User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This was the best suggestion on how to balance extreme attributes...
Page:
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
so my 150 confidence dudes are safe? or not?


so sick of these unrealistic extreme builds. neglecting stamina just to pump confidence and break the sim. for shame
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Hopefully they nerf stamina and confidence soon because it is way overpowered in today's sim.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
An issue cuz it doesn't work like 150 strength should.


It does if you have the speed and agility necessary to gain the momentum to use it.


The reason speed is the focus, is because speed is less dependent on other attributes to get the full benefit of having it high. Speed is only reliant on agility for acceleration, and FS greatly reduces that dependency.

 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=125



 
AlBarsch
offline
Link
 
This whole topic is baffling to me... We have the flexibility to build as we see fit, and if I want to build a player with 150+ in an attribute, I'll live with results of not having other atts at, or below, normal levels.

Agree that this whole argument is fueled by agents who don't know how to build dots
 
SAkram
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
Originally posted by jpjn94

Couldn't another option be to link attributes together to reduce how high they could go?

e.g. You can't go higher than 70 in Speed without having 40 in Agility.

You could even at a third attribute to some like the example above you would need a min of 20 in Stamina. Those attributes could be linked all the way up. Then players would be forced to have say 80 in Agility to have 140 in Speed.




 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AlmostDerailed
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN

Making agi>spd when it comes to cutting and acceleration would do the trick if spd is the only concern tbh.


why is not? doesnt agility mean accelerate?


Acceleration used to be like all speed. in season ~3, bort made agility a bigger part of it. The problem is that 10 spd still makes you accelerate faster than 10 agility. Thus there is no benefit to acceleration by having higher agility.
 
Red Sox
offline
Link
 
my only problem is

What about PB's? To get 70 Str how much ________ would you need? Would it be different for each Position?
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AlBarsch
This whole topic is baffling to me... We have the flexibility to build as we see fit, and if I want to build a player with 150+ in an attribute, I'll live with results of not having other atts at, or below, normal levels.

Agree that this whole argument is fueled by agents who don't know how to build dots


So... having skill caps to limit extreme variances but also having an EQ system that nullifies the skill caps was a good design choice? IMO it's like pouring a foundation at spot A and then building your house at spot B. Kind of not so bright.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AlmostDerailed
why is not? doesnt agility mean accelerate?


no agility means athleticism or body control
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
It does if you have the speed and agility necessary to gain the momentum to use it.


The reason speed is the focus, is because speed is less dependent on other attributes to get the full benefit of having it high. Speed is only reliant on agility for acceleration, and FS greatly reduces that dependency.



ok...let me rephrase this then...150 strength doesnt work anymore like it once did. 150+ strength used to be a pancake machine on the oline..now it looks more like a pansy for the most part.

The reason speed is the focus is because that is what is causing the "unrealistic" sim breaking qualities...nothing else does that. But even so...i think its a bit ridiculous to say ok...speed is out of hand...lets nerf every other attribute because of this...

and furthermore...some of the guys i am currently building that go beyond the realm of building nowadays...taking something like Catching to a high level...or agility...or blocking...if they were to make equipment so that you can only put so much into an attribute...it would make me be a complete fool for building outside the normal standards. Since I now can't put near 60 equipment point in speed...suddenly i just have a slow useless WR. Thats fucking great.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Acceleration used to be like all speed. in season ~3, bort made agility a bigger part of it. The problem is that 10 spd still makes you accelerate faster than 10 agility. Thus there is no benefit to acceleration by having higher agility.


There actually is benefit to acceleration by having high agility. It just doesn't work like many people think it does tho.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AlBarsch
This whole topic is baffling to me... We have the flexibility to build as we see fit, and if I want to build a player with 150+ in an attribute, I'll live with results of not having other atts at, or below, normal levels.

Agree that this whole argument is fueled by agents who don't know how to build dots


It's not a question of being able to build those dots or not, it's a question of whether the sim can be balanced around some dots having 150 in one attribute, while other dots have 150 in another attribute. The answer, as we've seen, is lolno

The only way they've "balanced" those players is by making attributes behave retardedly (Take a 100 Strength player, now take a 150 Strength player. Notice any difference? If you do most of it is probably in your head.)

And I mean, we've all seen what a shitstorm people throw when you try to make secondary attributes like Stamina and Confidence actually fucking mean something, because that's the only other reasonable way to balance things like this

But I don't even know why I'm posting this because you're arguing over hypotheticals. The stat system isn't going to change anyway, no matter how shitty it is.
 
HATEMOBSTER
offline
Link
 
Define a balanced sim. People always find something to complain about and rarely one aspect of the sim can be changed without it affecting another. The attributes won't go much higher than they are now even with archetypes. So instead of trying to patch up these "balance" issues, people are suggesting that Bort and co revamp the entire dot building process which has worked since season 1. When you make colossal changes to the game like that it could take seasons and seasons to fully complete.

That's what makes the game enjoyable for many is the ability to create a guy how you want to create him with few limitations. You try out different build types and hope you strike gold. If they made it so attributes were tied together like a few are suggesting, it would basically bring back cookie cutter builds.

They're doing a nice job at fixing what is actually needing to be fixed. The passing game is being looked at, the Dpc revision will help fix some of the bad blocking code complaints and the league structure is being changed. If it's not broke don't fix it.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
There actually is benefit to acceleration by having high agility. It just doesn't work like many people think it does tho.

Correct. From the experiments I've run, I think that speed & agility have about equal effects on acceleration. Each element might be a little too strong, which is why you can still have more than enough acceleration with 3 times as much speed as agility, although that dot becomes a joke when they have to change directions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.