User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
MrMike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jayme Thysell
Originally posted by MrMike

I think the best way to do it is this:

When a team is put up for sale, an Admin can choose from two classifications for the team. Competitive, and Gutted. If the team is obviously gutted, if the team is something like 6-9 points below most teams in its League, classify it as a Gutted. As with the plan you've laid out in the first post of the thread, the team would be sent to the bottom rung, and the new owner would be given a clean slate.

The biggest problem with your plan is that it requires admin attention. Whatever the solution is, it needs to be an automated system. You can't have the admins evaluate every transaction of a team being sold.


If it truly cannot be done by Admins, I would then say to look at the overall rankings. If the team being sold is 9 points under the Median Team in the League, it should be classified under the Gutted classification. If its within 6, it can be deemed competitive. Again, splitting the classification is the best way to handle this.

 
big_n_rich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pez35
I like the idea of all teams sold resetting stadium and fan support... A new owner should not get the benefit of a stadium and fan support that another owner worked hard to build.


I have to disagree. If you get a team in USA BBB (bottom rung) and the top 10 teams are all competitive they will likely have players mostly all around level 20 to start next season. Let's assume you are a heck of a recruiter and match them level for level you will have an issue when your guys get to level 24 (you won't have enough cash to pay for the level 24 upgrades). Fan support I fully support being reset, but don't shoot the new owner in the foot by not giving him the existing stadium upgrades to be able to afford the bonuses when they are due (assuming the old owner actually added onto the stadium).
Last edited Jul 7, 2008 14:05:01
 
maximus77
offline
Link
 
I think that you should just open it up for bid/sale to other people that are interested in buying a team.

The only clause with that is that the new owner should have to wait until the offseason to kick people out of the team. This will prevent those people that have twenty players from buying a team and kicking everybody out so that they can add their own players to the roster.

I'm sure that there are a lot of people out there that will take the time to be a GM. owner for a team so this solution would fix both ends!

Let me know what you think!

Peace
 
3ball
offline
Link
 
I don't know if this is happening or not, but it seems that most of the teams that are being gutted/sold are teams with pretty poor records. Are the owners of those teams selling their team, and going right back to the waiting list to buy another one to start over? I think there should be a time allotment for people before they can do that. Something like 40 days (a full season). Maybe that will help out a little with so many teams getting sold back?
 
pez35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by big_n_rich
Originally posted by pez35

I like the idea of all teams sold resetting stadium and fan support... A new owner should not get the benefit of a stadium and fan support that another owner worked hard to build.


I have to disagree. If you get a team in USA BBB (bottom rung) and the top 10 teams are all competitive they will likely have players mostly all around level 20 to start next season. Let's assume you are a heck of a recruiter and match them level for level you will have an issue when your guys get to level 24 (you won't have enough cash to pay for the level 24 upgrades). Fan support I fully support being reset, but don't shoot the new owner in the foot by not giving him the existing stadium upgrades to be able to afford the bonuses when they are due (assuming the old owner actually added onto the stadium).


The thing you're getting into with that though is that all new owners waiting for a team should be considered equal. The way it stands now is you might get the luck of the draw and get a team with a good stadium or you might get the other side of the coin and get a crap stadium... it shouldn't be like that. All new owners should inherit their teams as close to on equal ground as possible with other new owners.

If you get a gutted team in a league that you have to compete with 20+ players in, it doesn't matter how hard you recruit. You're going to get relegated probably 2 times before you start winning. (Unless of course you own 20-30 (20+) players you can slide in there.
Last edited Jul 8, 2008 00:00:20
 
pez35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 3ball
I don't know if this is happening or not, but it seems that most of the teams that are being gutted/sold are teams with pretty poor records. Are the owners of those teams selling their team, and going right back to the waiting list to buy another one to start over? I think there should be a time allotment for people before they can do that. Something like 40 days (a full season). Maybe that will help out a little with so many teams getting sold back?


That wouldn't likely do any good because they would often just receive someone else's gutted team and start the relegation skid that is becoming so prevelant.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Can't we prevent gutting?

That's what needs to happen.

As far as what to do with new and sold teams...

1. Sold teams need to stay in the same conference. Chemistry grace periods and other temporary boosts could give them an edge at becoming competitive. It's not hard to find someone good rotting on the bench somewhere if you are actually trying. Teams should be rebuilt with the same type of hard work that the successful teams have already put in. If we can somehow limit where players can sign based upon the season they are created, we can assure that leagues have parity.

2. There should be 2 types of new leagues during each release: level 13 cap leagues and level 4 cap leagues. Right now, there really is NOTHING to keep brand new agents interested (or to get good playing time for new players). Level 4 cap leagues would give new players a place to go and be competitive on a REAL team.

JMHO
 
buck2008
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by YardRat
1. The next highest rated teams should move up to fill the new void, based on the playoff brackets and then w/l record as the first tie-breaker, conference standing for regular season as the next, etc.

2. Interim ownership via another GM or player currently on the team to finish out the season with the option to remain owner at season's end, or continue with the sale.

