User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tagging players is ready
Page:
 
Mr. Likable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coach
Yep. So again we are letting the defense adjust to the offense, but not letting the offense adjust to the defense? Awesome.


That's right. We do one thing then Nerf it next season when their is clear advantage because of it. Then somewhere down the line we will fix to make it right, but then because of the Nerf. Its no longer right so we have Nerf again and again and again. By then people get fed up with it.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Funny thing is that if, say, I have to add all those extra inputs to account for tagging then it's highly likely that the D AI will run into the KB limit set on the server and be unable to be loaded anyway. It already happens with large AIs. How is that going to be handled?

Think it's time to throw in the towel and stop DCing. Not really looking forward to adding this sort of extreme detail to an already large AI. Especially considering how bad the interface is and how long it would take to create a new input and then manually move it down to where it needs to be. Just that aspect will take hours. Why isn't there an add input near all the existing inputs so it could be added where it's needed instead of always at the top. Easy with simple AIs, impossibly time-consuming with detailed AIs.

 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chris LeDoux
This is going to annoy me I think.

Defense shouldn't be able to react nearly as well as this will let them to. Especially if both QBs are on the field. If it's just the rusher out there, then you can sell out, but when you have the rusher and passer in the huddle together you can't automagically know which will line up where. Even though motion isn't represented visually (except the testing TE stuff), I should be allowed to suffer OOP in order to create mismatches.

"BUT WAIT!" The haters cry! "You have a rushing qb! This is obviously biased self interest!"

Some is self interest, most is just interest in getting this game working well - his lolbar is dark green, which means I put more into vision than any pure rusher needs to - his passing attributes are being built now and he'll be a threat on short passes soon enough.

But if I want to have Sonic in the game at the same time as the passing QB and split Hedgehog out to WR, you shouldn't be able to react to him being at WR until he actually goes in motion. Same deal for the passer - him moving from shotgun to slot shouldn't let you magic into your safety blitz + DE flats.


Defensive audibles would let you do this, yes.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
Especially considering how bad the interface is and how long it would take to create a new input and then manually move it down to where it needs to be. Just that aspect will take hours. Why isn't there an add input near all the existing inputs so it could be added where it's needed instead of always at the top.


TO THE SUGGESTIONS FORUM!
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coach
Originally posted by phthalatemagic

This is a bad idea.


Yep. So again we are letting the defense adjust to the offense, but not letting the offense adjust to the defense? Awesome.


And on top of that the DC has access to every possible play the offense has in its playbook. Even more awesome...
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82
Originally posted by Chris LeDoux

This is going to annoy me I think.

Defense shouldn't be able to react nearly as well as this will let them to. Especially if both QBs are on the field. If it's just the rusher out there, then you can sell out, but when you have the rusher and passer in the huddle together you can't automagically know which will line up where. Even though motion isn't represented visually (except the testing TE stuff), I should be allowed to suffer OOP in order to create mismatches.

"BUT WAIT!" The haters cry! "You have a rushing qb! This is obviously biased self interest!"

Some is self interest, most is just interest in getting this game working well - his lolbar is dark green, which means I put more into vision than any pure rusher needs to - his passing attributes are being built now and he'll be a threat on short passes soon enough.

But if I want to have Sonic in the game at the same time as the passing QB and split Hedgehog out to WR, you shouldn't be able to react to him being at WR until he actually goes in motion. Same deal for the passer - him moving from shotgun to slot shouldn't let you magic into your safety blitz + DE flats.


Defensive audibles would let you do this, yes.


Defensive audibles wouldnt let you change personnel out. Hell, I think people in this forum vastly overstate how common it is for coaches to swap in/out players based on who the opposing team has on the field.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
And on top of that the DC has access to every possible play the offense has in its playbook. Even more awesome...


I didn't think OPC was necessary but now that tagging has been introduced, it is needed to level the playing field for the offense.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
Funny thing is that if, say, I have to add all those extra inputs to account for tagging then it's highly likely that the D AI will run into the KB limit set on the server and be unable to be loaded anyway. It already happens with large AIs. How is that going to be handled?

