User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarletmbb
I like it, except for 5/6. I can be done without that to prevent exploitation. Why don't you just use a ratio as a multiplier, like (avg opp lvl)/(your avg lvl) and adjust it with starters?


won't people just put there worst players in as starters and ajust the sub out to get the real players (backups in more)

like the idea but it would have to be based on team lev not starters i think..
 
Major League
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


We don't punish good teams. In fact, they end up with more cash, good morale, high fan support. Good teams don't need to be propped up because they are, well, good.


Which is basically funding only the Owners not the players...Good try though

Try coming up with an idea that benefits the players that are higher leveled. Not just the noobs. I see this only the downfall of this game is long-term. You just keep hurting the higher leveled guys.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 18:58:28
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kostitsyn
Alright.

Let's say, my guy is level 21, I want to make the playoffs, but good team in USA pro league arent interested in my guy cause they are already deep at my position. I gotta sign in a lower league, but in lower league especially you cant trust many GM's. I signed for a guy that i didnt know once and he screwed me over so I'm not interested in trying my luck any time soon. I want to play on a team i know the manager a little. Most are like USA BBB, Canada AAA, EE AAA and stuff. Those league level are lower.

My guy gets better slower soi next time my contract expires my guy will have an even harder time finding room in USA Pro. What are my options? I pay to help the game and develope my guys, but suddenly my ceiling are lower because I cant find a team that suits my needs in USA Pro.

And on the other side, a guy could just buy a team in USA pro, get only level 1 on it, make the league elss competitive and up his ceiling by like 15%. I dont see why it should happen. The guy instead of getting 12000 XP(12 levels) pre boost he gets 13800. That's like 2 more levels so he's be level 17 instead of being level 15.

The level 15, will have to start in D-league so even elss XP before finding a low levl league that will want his player so no big XP boost and stuff. Reacing level 14-15 will be evn harder to reach after a season while the guy that screws a league up will reach level 17. It doesnt really work...



unless if you only give the bonus out if the beat the better team..
 
kostitsyn
offline
Link
 
Also, The top AAA team will improve slower since they are on top while the 12th team in USA will imporove faster since they are lower then the averga henc making it even harder for team to stick at the next level and not getting relegated.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Major League
Originally posted by Bort



We don't punish good teams. In fact, they end up with more cash, good morale, high fan support. Good teams don't need to be propped up because they are, well, good.


Which is basically funding only the Owners not the players...Good try though

Try coming up with an idea that benefits the players that are higher leveled. Not just the noobs. I see this only the downfall of this game is long-term. You just keep hurting the higher leveled guys.


It only hurts higher level guys if they insist on playing in the lower level leagues. Sign a contract in the pros and there is no issue, also maybe AAA shouldn't have a penalty, or it should be very difficult to be penalized (i.e. an 8-10 level deviation from average, where BBB could be a 4-5 level deviation)

 
Major League
offline
Link
 
Ok, getting into the pros is just so easy for everyone.
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
This is a terrible idea IMHO. Why would you punish a player for helping out a team in other leagues like South America and other lower leagues. If this suggestion gets put into action, every high level player will rush for the USA leagues like they already are, leaving other leagues dried out with lvl 1's and 2's. Whats the point in having D leagues. I would say this is an ok rule for D leagues, but not any other league. I figured the goal for Bort and GLB was to make every league competetive, not make one the super league, and others like the current D leagues.

Also, If this rule is made and everyone rushes for the USA leagues, there will be too many people in the USA leagues, and no one will want to move down because they will lose exp. I just think it’s a terrible idea all around.

Edit - What would be the insentive of staying with a team you started out with. say you boost your player, but your team and other teams in the league dont. Your players lvl would get higher than theirs, and then you would have to leave your team. I thought we were trying to find ways to stop people from leaving their teams.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 21:08:31
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Major League
Ok, getting into the pros is just so easy for everyone.
He's got a point. There are players that can't get into the pro leagues as is, how difficult will it be when there's a definitive border line where if you're above it, you have to either be in Pro leagues or take an XP hit?
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
The only thing I would agree with would be maybe a xp plus for playing higher lvl people, not a penalty.
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
By the way, I just checked... the average USA Pro level is 16. There's a level 24 kicker. Does that mean that the kicker is now penalized for playing in the top league?