3. No cpu players on any roster allowed, except for teams in the bottom tier of their league.

4. Is there an option to buy (accept/deny) for new owners currently when offered a team with no penalty (dropping down/off the list)? If not, there should be. If a new owner wants to field a team with his players in the 20's, then he should be allowed to A)Refuse ownership of a team that is going to restrict his capability to create such a team without losing the opportunity to own or B)Accept the team with full knowledge that the lvl 20's in a lower rated league is going to suffer sportsmanship penalties.

5. See the interim ownership comment in #2.


which GM would get this team then

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2665

why would a team need that many GM's?????
 
pez35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buck2008
Originally posted by YardRat

1. The next highest rated teams should move up to fill the new void, based on the playoff brackets and then w/l record as the first tie-breaker, conference standing for regular season as the next, etc.

2. Interim ownership via another GM or player currently on the team to finish out the season with the option to remain owner at season's end, or continue with the sale.

3. No cpu players on any roster allowed, except for teams in the bottom tier of their league.

4. Is there an option to buy (accept/deny) for new owners currently when offered a team with no penalty (dropping down/off the list)? If not, there should be. If a new owner wants to field a team with his players in the 20's, then he should be allowed to A)Refuse ownership of a team that is going to restrict his capability to create such a team without losing the opportunity to own or B)Accept the team with full knowledge that the lvl 20's in a lower rated league is going to suffer sportsmanship penalties.

5. See the interim ownership comment in #2.


which GM would get this team then

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2665

why would a team need that many GM's?????


Just another in a long line of terrible owners... I doubt he keeps his team for longer than a season.
 
SkierLegend
offline
Link
 
I don't know if anybody is still reading this far in, but I'll throw my ideas out there anyway.

Edit: I just realized how roundabout I was in answering Bort's original questions. You were probably looking for simpler solutions than the fairly large reorganization I proposed... I apologize. I still think it's an idea worth consideration though.


I think there should be another "league" for recently acquired teams. When a team is sold mid-season, players are released and replaced by CPU. At the end of the season, it would move to this "Interim League" and be replaced by a team from the Interim League best fit to fill the position based on average level, with the tie-breaker being win/loss, then point differential. The day before schedules are simmed, the average level would be calculated and the teams in the Interim League would be separated in to respective sub-leagues based on that level with different leagues for average level 7-12, 13-17, 18-24, etc. (These ranges aren't absolute, I just threw them out there for example's sake). The way I see it, if the range is smaller than teams would be closer within conferences which would help owners recruit because Free Agents won't be discouraged by the team's performance. This would also make a level cap unnecessary. If this means 20 teams in the 7-12 league and only 5 in the 18-24, then so be it. Conferences could then be randomly thrown together within leagues if needed. Of course the range would have to be wider at the levels where the teams are more rare to keep a league feasible. However, if there is only one conference because not many teams fit the criteria, than there is really no problem with that.

The reason that conferences and leagues would be thrown together so lackadaisically leads me to my next point. To keep teams from wanting to be in the Interim League, Win/Loss would be shown but no rankings or playoffs (or at least no reward for winning given. Like I said earlier this puts all teams on an even playing field when it comes to recruiting). Basically it would be an exhibition league. Players will still receive experience as they would normally and Owners would receive money from games just as they would normally. As an incentive to help the owners build a team instead of non-Interim teams becoming overpopulated, a small signing bonus or EXP bonus could be given out to Interim League players. There would also be no Trade deadline for trading within the Interim League.

Just to re-hash, sold teams would move down to the Interim League, and a team with the appropriate skill level from The League would take it's place. Brand new teams would also benefit, because they could be placed in the Interim League as well. The key would be to make the Interim League non-competitive enough that teams want to get better so they can leave, while keeping it rewarding enough and give it enough sense of purpose that players stuck on a relegated team don't feel punished and FA's will sign with Interim teams.

To keep the Interim League population from becoming either stagnant or too large, new leagues could be created as needed and filled with Interim teams based on average level closest to an "ideal value" (variable) established by an administrator specifically for that league.

Originally posted by Bort


(To answer Bort's questions)

1. The team most qualified, based on Average skill level of the team compared with the conference they would be entering. This average would be calculated both at the end of the season (to determine which teams are most qualified for promotion), and again before the schedules are simmed to divide the remaining Interim teams in to fair sub-leagues based on a level range as I described earlier.

2. Give it to a CPU team. (see question 3). That, and/or penalize owners flex-point wise for a mid-season sale.

3. Sure, they'd be a cupcake team. I'm sure anyone would prefer a cupcake team of CPU to a cupcake team of angry, abandoned users. I'm not sure about the logistics of this, but a possible solution is to replace the human team with tailor-made CPUs with the same levels to keep the team somewhat competitive. The CPUs could be erased completely after the season (when the team moves down) and would be non-sign able/tradable to keep the status quo of CPUs as it is now..

4. The Interim wouldn't have a level cap, because it would just be sorted based on level. If a team is sure they can compete immediately and don't want to spend time in the Interim League, then an appeal system could be set up for the Admins to review and assign these teams to leagues as they see fit (or deny the appeal). If that isn't feasible, than they could suck it up and serve their season in the Interim League.