Think it's time to throw in the towel and stop DCing. Not really looking forward to adding this sort of extreme detail to an already large AI. Especially considering how bad the interface is and how long it would take to create a new input and then manually move it down to where it needs to be. Just that aspect will take hours. Why isn't there an add input near all the existing inputs so it could be added where it's needed instead of always at the top. Easy with simple AIs, impossibly time-consuming with detailed AIs.



As an OC, everything I do is with keeping things simple in mind. This is why I didn't use packages, it actually took me longer to update packages and keep my AI as versatile and still somewhat "random".
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Defensive audibles wouldnt let you change personnel out. Hell, I think people in this forum vastly overstate how common it is for coaches to swap in/out players based on who the opposing team has on the field.


Yeah but IRL defense gets the last move, because the offense has to be set and snap while the defense can still be adjusting. So for a split second, the defense gets to see the offensive formation and personnel and make adjustments if necessary. But yes, at that late stage not personnel adjustments.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82

Originally posted by Toriq
Especially considering how bad the interface is and how long it would take to create a new input and then manually move it down to where it needs to be. Just that aspect will take hours. Why isn't there an add input near all the existing inputs so it could be added where it's needed instead of always at the top. Easy with simple AIs, impossibly time-consuming with detailed AIs.



TO THE SUGGESTIONS FORUM!


LOL! Fixing the UI has been suggested repeatedly but it has never been changed. AJAX, anyone?

T

 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
LOL! Fixing the UI has been suggested repeatedly but it has never been changed. AJAX, anyone?

T



passing rollouts, anyone? o_o
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82
Originally posted by taurran

Defensive audibles wouldnt let you change personnel out. Hell, I think people in this forum vastly overstate how common it is for coaches to swap in/out players based on who the opposing team has on the field.


Yeah but IRL defense gets the last move, because the offense has to be set and snap while the defense can still be adjusting. So for a split second, the defense gets to see the offensive formation and personnel and make adjustments if necessary. But yes, at that late stage not personnel adjustments.


Um... sorry but defenses do not make personell adjustments after the offense is set. They may shift and/or change up coverage assignments, but they don't substitute players. Offenses try to make play calls quick and efficient, and in many cases, run no-huddle offenses to combat defense making adjustments to the play call.

Just as defenses are able to adjust, so are offenses through audibles and adjustments to blocking assignments based on the defensive formation.

The offense is ultimately in control of what happens on the field. In GLB, the offense has very little as far as options and the defense has every tool to predict and adjust to the short list of plays that can be called in a situation.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Um... sorry but defenses do not make personell adjustments after the offense is set. They may shift and/or change up coverage assignments, but they don't substitute players. Offenses try to make play calls quick and efficient, and in many cases, run no-huddle offenses to combat defense making adjustments to the play call.

Just as defenses are able to adjust, so are offenses through audibles and adjustments to blocking assignments based on the defensive formation.

The offense is ultimately in control of what happens on the field. In GLB, the offense has very little as far as options and the defense has every tool to predict and adjust to the short list of plays that can be called in a situation.


I said not personnel adjustments, taurran.
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Being an OC in this game sucks balls. It already takes 1-2 hours to gameplan for a competitive game, now it's just going to be that much more of a waste of time.


Originally posted by taurran
Who the fuck are you kidding? It takes 5x as long for an OC to plan than it does a DC. The offensive AI requires a level of detail far and above anything DCs have ever had to put up with.


So you take 1-2 hours to set an offensive for your competitive games? I spend up to 4-5 hours to set up my defense for competitive games (seriously). If you add in having to cover "tagged" players it will be ridiculous.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82
Originally posted by taurran

Um... sorry but defenses do not make personell adjustments after the offense is set. They may shift and/or change up coverage assignments, but they don't substitute players. Offenses try to make play calls quick and efficient, and in many cases, run no-huddle offenses to combat defense making adjustments to the play call.

Just as defenses are able to adjust, so are offenses through audibles and adjustments to blocking assignments based on the defensive formation.

The offense is ultimately in control of what happens on the field. In GLB, the offense has very little as far as options and the defense has every tool to predict and adjust to the short list of plays that can be called in a situation.


I said not personnel adjustments, taurran.


I'm saying personnel adjustments have been far overstated as being realistic and/or needed... at all. The defense currently has an upper hand in play calling, and will have an even greater advantage next season when this goes in.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.