User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




Originally posted by jrry32






No, I don't see an issue. Do you mean something along the lines of a OPL team getting demoted and instead of ending up in the OPL where they can dominate, they end up in the SAPL or USAPL where they will struggle? So we should skew the system and get rid of good teams out of the Pro League so lesser teams don't end up in tough leagues? Isn't the point of GLB tough competition? Sorry if I don't think teams should be put where they know they can win.


What if a USAPL team gets demoted to OPL, it has an easy pass back to the WPL it wouldn't have otherwise had.


So...? That team deserves to make it back up if they are the best team in the OPL at the time.


...so simply by virtue of a lucky draw, they should get the spot back easier than they otherwise would.

At least you admit it, not much to argue I suppose.


Uh yea...are you proposing that a team currently in the OPL not as good as them should get the spot over them? Do you not see a problem with that? Or do you not see that the original team from the OPL had an easier path to the WPL through "luck of the draw"?


No, I'm not.

I'm proposing that the WPL is a dumbass idea and that either option we choose will leave us with one of a couple problems.

You're no more (or less) wrong than the person arguing for an even 4-4-4 split between leagues. It'll have to deal with the flip side of the "This idea sucks" coin.


And choosing nothing leaves us with the same problems we have now...teams gutting in Pro Leagues because they think they have no shot of knocking off Emmaus, Santiago, Drygeria, etc. as well as teams getting tired of having it easy like WSI was in their Pro Leagues and the best Pro teams having nowhere to go and only scrimmages to play the best of the other leagues. So no matter what, there are problems.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by entropy
Wouldn't it make more sense to just have a World Cup run by some script Bort can cook up? Just have all season 10 champions and 2nd place teams play in a seeded tournament. Bort can reserve the scrimmage times or something.

OR AM I CRAZY


This idea is most certainly not great and is not 9 seasons old.
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by entropy

Wouldn't it make more sense to just have a World Cup run by some script Bort can cook up? Just have all season 10 champions and 2nd place teams play in a seeded tournament. Bort can reserve the scrimmage times or something.

OR AM I CRAZY


This idea is most certainly not great and is not 9 seasons old.


But is it worse than the World League. That's the question.
 
Polorl69
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by entropy
Wouldn't it make more sense to just have a World Cup run by some script Bort can cook up? Just have all season 10 champions and 2nd place teams play in a seeded tournament. Bort can reserve the scrimmage times or something.

OR AM I CRAZY


Crazy IMO

I like the idea of a world league
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

And choosing nothing leaves us with the same problems we have now...teams gutting in Pro Leagues because they think they have no shot of knocking off Emmaus, Santiago, Drygeria, etc. as well as teams getting tired of having it easy like WSI was in their Pro Leagues and the best Pro teams having nowhere to go and only scrimmages to play the best of the other leagues. So no matter what, there are problems.


I'm not going to argue that point, because I agree with it, but the answer isn't the WPL. THat just puts another level of "Well I'm not winning anything" inbetween a team and their goal, that causes even more loss of interest.

We all know the issues that affect the game, and we're ignoring them like the 800 lb. gorilla in the room. This WPL stuff is just flash, and potentially damaging flash at that.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by entropy
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by entropy


Wouldn't it make more sense to just have a World Cup run by some script Bort can cook up? Just have all season 10 champions and 2nd place teams play in a seeded tournament. Bort can reserve the scrimmage times or something.

OR AM I CRAZY


This idea is most certainly not great and is not 9 seasons old.


But is it worse than the World League. That's the question.


