User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by LJ



The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again.




Here's another reason to dislike the rule:

Owner #1 knows none of his teammates in real life and has alot of turnover in his team for season to season.

Owner #2 is a store manager and as a gift to his employees he buys flex points for them to keep them happy at work and staying with the company.



Owner #1 is now not able to buy flex points for new players coming in

Owner #2 has a big advantage because he can buy flex points for his players (legally)


Why can some owners can buy flex points for their players and others can't??? How is that fair?

Am I the only one who sees this???


SI, you realize that this is totally impossible to police right?



That is my point (the way it is set up now).

They could police it if people paid GLB directy. Then it wouldn't be hard to match up a credit card or debit card to someone's name. It would be very easy to catch the multiple account players as well.

I proposed scrapping palpay....


it is still not able to be policed... if the guy is there boss and wants to buy them FP how the heck can GLB tell if he did it? Let's say the store manager is dead set on buying his employees FP, and let's say that we stop using paypal as you suggest. The creative store manager gives them gift credit cards and makes some monitored policy that they spend the gift card here on FP. you cant stop it from being done outside the control of GLB.

If people can hack into government security where 1000 guys are paid to come up with random scenarios more involved than any of yours, then there will be away around any rule that is made on this sight. Keep coming up with random scenarios if it makes you feel better though. But whatever you come up with, there will be a way around it.

If you are really against the buying of FP for others, you sure are handing out alot of plausible ideas to the community. If you are just against the rule as it is posted because there are loop holes, then get over it and read Laggo's post above that echos many others in this thread.

Maybe Bort can give you FP to be his private think tank so you quit teaching methods to those who want to circumvent the rules
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Someone earlier hit the nail on the head. This is exactly like paying for a PL or buying gold with real money in other MMOs. There are way too many scenarios that can/will pop up for them to classify every situation as allowed/prohibited, but the one thing that can be clarified is this.....

If they find proof that you DID pay or accept FP that was linked to a contract signing/resigning, you will be punished. It doesnt matter how someone tries to get around it, or what loophole they tried to use, or if they did it outside of the GLB forums/PMs...if they find proof that it happened, you get punished. If there is no proof, they can do nothing about it.

Sure there may seem to be discrepancies, but the only way they can handle it realistically is case by case. Two owners could both offer 100FP awards to a player on their team for MVP, both players could resign with their team later in the year, and one set of those people may be punished, but not the other. Why?..because after looking at both situations they found proof that one owner/player broke the rules and found no proof that the others did so. You cant put a hard line policy on situations like this that require a judgment call by those in charge, unless you totally outlaw it at all. Even then you are still going to have people going outside of the admin/moderators jurisdiction to do this stuff, just like they do in real life....thats why the black market exists.

You cant expect them to be omniscient.
 
the47x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Someone earlier hit the nail on the head. This is exactly like paying for a PL or buying gold with real money in other MMOs. There are way too many scenarios that can/will pop up for them to classify every situation as allowed/prohibited, but the one thing that can be clarified is this.....

If they find proof that you DID pay or accept FP that was linked to a contract signing/resigning, you will be punished. It doesnt matter how someone tries to get around it, or what loophole they tried to use, or if they did it outside of the GLB forums/PMs...if they find proof that it happened, you get punished. If there is no proof, they can do nothing about it.

Sure there may seem to be discrepancies, but the only way they can handle it realistically is case by case. Two owners could both offer 100FP awards to a player on their team for MVP, both players could resign with their team later in the year, and one set of those people may be punished, but not the other. Why?..because after looking at both situations they found proof that one owner/player broke the rules and found no proof that the others did so. You cant put a hard line policy on situations like this that require a judgment call by those in charge, unless you totally outlaw it at all. Even then you are still going to have people going outside of the admin/moderators jurisdiction to do this stuff, just like they do in real life....thats why the black market exists.

You cant expect them to be omniscient.


Old mafia rules, my friend. Only discuss business in person.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
I PMed this to a mod, but I'm throwing it in the thread as well. So that mod who knows who he is can skip this post, I didn't make any changes

-----

Like I and others have said, if you're serious about it you have to outlaw all FP transactions between players.

Hell, go fish through norsemanvike's posts. He contradicts himself back-to-back in quoting me: he says it's ok to pay a player FP for in-game performance if I so choose, but then notes that if I do so it's possible I would be banned for signing him in the first place or if I ever re-sign him at a later point (including that offseason)!

It's not so much the intent of the rule that I care about; outlaw it, legalize it entirely, makes no difference to me. I don't offer FP, I don't boost, I don't buy custom equipment, I don't give a shit about FP beyond making more players to manage and maybe someday snagging a team.

It's the fact that you're trying to outlaw it while leaving so many obvious exploits & loopholes that it's impossible to enforce. People like me bring up loophole after loophole and the only response we get is either contradictory (see my example above) or completely unbecoming of a moderator (LJ's "stop looking for loopholes" as well as his "if you don't like the rule you must be someone we're making the rule to stop" implied accusation).

Any time the rule as it stands now is used to ban somebody, there's a good chance they could come up with a reasonable argument for why their situation fits into a previously mentioned loophole in the rule. Why give the admins all the extra work of fishing through excuses? Or better yet, why leave the loopholes?

Honesty is the best policy.
Come out and say "We can't stop you from finding alternate ways of paying players via cash or FP. We can however try to keep it outside the game, so that it's very difficult for you to do so. This will also attempt to prevent a massive flood of only-sign-for-FP free agents that will ruin this game as it ruined CyberDunk.

