User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This is insane (Promotion complaint)
Page:
 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LC311
Since Bort closed the "loophole" of boosting past day 42 lets look at the following.

Does moving the OP's team to 22 improve competition at level 22?
Does leaving the OP's team in 14 improve competition at level 14?
Does OP's team have an unfair advantage at level 14?






No, yes and no in that order.

But too many here aren't concerning themselves with rational questions and reasonable solutions.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by razor9
That's a rather selective argument. There will be whole teams of level 38's in the the 38 cap that will boost to 41 on day 1. So he's got half a dozen, that means he should be in a 42 cap? What about the rest of his team? They won't even finish the season at or above the cap.


exactly. the way it is now to compete i should release everyone on my roster and recruit higher levels? im sorry but FUCK THAT! im not going to screw the guys over who started playing on my team from day 1. that is simply rediculous and out of the question for me. and the fact that other playoff teams are allowed to to only go up one is simple BULLSHIT
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by razor9
People are not entitled to win anything. But they are entitled to have a an equal shot at winning at the beginning of every season. The playing field has to be level or this whole game is just a sham.

Level 14's, should be with level 14's. So on and so forth. Why is that so much to ask? Why are people so irate at people wanting to play teams of their own skill level? It is quite possible that the OP's team could make the playoffs again, even at the higher level. It is also possible that if he was in a league of all teams the same level as his players that he could miss the playoffs and actually do worse. But from the beginning, you have a chance to compete for the title. In a level 22 cap, he will never have a chance to win it all. That's all he or anyone else is really asking for: a chance to win a title. Not a title itself.

The biggest pie in the face here is the last minute change, after teams have dumped players to stay under cap levels.


Why is it so much to ask that people stop being selfish and only looking at things from their little warped perspective? I understand your point, it sucks but you have to look at the big picture. How do you accomplish it? What do you do with CPU teams? Do you leave them in their current league to throw off competition or do you promote an underleveled team to replace that CPU team? It's just not as easy as you guys make it out to be.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07
Originally posted by razor9

That's a rather selective argument. There will be whole teams of level 38's in the the 38 cap that will boost to 41 on day 1. So he's got half a dozen, that means he should be in a 42 cap? What about the rest of his team? They won't even finish the season at or above the cap.


exactly. the way it is now to compete i should release everyone on my roster and recruit higher levels? im sorry but FUCK THAT! im not going to screw the guys over who started playing on my team from day 1. that is simply rediculous and out of the question for me. and the fact that other playoff teams are allowed to to only go up one is simple BULLSHIT


You are assuming the teams at the 42 cap are 100% level 42+? I just don't think that's true.
 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DarthVisor
+1

Their is no reason for anything else.
Originally posted by Darth Visor
If your team is constantly winning.... guess what.... you've done a good job with your team. Why should you be punished and forced to move to a cap level where your sure to fail.

If your team is constantly losing.... guess what.... you haven't done a good job... maybe you should gut and start over.

A cap is a cap! A cloud is a cloud!

It would be SOOOOOOOO easy to fix all this crap.

First, make caps that are true caps. If your team fits under the cap, you go there. If someone on your team is over a cap, you go up to the next cap.

Next, have a level 1 cap leagues! All these CPU and restarted teams could all go there and play a pee wee like season, then they would be ready to move to cap 14 the next.


Originally posted by bumph
brilliant idea. having level 14's playing level 14's, having level 18's playing against similar leveled players and not having 14's vs players level 22-25.


You'd think this would have been obvious LONG ago. After all, what are the caps for?
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
Another twist to this is that I've seen team who have intentionally lost to make sure they only go up one level and then have players 4 and 5 levels above the cap when season starts (before boosting!).

 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I can only see two actions that can be taken by an owner at this point. One is to be quiet and accept the promotions as they come. The other is to throw an entire season to get demoted to a more appropriate league. If support will not place teams in appropriate leagues than the owners will probably do one of the two choices above.

It is pretty simple. You can only steer people so far until they break away and do their own thing. A league starting at level 1 would prevent this issue. As for now we have a lot of teams starting over and getting misplaced because they did not throw games. It is kind of like saying do not game the system but the only way to get where you need to be is to game the system.

O_o
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
What is so dumb is that this is only a problem because we don't have a L1 cap for the minors so L1 teams are forced into the L14 cap.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xsujx
Originally posted by DarthVisor
+1

Their is no reason for anything else.
Originally posted by Darth Visor

If your team is constantly winning.... guess what.... you've done a good job with your team. Why should you be punished and forced to move to a cap level where your sure to fail.

If your team is constantly losing.... guess what.... you haven't done a good job... maybe you should gut and start over.

A cap is a cap! A cloud is a cloud!

It would be SOOOOOOOO easy to fix all this crap.

First, make caps that are true caps. If your team fits under the cap, you go there. If someone on your team is over a cap, you go up to the next cap.

Next, have a level 1 cap leagues! All these CPU and restarted teams could all go there and play a pee wee like season, then they would be ready to move to cap 14 the next.


Originally posted by bumph

brilliant idea. having level 14's playing level 14's, having level 18's playing against similar leveled players and not having 14's vs players level 22-25.


You'd think this would have been obvious LONG ago. After all, what are the caps for?


How do you accomplish this? Also, Caps are not for the minimum level so that's not what they are for. They are to keep teams from signing players way above the league level.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
What exactly does KC have to do with this?

Ok, Jiddy, how exactly do we do that?


Rage already put in the ticket...Look a bit back.

And KC was a response to your "entitlement" palabra...You reap what you sow there by calling others out when you jump on a team that was easily a seamless ride to an LOLtrophy with their talent and the way the sim ran 2 seasons ago...Anyone with eyes could see that TBH. I like Sexxy Buxxy and felt bad what the sim overhaul to HB passing did to y'all this season though. I'm sure he's torqued about it...
Edited by Jiddy78 on Jan 20, 2010 13:10:38
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07
Originally posted by razor9

That's a rather selective argument. There will be whole teams of level 38's in the the 38 cap that will boost to 41 on day 1. So he's got half a dozen, that means he should be in a 42 cap? What about the rest of his team? They won't even finish the season at or above the cap.


exactly. the way it is now to compete i should release everyone on my roster and recruit higher levels? im sorry but FUCK THAT! im not going to screw the guys over who started playing on my team from day 1. that is simply rediculous and out of the question for me. and the fact that other playoff teams are allowed to to only go up one is simple BULLSHIT


Please link these other teams that were able to go up 1 cap. In the past that was certainly the case but since last seasons changes I haven't seen that.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DarthVisor
Another twist to this is that I've seen team who have intentionally lost to make sure they only go up one level and then have players 4 and 5 levels above the cap when season starts (before boosting!).



Exploiters will cause problems no matter the system.
 
LC311
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Why is it so much to ask that people stop being selfish and only looking at things from their little warped perspective? I understand your point, it sucks but you have to look at the big picture. How do you accomplish it? What do you do with CPU teams? Do you leave them in their current league to throw off competition or do you promote an underleveled team to replace that CPU team? It's just not as easy as you guys make it out to be.


So we all can assume that your own team won't be dropping down to level 22 capped for s14?
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
What is so dumb is that this is only a problem because we don't have a L1 cap for the minors so L1 teams are forced into the L14 cap.


Isn't that the point of peewee teams?
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
What is so dumb is that this is only a problem because we don't have a L1 cap for the minors so L1 teams are forced into the L14 cap.


This says the most with the least amount of words. I like it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.