No, it's much...MUCH better.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Yea, entropy I was thinking something similar. But it doesn't really help the current problems. I was thinking of at the very end of the season, having the 8 league champs have a world cup tourney and freezing rosters but not making teams pay salaries and have the freeze happen until day 46 or day 47(a game every other day) when the tourney is over and the off-season begins. You could do seedings by scrimmage + league record and then points scored, etc.]
Edited by jrry32 on Jul 8, 2009 13:59:08
 
Polorl69
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32


And choosing nothing leaves us with the same problems we have now...teams gutting in Pro Leagues because they think they have no shot of knocking off Emmaus, Santiago, Drygeria, etc. as well as teams getting tired of having it easy like WSI was in their Pro Leagues and the best Pro teams having nowhere to go and only scrimmages to play the best of the other leagues. So no matter what, there are problems.


I'm not going to argue that point, because I agree with it, but the answer isn't the WPL. THat just puts another level of "Well I'm not winning anything" inbetween a team and their goal, that causes even more loss of interest.

We all know the issues that affect the game, and we're ignoring them like the 800 lb. gorilla in the room. This WPL stuff is just flash, and potentially damaging flash at that.

well at least it gets our minds off the other problems that this game has for a few hours
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Should be more than 4 USA teams imo.

OPL getting the same number as USA?

I guess it's politically correct though.


I love my OPL, but that would be a joke. The reason I love being there is itīs a competitive environment for us. A world league is going to lead to a lot of WSI-like situations and even more gutting of top teams imo. Folks donīt grasp just HOW tough USA Pro. is.


Thank you.

People don't wanna seem to believe it
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Yea, entropy I was thinking something similar. But it doesn't really help the current problems. I was thinking of at the very end of the season, having the 8 league champs have a world cup tourney and freezing rosters but not making teams pay salaries and have the freeze happen until day 46 or day 47 when the tourney is over and the off-season begins. You could do seedings by scrimmage + league record and then points scored, etc.]


Personally I'd rather be playing my "tournament" games all season long in the World League, rather than waiting for the end of the playoffs before the real season starts. Hell, as it is now I know a lot of teams only worry about days 33-40 and their tournament games if they make it to the Quarterfinals or Semi's. Tacking another thing on the end of the year still doesn't remove the fact that for the very top teams or more dominant teams in weaker leagues the first 32 days of the season are basically for shits and giggles.
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


Why do you keep saying this VT? If I'm in OPL, why would I lose interest because I'll never make it to WPL anymore than if I was in the old USA A knowing I'll never make it to USA Pro? Or today stuck somewhere capped in the cloud having to wait forever just to be a AA somewhere?

Most teams don't play because they believe in some grand illusion that they'll make it to any pro league by the time their 10 seasons are up. If so, there would be a lot, lot fewer teams in GLB.

Pro leagues are reserved for the best of the best. Most agents/owners get that. WPL would give the best of the best something more to play for.

Under your logic, nobody should try to win USA Pro today because after all, you have no next level to play for after that.
 
James128
offline
Link
 
I like the nfl division idea. As for the regulation maybe this is the time to eliminate the the pro league names and exchange them with Pro League 1 Pro League 2 etc... You could easily have the AAA regions feed into them and wouldn't have to change those leagues names. Demotion would be easy because it wouldn't matter where the teams got demoted too because they would no longer have ties to the old pro leagues if that makes sense.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
I like the nfl division idea. As for the regulation maybe this is the time to eliminate the the pro league names and exchange them with Pro League 1 Pro League 2 etc... You could easily have the AAA regions feed into them and wouldn't have to change those leagues names. Demotion would be easy because it wouldn't matter where the teams got demoted too because they would no longer have ties to the old pro leagues if that makes sense.


NO! I like Pro Leagues having names...none of that generic bullshit.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
I like the nfl division idea. As for the regulation maybe this is the time to eliminate the the pro league names and exchange them with Pro League 1 Pro League 2 etc... You could easily have the AAA regions feed into them and wouldn't have to change those leagues names. Demotion would be easy because it wouldn't matter where the teams got demoted too because they would no longer have ties to the old pro leagues if that makes sense.


But then I wouldn't get the play the role of arrogant American asshole with a superiority complex!
 
Link
 
The Pros will be substantially lower quality IMO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.