Great ?, maybe been answered, havent got to it yet though.

As for cap limits, it would be EXTREMLY easy now. Bort has made all those pretty avg.'s of the leagues, well just take BBB for example. Take the A League teams. Take the highest player on each team, avg. those players, then take 75% of that for the ceiling on the BBB's. By that time, anybody in BBB that is pushing lvl 16, 17, or so, needs to step up and get their ass out of BBB.

Then, for A, take the AA Leagues, take the top player on each AA team, avg. them, and take 75% of that for the ceiling on A.

And so on, and so on up the ladder. Of course Pro dont have a ceiling. But, just have the calculations run every night, so it can adjust to the player pool in each league division. It wouldnt be hard, and it is totally based of the make-up of the leagues, so then no 1 team can kill the avg. of the divisions.

If a playe is well aware of this threshold, then they need to be looking elsewhere when they are approaching it. But, since the threshold adjusts, it would take into account the non-ability for people to move up due to lack of upper echelon leagues for them to move too. If the AAA starts to bulge with lvl 20's, then the threshold grows closer to the Pros. Since they will be getting a higher ceiling constantly.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
I like the bonus. My brother just signed with a pro team as a level 8. Qb none the less. I have had my fair share of offers too for backup positions but it is not what I am trying to do as far as my player builds. Alot of high level guys just want to pump their own ego because they were here first and would love to beat up on the noobs to maintain their 300 yrd a game average with no penalty.
 
cardfan
offline
Link
 
I'm not going to lie. I didn't read all of this, so My suggestion may have been presented.

Make money important.

The higher the league you're in the more money you make.

Make Hall of Fame stats be weighted to the highest league/s.

Curtail the ability to "manufacture" money.

Offer higher ticket/concessions prices for the higher leagues.

Slight bonus for playing above yourself. Same for playing below yourself. You could be on a friends team and be the highest/lowest player in the league, but you would/wouldn't benefit as much from it.

Make special equipment that is expensive enough to warrant playing in higher leagues.

Increase the # of teams that "have" to move up/down leagues due to performance. This should keep the cream rising and the slackers falling. This should also keep the highest leagues stocked with the best teams.

Some people will be more then happy to have outlandish stats, but if they count for nothing and won't be recorded anywhere, it may squash some of them.

Make someone ineligible if they way out class the league they play in. A level 20 shouldn't be able to join a team that averages level 8 or less, or something like that. On the converse, you probably shouldn't be able to have someone on a team that averages 20, that is a level 8. I understand being able to develop players, but way out classed player should develop somewhere else, like college or high school.That is what it is like right now to be a level 5 in a league that is all 15 or higher.you're putting a peach fuzz kid out there playing with men. The ratio isn't set, just an example to work with.

Oh well, I've said a lot.

Vive el Bort!

 
crazymorg
offline
Link
 
i hate this idea

the only way id like it any way is if you only used the starters for teams

otherwise every single starter will be way above the average for the league

how the heck are any leagues supposed to get any good players if this gets implemented
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazymorg
i hate this idea

the only way id like it any way is if you only used the starters for teams

otherwise every single starter will be way above the average for the league

how the heck are any leagues supposed to get any good players if this gets implemented


It's already nearly impossible for my BBB team to sign a player who's level is in line with the rest of our team... it would be pointless if they added penalties on top of that.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jcdawg23
If this suggestion gets put into action, every high level player will rush for the USA leagues like they already are, leaving other leagues dried out with lvl 1's and 2's.


That seems to be what people want in general.

Although, I don't think they would just "rush for USA." They'd just rush for the higher tier leagues and stay away from the low ones. Lv 1's and 2's aren't going to care where they play, but high level guys will. Hmm...isn't that the idea we're trying to accomplish?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.