Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32
No, I don't see an issue. Do you mean something along the lines of a OPL team getting demoted and instead of ending up in the OPL where they can dominate, they end up in the SAPL or USAPL where they will struggle? So we should skew the system and get rid of good teams out of the Pro League so lesser teams don't end up in tough leagues? Isn't the point of GLB tough competition? Sorry if I don't think teams should be put where they know they can win.
What if a USAPL team gets demoted to OPL, it has an easy pass back to the WPL it wouldn't have otherwise had.
So...? That team deserves to make it back up if they are the best team in the OPL at the time.
...so simply by virtue of a lucky draw, they should get the spot back easier than they otherwise would.
At least you admit it, not much to argue I suppose.
Uh yea...are you proposing that a team currently in the OPL not as good as them should get the spot over them? Do you not see a problem with that? Or do you not see that the original team from the OPL had an easier path to the WPL through "luck of the draw"?
No, I'm not.
I'm proposing that the WPL is a dumbass idea and that either option we choose will leave us with one of a couple problems.
You're no more (or less) wrong than the person arguing for an even 4-4-4 split between leagues. It'll have to deal with the flip side of the "This idea sucks" coin.
And choosing nothing leaves us with the same problems we have now...teams gutting in Pro Leagues because they think they have no shot of knocking off Emmaus, Santiago, Drygeria, etc. as well as teams getting tired of having it easy like WSI was in their Pro Leagues and the best Pro teams having nowhere to go and only scrimmages to play the best of the other leagues. So no matter what, there are problems.
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32
No, I don't see an issue. Do you mean something along the lines of a OPL team getting demoted and instead of ending up in the OPL where they can dominate, they end up in the SAPL or USAPL where they will struggle? So we should skew the system and get rid of good teams out of the Pro League so lesser teams don't end up in tough leagues? Isn't the point of GLB tough competition? Sorry if I don't think teams should be put where they know they can win.
What if a USAPL team gets demoted to OPL, it has an easy pass back to the WPL it wouldn't have otherwise had.
So...? That team deserves to make it back up if they are the best team in the OPL at the time.
...so simply by virtue of a lucky draw, they should get the spot back easier than they otherwise would.
At least you admit it, not much to argue I suppose.
Uh yea...are you proposing that a team currently in the OPL not as good as them should get the spot over them? Do you not see a problem with that? Or do you not see that the original team from the OPL had an easier path to the WPL through "luck of the draw"?
No, I'm not.
I'm proposing that the WPL is a dumbass idea and that either option we choose will leave us with one of a couple problems.
You're no more (or less) wrong than the person arguing for an even 4-4-4 split between leagues. It'll have to deal with the flip side of the "This idea sucks" coin.
And choosing nothing leaves us with the same problems we have now...teams gutting in Pro Leagues because they think they have no shot of knocking off Emmaus, Santiago, Drygeria, etc. as well as teams getting tired of having it easy like WSI was in their Pro Leagues and the best Pro teams having nowhere to go and only scrimmages to play the best of the other leagues. So no matter what, there are problems.






























