User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The time has come to remove the Click and Drag of the Defensive Line in the DPC
Page:
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=588100&pbp_id=14909521

Totally realistic! I love the d-line setup here!
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by kurieg

Why is that a problem?

Because even the best defensive linemen don't get instant sacks, which is what the "win first roll -> speed boost -> SACK!" essentially amounts to.

Originally posted by kurieg

The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.

I get so tired of every flaw in the sim being labeled an "exploit," and every attempt to address those flaws being labeled a "nerf." When a problem is caused by something Bort changed in the sim, then Bort changing something to address it is not a nerf, it's simply correcting an unintended consequence. I want defensive linemen to be capable of breaking a double team or splitting a gap, but it is a little too potent right now because of the speed boost and the limit on blocking angles.


Um, there's a big diff between a fast sack and an "insta" sack.

Bort changed something in the sim because he felt that DEs were utterly unable to generate pressure. He basically nerfed pass blocking. That mechanic is doing what it's coded to do, i.e., it's unbugged. IF Bort decides it's now too easy to get that sack in this manner, then any change will be, by definition, a nerf.

I don't think nerfs are bad, in general.

I have a very, very real concern that this will be overdone. I think that most LGs are shit poor pass-blockers. They should get owned, and hard and fast.

Let them adjust before deciding if the mechanic is OP.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by kurieg

Why is that a problem?

Because even the best defensive linemen don't get instant sacks, which is what the "win first roll -> speed boost -> SACK!" essentially amounts to.

Originally posted by kurieg

The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.

I get so tired of every flaw in the sim being labeled an "exploit," and every attempt to address those flaws being labeled a "nerf." When a problem is caused by something Bort changed in the sim, then Bort changing something to address it is not a nerf, it's simply correcting an unintended consequence. I want defensive linemen to be capable of breaking a double team or splitting a gap, but it is a little too potent right now because of the speed boost and the limit on blocking angles.


Fixing unintended consequences is a nerf. Just as Tdm and Kureig. If Bort screws up he should have to live with his screw-up for all eternity.

BTW, I'm not !pass rushing. Just !this thing.
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 17, 2009 13:25:09
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
That if you look at any successful pro team and you see them using this strategy should tell you that its obviously got a problem in that it performs better than it should and is logical.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by kurieg


Why is that a problem?

Because even the best defensive linemen don't get instant sacks, which is what the "win first roll -> speed boost -> SACK!" essentially amounts to.

Originally posted by kurieg


The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.

I get so tired of every flaw in the sim being labeled an "exploit," and every attempt to address those flaws being labeled a "nerf." When a problem is caused by something Bort changed in the sim, then Bort changing something to address it is not a nerf, it's simply correcting an unintended consequence. I want defensive linemen to be capable of breaking a double team or splitting a gap, but it is a little too potent right now because of the speed boost and the limit on blocking angles.


Fixing unintended consequences is a nerf. Just as Tdm and Kureig. If Bort screws up he should have to live with his screw-up for all eternity.

BTW, I'm not !pass rushing. Just !this thing.


Of course it's a nerf. That doesn't make it a good or bad thing. Some nerfs are needed.

This one isn't justified yet imo. Meta-game needs time to catch up, or some very good testing needs to take place. Right now, overall pass rush stats are not that high at all. We don't need to return to the days of DEs doing nothing.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
If the defense can generate pressure before this problem, and then the bug is fixed and defenses can no longer generate pressure, then it's a NERF. It may be an unintended consequence, but if he's going to fix this bug and nerf the DEs, then he needs to counter-nerf the O-Line. Otherwise, we are back to season 8 more-or-less.


 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=588100&pbp_id=14909521

Totally realistic! I love the d-line setup here!


stop whining and fuck your face.

 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
That if you look at any successful pro team and you see them using this strategy should tell you that its obviously got a problem in that it performs better than it should and is logical.


1.) show us the proof of Pro teams consistenly using this
2.) show me where this is a rampant problems in all leagues
3.) show me where this is a consisnt bug found in the sim.


Then I will agree to your above post.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
That if you look at any successful pro team and you see them using this strategy should tell you that its obviously got a problem in that it performs better than it should and is logical.


