User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


I just can't stress this enough: "Coaches" should have ZERO effect on a player's long-term build.



If it does, we will just bring in coaches on SB teams, and optimize the boost to our players builds. Then anyone who doesn't have these coaches will be at an ever bigger disadvantage. Further separating the new gamer, from the Established vets of this game.
Their is no way bort would allow coaches to actually give us a boost to a players build is there? If coaches have any affect on a players build, then he would essentially be saying, you need to spend X amount more to play this game, if you want to have a player who will be successful. I mean every agent in the game who plays this game seriously would be forced to have coaches on every new team. If this is a thought of Borts, then I would just say raise the price of flex, and save us the time of filling in coaches on all these teams to get these boosts you are talking about.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fbfan18
Any thoughts on having Coaches move up in ranks as well? Say they must spend a season in the Cloud and could only move up to AA after a full season in the cloud? And so on to Pro after 4 seasons of Coaching minimum? Would be an interesting concept to create a "career" for a Coach.


I wonder if coaching levels would play into this idea.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AngryDragon

Meh..

If I really wanted to train blocking at such a low percent of a training bonus and got a bonus from a coach. We would probably be talking about gaining 1 point in 20 trainings rather than 34. So yes that is kind of big but still very time consuming. I would mean I could gain 1 point from training in a season rather than two.

Still I agree there are many other bonuses to be gained from coaches that can affect the strategy of the sim rather than player builds. Player builds should probably be equal for all players like you are saying.

Someone mentioned buying plays that might cause more bugs since the testing group would be limited. I was thinking that buying player tactics might be pretty cool. Again this might also lead to more bugs due to a limited testing group.


We had definitely discussed the idea of having coaches unlock new tactics options. However, we don't have all that many more tactics options on tap, so it might not really be worth it unless some options get removed only to be re-enabled by coaches. I'm focusing more on the gameplanning and other tactical ideas.


I really dislike taking away any of the current player tactics just to re-enable them later.

I really think the current player tactics actually needs to be made a lot more robust (there's a suggestion thread from me floating around about this).
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fbfan18
Any thoughts on having Coaches move up in ranks as well? Say they must spend a season in the Cloud and could only move up to AA after a full season in the cloud? And so on to Pro after 4 seasons of Coaching minimum? Would be an interesting concept to create a "career" for a Coach.


I can here the World League teams bitching already....LOL but it is an interesting idea.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fbfan18
Any thoughts on having Coaches move up in ranks as well? Say they must spend a season in the Cloud and could only move up to AA after a full season in the cloud? And so on to Pro after 4 seasons of Coaching minimum? Would be an interesting concept to create a "career" for a Coach.


I'd think that would naturally happen anyway.

I like drifter's idea of higher levels making the coach's morale go down if he is not in a high enough position, though. Would enforce the coach trying to improve his lot. It might be worthwhile to extend that idea to players, too, at some point...play as lv 60 in uncapped minors and you start to lose morale, etc.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by fbfan18

Any thoughts on having Coaches move up in ranks as well? Say they must spend a season in the Cloud and could only move up to AA after a full season in the cloud? And so on to Pro after 4 seasons of Coaching minimum? Would be an interesting concept to create a "career" for a Coach.


I'd think that would naturally happen anyway.

I like drifter's idea of higher levels making the coach's morale go down if he is not in a high enough position, though. Would enforce the coach trying to improve his lot. It might be worthwhile to extend that idea to players, too, at some point...play as lv 60 in uncapped minors and you start to lose morale, etc.


I like this here.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by fbfan18


Any thoughts on having Coaches move up in ranks as well? Say they must spend a season in the Cloud and could only move up to AA after a full season in the cloud? And so on to Pro after 4 seasons of Coaching minimum? Would be an interesting concept to create a "career" for a Coach.


I'd think that would naturally happen anyway.

I like drifter's idea of higher levels making the coach's morale go down if he is not in a high enough position, though. Would enforce the coach trying to improve his lot. It might be worthwhile to extend that idea to players, too, at some point...play as lv 60 in uncapped minors and you start to lose morale, etc.


I like this here.


Me too.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I like drifter's idea of higher levels making the coach's morale go down if he is not in a high enough position, though. Would enforce the coach trying to improve his lot. It might be worthwhile to extend that idea to players, too, at some point...play as lv 60 in uncapped minors and you start to lose morale, etc.


Isn't that part of the point of suggested levels? You could just lower the range on them and increase the penalty.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern

If it does, we will just bring in coaches on SB teams, and optimize the boost to our players builds. Then anyone who doesn't have these coaches will be at an ever bigger disadvantage. Further separating the new gamer, from the Established vets of this game.
Their is no way bort would allow coaches to actually give us a boost to a players build is there? If coaches have any affect on a players build, then he would essentially be saying, you need to spend X amount more to play this game, if you want to have a player who will be successful. I mean every agent in the game who plays this game seriously would be forced to have coaches on every new team. If this is a thought of Borts, then I would just say raise the price of flex, and save us the time of filling in coaches on all these teams to get these boosts you are talking about.



Again, you're on the money. Having "coaches" affect long-term builds would be bad for the game.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
BORT, If you really want coaches to work and be realistic. Allow us to "Watch film" with our position coach. Then give us say 5 options per player.

Free safety watches film, decides team A runs 5 Favorite plays. He studies plays, and when he sees these plays he gets.

Play 1) HB Screen Ace X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 2) Strong I slam .8X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 3)Shotgun Screen .6x% boost
Play 4 etc
Play 5 etc
This way we could actually game plan, and use "Coaches" to give our players boosts to these teams who abuse the same 4-5 plays game in game out. Would force teams to truly devise schemes, and really come up with new game plans week to week.

Edit: this would take more work, but I Don't want coaches to be some BS thing that just gives people a reward for having them. I Want people to have to study, and work to get advantages out of these coaches, not just some Free pass for finding this website first.
Edited by David Stern on Sep 3, 2009 23:04:16
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Seems like it would be better for there to be a penalty of some sort for making switches willy-nilly. Either a limit to the number of switches, or it costs something every time you switch.


A simple cost might be best, but here's a random brainstorming idea. You could have something like workout groups. If a group was accustomed to practicing together they'd be a little better, and if a group member was lost they might get a little worse, at least until they'd gotten used to the new player.

So lets say a lineman coach selected 4 players to coach, giving each +1 strength at the start. Then each game (or two) that the group is together each member gains an additional +1 strength up to a maximum of +5 total. Later if the coach drops one player and adds another the strength gained for everyone in that group drops and has to be re-earned over time.



Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 23:03:59
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Agreed, your player should not suffer build wise because you have no or shitty coaches.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Isn't that part of the point of suggested levels? You could just lower the range on them and increase the penalty.


I like the suggested levels for coaches in tiers. That way they can be relaxed in seasoon 12. Then adjusted in season 13 to nudge the higher leveled coaches to the higher tiers. The suggested levels could be adjusted every season until they work like player levels in the tiers.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Agreed, your player should not suffer build wise because you have no or shitty coaches.


Agreed.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Agreed, your player should not suffer build wise because you have no or shitty coaches.


I'm more afraid of the opposite. Players rotating amongst teams to fulfill specific intense training combos they "need". The idea in general of providing player x a superior build path to player y scares me.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.