User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
HoyaHater
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I like the "pick game to analyze" idea. Instead of just last 3/4 games (perhaps that could just be the default)


Definitely... blowout games over gut/CPU teams do not provide any useful information. Indeed, they skew the stats.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


This would detract nothing from being a "better" scout.

It would merely decrease the value of being an OCD scout with dozens of hours to waste on GLB every day by allowing the better scout to do his thing in a tenth of the time.

Just as it will allow the lousy scout to do his thing more quickly as well.

ALL this would do is avoid all the data mining and entry, basically. You would still need to understand, sort, and apply the data for it to be successful or not.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
I am with yello1, saving users time they spend in breaking down game films can only help the game. Speaking as an OC, if a defense managed to pick up something from previous games and stop me then it is praises for the DC and boos for me. Quality scouting tools will help me save time, so I can make my opponents scouting even more useless. Not to talk about the improved relationship with my wife.



Seriously.

Winnowing film has caused more than one or two fights and garnered me many a disparaging WTF why are we doing nothing again this weekend while you sit at the computer.

Not to mention the decreased work productivity.
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
This probably will be unlocked by Coaches Bort?

An O guy can break down the film on Opponent's D

A D guy can break down the film on Opponent's D

 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
This would detract nothing from being a "better" scout.

It would merely decrease the value of being an OCD scout with dozens of hours to waste on GLB every day by allowing the better scout to do his thing in a tenth of the time.

Just as it will allow the lousy scout to do his thing more quickly as well.

ALL this would do is avoid all the data mining and entry, basically. You would still need to understand, sort, and apply the data for it to be successful or not.


I agree with you 100%. Rare thing, isn't it? lol
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
So I've got the offense scouting portion mostly done, and it's pretty neat IMO. One of the testers was going to put up some screenshots; I don't know if that's happened yet, but I'm sure it will.

Anyway, I was thinking about the defense scouting and I realized it's probably not really all that useful to just know what formations they used most, as it doesn't really tell you where their weaknesses are. It'd be more useful to know how they did vs particular types of plays that their opponents ran. So...basically I'm thinking I'd make it show offensive production, similar to the O scouting report, for their opponents. Then you could see which types of plays gashed the D the most.

Ideas?
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So I've got the offense scouting portion mostly done, and it's pretty neat IMO. One of the testers was going to put up some screenshots; I don't know if that's happened yet, but I'm sure it will.

Anyway, I was thinking about the defense scouting and I realized it's probably not really all that useful to just know what formations they used most, as it doesn't really tell you where their weaknesses are. It'd be more useful to know how they did vs particular types of plays that their opponents ran. So...basically I'm thinking I'd make it show offensive production, similar to the O scouting report, for their opponents. Then you could see which types of plays gashed the D the most.

Ideas?


I think your theory is correct, but the teams we need to scout and gameplan the most, don't run plays they aren't successful running. Is it too much to show which plays they run the most?
 
Kruelgor
offline
Link
 
Honestly? I would like to see a break down on what the opponent does on 1st and 10's outside of the red zone. This is what I do anyway when I scout an opponent. 1st and 10's are very important and are the most unpredictable when facing an opponent so good scouting info here would be of great benefit.

EXAMPLE:

1st and 10 report
-----------------------
Pass Attempts - 6
Rush Attempts - 3
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays

You can have a selection button which will just show the previous games stats and then the entire season's stats. You can also provide the same kind of report for the Red Zone.
Edited by Kruelgor on Aug 19, 2009 15:07:25
Edited by Kruelgor on Aug 19, 2009 15:05:39
Edited by Kruelgor on Aug 19, 2009 15:05:21
Edited by Kruelgor on Aug 19, 2009 15:01:09
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kruelgor
Honestly? I would like to see a break down on what the opponent does on 1st and 10's outside of field goal range. This is what I do anyway when I scout an opponent. 1st and 10's are very important and are the most unpredictable when facing an opponent so good scouting info here would be of great benefit.