5. If the owner doesn't have the decency to wait until the end of the season, then I say tough luck. If they do sell it at the end of the season, then the new owner could possibly decide wether to keep the team as is, move down to Interim, or release the team and start new.



I know this idea isn't perfect, but I think after a little bit of tampering it could solve the problems. With a little bit of ironing out, it could also solve the "team gutting" problem, though I'm not quite sure how yet. That being said, I don't know much about coding and it could be completely impossible. Constructive criticism is appreciated.
Last edited Jul 8, 2008 13:13:25
 
sew3663
offline
Link
 
What I've seen in other games (Hattrick, a soccer sim) is that once the team goes ownerless, it becomes a CPU team and gets demoted by the traditional method until it is in one of the bottom two levels of the country/region. Then, a new owner can take it over and rebuild from scratch.

With Hattrick, the players aren't owned by anyone, so what could be done is come end of season, all players are released and the roster is refilled with CPU players. These players stay on the team while it falls down to the bottom two leagues. You can allow the CPU players to improve or not.

To improve this, we would need better promotion/demotion movement (Hattrick has 8-team leagues, the top team either plays a qualifier or auto-promotes, the bottom 2 teams auto-demote and the 5th/6th place teams play the lower league 1st place teams for qualifiers). That way, the abandoned teams don't take long to sink to the bottom, only a couple or 3 seasons.
 
tyequity
offline
Link
 
Having read a good number of these posts, here are my thoughts:

1. I agree that the cost of owning a team is way too cheap. I think the fact that you only have to spend 1000 FP (and can get a refund) makes it way too easy to either cheat and gut a team or just give up because you lost interest.

2. I am somewhat new to this (about 2 seasons), but I don't understand why there are not more teams promoted and demoted. I guess in some ways many people may like the continuity of the teams in the conference, but it seems to me that the number of promotions and demotions should be based more on the relative quality of the teams, not just a set number. If there are 5 horrible teams, then they should all be demoted. Further, I think the demotions should be a free fall until you get to the right division based on the quality of the team being demoted. You may still want to make the demoted team the worst in the league, but they should at least be within spitting distance of being competitive. Finally, if you feel like it would be a disservice to promote that many teams to replace the demoted ones (ie those promoted teams would just be next year's fodder), then you may have to replace some demoted teams with brand new CPU teams in the division, which you could then offer for sale by a check box for people who don't mind starting from scratch in a higher level league.

3. Finally, I think it would be great for some of the d-league teams to be human owned or at least have a low tier division that basically starts with a lvl 1 level cap. That way you can basically buy a team and assemble it with players that you and your friends may create day 1 and then have the team move up to a regular division the next year and then go on from there.
 
tmarze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I've seen this idea floated around several times in several threads, and I do kinda like the idea of everyone starting with the same clean slate, bottom rung, when you get a team. There are some issues with the idea, though, so I'm just sort of collecting the various versions of this idea in one spot for discussion.

Basically the idea I've seen is:

When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up?
They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

If it's done after the playoffs .The team that lost in the same conference finals in the lower bracket is moved up,and the team they was sold takes it bumped up teams place in the same conference.If done durring the season the 1st place team of the lower bracket gets bumped up.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?
that team GMs get the 1st shot on buying that team,Players on the team next .Either till the end of the season or a full season with with the adjusted FP cost if it's for till the end of the current season.

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

Good if the CPU players are at that leagues level average.

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

If a player wants to own a team where he can pull his player on the team.He has to check the proper boxes on the current waiting list for league that 20 level players can be signed on.

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Players on the team would have the option.This is where team loyaly could have a effect players,The one with the longest tenure for on that team has the 1st option.Also in effect if that player has owned and sold a team at any time would go to the back of the line.

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.


On these teams, that team GMs has 1st shot at taking over the team,then the players 2nd,going by players tenure on that team.Players with the longest tenure on that team would have the 1st option. 2 players with the same tenure then it comes to 1st come 1st serve.One other note If the players has owned and sold a team still goes to the back of the line.

Last edited Jul 8, 2008 22:54:27
 
jedimster
offline
Link
 
I can see starting them at the bottom,but this simulates the NFL.If I were to buy the New York Giants,I wouldn't lose all my good players just because someone else brought them inI don't like the idea of everyone being released.If you have been on a team since day 1,you start to get a little loyalty to that team.I know I have a some players I would like to keep on the teams they are on.Maybe I'm the only one who feels that way though.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
#1 is easy, move them down at the end of the season and promote more than one team.

#2 Some people havent thought this through.

#3. horrible. at least a human can TRY to get people in midseason.

solution for #4 is clearly to scrap this idea altogether. Think about it. Why do you need sportsmanship? because some teams are vastly supperior, and those tend to be the ones that havent been gutted. To be honest, we suffered last year with a plan to focus only on speed leveling, now we are good, and we are going to be punished for it. bad form.

#5. Has the game become so big that you cant have an employee look and see if a team has been gutted?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.