There's an assumption here. The assumption is that there's another viable alternative to generating pressure.

If there isn't, people will gravitate to the only one that works.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=588100&pbp_id=14909521

Totally realistic! I love the d-line setup here!


107 points in a game is not enough?
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by lolMurp


What started this issue?

Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.


Why is that a problem?

Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?

We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?


The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.


Now I want to know what you think of this plays:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14859797
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14859874
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14860397

[x] 90+ blocking (100+ on the LG)
[x] mid 70s agility
[x] 50+ speed
[x] 60 vision

[x] failed badly

 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
If the defense can generate pressure before this problem, and then the bug is fixed and defenses can no longer generate pressure, then it's a NERF. It may be an unintended consequence, but if he's going to fix this bug and nerf the DEs, then he needs to counter-nerf the O-Line. Otherwise, we are back to season 8 more-or-less.




this is what I'm concerned about. I truthfully couldn't care less if this "bug" is squashed, even though I don't really think it is a bug. Ultimately what is going to happen though (imo) is that a change will have a sweeping effect on the game rendering 95% of DE's impotent again and turning every OT dot into Anthony Munoz.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=588100&pbp_id=14909521 Totally realistic! I love the d-line setup here!

That's a different issue. That's a problem with the blocking programming and how it picks targets.


Originally posted by kurieg
Bort changed something in the sim because he felt that DEs were utterly unable to generate pressure. He basically nerfed pass blocking. That mechanic is doing what it's coded to do, i.e., it's unbugged. IF Bort decides it's now too easy to get that sack in this manner, then any change will be, by definition, a nerf.

Just because you insist on using a certain word doesn't mean that you're using it properly. And no, fixing something Bort created but didn't intend would not be a nerf. DEs got nerfed after S6 when Bort decided that they were too dominant. Not that something he did made them too dominant, but they were too dominant in general. Elusives also got nerfed because Bort felt like there were too many outside runs going the distance. Not that something he did made them too effective and needed to be corrected, but that they were working too well and put the game out of balance. Those things are "nerfs."

And Bort already decided. He agreed with something I said yesterday about the culprit being the combination of break block speed bursts and blocking angles, then said he would experiment with some potential fixes. So there's really no need to debate this as if anyone is going to persuade him.

Originally posted by
I have a very, very real concern that this will be overdone. I think that most LGs are shit poor pass-blockers.

I'm not that concerned about it. Our best DT was dominating before I started putting him in gaps, and I'm confident that he'll continue dominating if this issue is fixed. And for the record, this kind of thing happens to LGs who are built like LTs. It's not a build issue. Any offensive line build can lose a roll, as they should, and this problem comes in when the LG loses that initial roll before he's completed his drop.
Edited by jdbolick on Jul 17, 2009 13:36:44
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by tdm13

If the defense can generate pressure before this problem, and then the bug is fixed and defenses can no longer generate pressure, then it's a NERF. It may be an unintended consequence, but if he's going to fix this bug and nerf the DEs, then he needs to counter-nerf the O-Line. Otherwise, we are back to season 8 more-or-less.




this is what I'm concerned about. I truthfully couldn't care less if this "bug" is squashed, even though I don't really think it is a bug. Ultimately what is going to happen though (imo) is that a change will have a sweeping effect on the game rendering 95% of DE's impotent again and turning every OT dot into Anthony Munoz.


IMO further adjustments are needed to keep DEs nice and pass rushey. But relying on a bug/exploit/unindended consequence, etc is not the way to go.

I think Bort is probably aware of the issues facing DEs
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by jdbolick


Originally posted by lolMurp



What started this issue?

Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.


Why is that a problem?

Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?

We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?


The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.


Now I want to know what you think of this plays:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14859797
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14859874
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14860397

[x] 90+ blocking (100+ on the LG)
[x] mid 70s agility
[x] 50+ speed
[x] 60 vision

[x] failed badly



How is that related?

1&2) Complete overload blitz. Nobody picks up the DT at all. 7 guys vs. 5-6 blockers. Oops.
3) Overload on the strong side. Still involves bouncing and eventually getting through.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.