EXAMPLE:

1st and 10 report
-----------------------
Pass Attempts - 6
Rush Attempts - 3
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays
Name of the Play - % of total plays


I can't disagree, but I'd hope that would be included in with an every down scenario.
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
Number of times a position blitzed by formation
Edited by razor9 on Aug 19, 2009 15:18:01
Edited by razor9 on Aug 19, 2009 15:16:48
Edited by razor9 on Aug 19, 2009 15:16:08
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
For the Defense:

% of the time that CB, SS, FS, ROLB, MLB, LOLB, LDE, RDE, DT, and NT blitz versus each formation.
% of the time that CB, SS, FS, ROLB, MLB, LOLB, LDE, DRE, DT, and NT do man coverage versus each formation.

% of the time that team uses 4-3, 3-4, Dime, etc.
% of the time that team uses 4-3, 3-4, Dime, etc. against each formation.

Players or Team %s:
Forced Fumbles per tackle ratio
Knocked Loose per tackle ratio
Missed Tackles per tackle ratio
Deflected Passes per man coverage
Blown Coverages
Sack to Blitz ratio
Hurry to Blitz ratio
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
For the Defense:

% of the time that CB, SS, FS, ROLB, MLB, LOLB, LDE, RDE, DT, and NT blitz versus each formation.
% of the time that CB, SS, FS, ROLB, MLB, LOLB, LDE, DRE, DT, and NT do man coverage versus each formation.

% of the time that team uses 4-3, 3-4, Dime, etc.
% of the time that team uses 4-3, 3-4, Dime, etc. against each formation.

Players or Team %s:
Forced Fumbles per tackle ratio
Knocked Loose per tackle ratio
Missed Tackles per tackle ratio
Deflected Passes per man coverage
Blown Coverages
Sack to Blitz ratio
Hurry to Blitz ratio

That's a good way to do it, although D-linemen cannot play man coverage.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I DC and OC. I will try to list some of the things I look for when scouting.

DC
1. Oline vs D line matchups
2. Secondary vs WR matchups
3. LBs vs HBs, FBs, and TEs matchups
4. On passing plays do they prefer streak routs or slants and post routes?
5. How often does the HB or FB run a route and from what formations?
6. What do they call on 3rd or 4th and short?
7. What do they do inside the redzone?
8. Do they have a rushing QB or is a QB in the TE1 or TE2 slot?
9. Who is in their custom slots?

OC
1. Oline vs D line matchups
2. Secondary vs WR matchups
3. LBs vs HBs, FBs, and TEs matchups
4. I look for the safety coverage for each formation in 1st and 2nd down situations.
5. I look for the type of defense they run 3-4 vs 4-3. Does this change in nickel or dime situations?
6. Who generally picks up the HB or FB in passing situations.
7. Look for any zone defensive calls.
8. Are there any common plays that other teams have used successfully vs this team?
9. Who is in their custom slots?
Edited by AngryDragon on Aug 19, 2009 20:56:58
 
Vitamin Water
offline
Link
 
Will this only be available for team owners, scouts, OC's, DC's, and other like gm's?
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So I've got the offense scouting portion mostly done, and it's pretty neat IMO. One of the testers was going to put up some screenshots; I don't know if that's happened yet, but I'm sure it will.

Anyway, I was thinking about the defense scouting and I realized it's probably not really all that useful to just know what formations they used most, as it doesn't really tell you where their weaknesses are. It'd be more useful to know how they did vs particular types of plays that their opponents ran. So...basically I'm thinking I'd make it show offensive production, similar to the O scouting report, for their opponents. Then you could see which types of plays gashed the D the most.

Ideas?


Allow that to be filtered by the ratings variance between them and their opponents.

IE Let me filter out the games where they were beating up CPU teams that were rated 9 points lower, and the flip side of that where they were the punching bag for someone else. Let me see equal matched opponents, or closely matched etc.

Then, that becomes interesting indeed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.