Therefore, if you offer a contract with FP incentives through the forums or PMs and we find out, you'll be punished. Furthermore if you're found asking for or supplying outside-the-site ways to get FP incentives, you will also be punished."

Can they still do it, of course they can, no rule will stop them. Will they have to be incredibly devious and under-handed to do it, of course they will.

But that's exactly how you want it, isn't it? I mean, everyone agrees it can't 100% be stamped out, and limiting it to the most desperate of desperate is about as constrained as you can get...
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I PMed this to a mod, but I'm throwing it in the thread as well. So that mod who knows who he is can skip this post, I didn't make any changes

-----

Like I and others have said, if you're serious about it you have to outlaw all FP transactions between players.

Hell, go fish through norsemanvike's posts. He contradicts himself back-to-back in quoting me: he says it's ok to pay a player FP for in-game performance if I so choose, but then notes that if I do so it's possible I would be banned for signing him in the first place or if I ever re-sign him at a later point (including that offseason)!

It's not so much the intent of the rule that I care about; outlaw it, legalize it entirely, makes no difference to me. I don't offer FP, I don't boost, I don't buy custom equipment, I don't give a shit about FP beyond making more players to manage and maybe someday snagging a team.

It's the fact that you're trying to outlaw it while leaving so many obvious exploits & loopholes that it's impossible to enforce. People like me bring up loophole after loophole and the only response we get is either contradictory (see my example above) or completely unbecoming of a moderator (LJ's "stop looking for loopholes" as well as his "if you don't like the rule you must be someone we're making the rule to stop" implied accusation).

Any time the rule as it stands now is used to ban somebody, there's a good chance they could come up with a reasonable argument for why their situation fits into a previously mentioned loophole in the rule. Why give the admins all the extra work of fishing through excuses? Or better yet, why leave the loopholes?

Honesty is the best policy.
Come out and say "We can't stop you from finding alternate ways of paying players via cash or FP. We can however try to keep it outside the game, so that it's very difficult for you to do so. This will also attempt to prevent a massive flood of only-sign-for-FP free agents that will ruin this game as it ruined CyberDunk.

Therefore, if you offer a contract with FP incentives through the forums or PMs and we find out, you'll be punished. Furthermore if you're found asking for or supplying outside-the-site ways to get FP incentives, you will also be punished."

Can they still do it, of course they can, no rule will stop them. Will they have to be incredibly devious and under-handed to do it, of course they will.

But that's exactly how you want it, isn't it? I mean, everyone agrees it can't 100% be stamped out, and limiting it to the most desperate of desperate is about as constrained as you can get...


Well said. If this rule is to have any teeth, ALL FP transactions must be banned. The "case-by-case" approach kills this rule from the start.

I also feel that LJ's comments were extremely short-sighted and immature and it begs the question: how did someone like this become a moderator?
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Edited because it's simply a waste of time.......

When it's the mods that are at the centre of the gutting problem, when it's the alpha testers that have close links with the FP bribes and when the self-appointed GLB mafia keep defending it (knowing that they'll never be touched either, due to being friends with mods/alpha testers) then what's the f**king point??

I've already made my case to mods and admins and I guess the fact that the 'ringleaders' are still here speaks volumes about what is being done to protect the honest PAYING players from the cheats!!

Way to go everyone!!
Last edited Jul 13, 2008 05:36:55
 
ACES
offline
Link
 
I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ACES
I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.

You can offer it, they can accept, but at any point someone may decide to ban you for signing the player in the first place. Also, if you re-sign that player you may be banned for it.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ACES
I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.


As long as those FP arent a requirement, or a highlighted incentive linked to the player resigning with your team, it is allowed. Obviously that player may take what was done into consideration when making his decision whether or not to resign with the team, but as long as he doesnt request that you continue to do so, and you dont "remind him" that it was done to help convince him to resign, you should be fine.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Is this another critique or is it your solution?

Originally posted by oldskool
"We can't stop you from finding alternate ways of paying players via cash or FP. We can however try to keep it outside the game, so that it's very difficult for you to do so. This will also attempt to prevent a massive flood of only-sign-for-FP free agents that will ruin this game as it ruined CyberDunk.

Therefore, if you offer a contract with FP incentives through the forums or PMs and we find out, you'll be punished. Furthermore if you're found asking for or supplying outside-the-site ways to get FP incentives, you will also be punished."



I don't see much of a difference between this and what is already posted. It doesn't state the punishment (which is fine by me), and it adds " Furthermore if you're found asking for or supplying outside-the-site ways to get FP incentives , you will also be punished." It doesn't really change any of the loopholes or investigation time. It doesn't say anything about what happens if I just give FPs for performance. What am I missing here?
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ACES
I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.


Any way you transfer FP, there is still risk involved, so we don't recommend it. as of right now it is not illegal.
 
Tiger224
offline
Link
 
I didn't even know you can transfer FP in the first place. How do you do it?

Thanks-

Scott
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tiger224
I didn't even know you can transfer FP in the first place. How do you do it?

Thanks-

Scott


there is no way to transfer FP in this place.
 
Tiger224
offline
Link
 
I'm confused then. How can you offer FP's to entice players to sign?
 
hud
offline
Link
 
outside of the game setup. you have to do it through paypal. some people have been giving GLB account information to other players as well so those other players can buy them FP. Both are discouraged because both can cause major problems and disputes. There is risk involved. You give your account info away and someone can royally hose your stuff when they log in to buy you Flex. You do it through paypal and you might get scammed or robbed. In either of these cases, GLB will not support you.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.