be satisified with such a BULLSHIT playoff sim as being the end to our "season" is an absolute joke.
Sorry Bort, I tried to support you. But you should have stepped in and fixed the sims before it ever got to the PLAYOFFS of "Season 3". 10 freaking interceptions in a game belongs nowhere in your coding--particularly so when its a playoff game between 2 teams with roughly similar records and roughly similar levels.
You owe Nashville a refund--and not in flex points that could only be spent on a BROKEN sim. Cash please--no "sim" worth paying pretends that a PLAYOFF TEAM throws 10 picks in a single game. There's not an excuse you can offer as to why we're supposed to be happy having our "season" end with TEN interceptions in a SINGLE GAME--NINE of them by our starter who threw only 15 all season.
Must.... not.... kick... a... man... while... he... is... down...
F'it though, nothing about kicking a girl when she's down!
Neenerneener JamyP!

driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deuceswild26
Strength: 34 Blocking: 9
Speed: 18.37 Tackling: 9
Agility: 22.68 Throwing: 59
Jumping: 14.5 Catching: 14.5
Stamina: 52.66 Carrying: 14.5
Vision: 47.75 Kicking: 9
Confidence: 29.12 Punting: 9
5-5-4-5-7
Strength is kind of low too, besides confidence. got rattles early and shook his nerves. Strength will help put velocity on the ball.
Strength: 34 Blocking: 9
Speed: 18.37 Tackling: 9
Agility: 22.68 Throwing: 59
Jumping: 14.5 Catching: 14.5
Stamina: 52.66 Carrying: 14.5
Vision: 47.75 Kicking: 9
Confidence: 29.12 Punting: 9
5-5-4-5-7
Strength is kind of low too, besides confidence. got rattles early and shook his nerves. Strength will help put velocity on the ball.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























