User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Gyuri1



Originally posted by Deathblade




Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out.


That makes sense. And the degree to which they slow down could be affected by carrying, strength, and perhaps vision?


Probably more like confidence, really. Think about it - you're getting pummeled, have fumbled 3 times. You're going to cowering in fear every time a defender gets nearby.


Yeah, confidence should make a difference. But vision, too. If you have high vision, you can see the defender coming and trying to force the fumble. Players w/ low vision won't be able to detect this as quickly and would be more prone to fumble.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
The main problem is things should change so drastically from season to season, especially this far into the game.

You can't expect Elusive Backs to have as much Strength/Carrying as Power Backs, just to hold on to the ball, otherwise there would be NO point in having an elusive back. Besides, they have to crank up Speed/Agility super high, just to be able to contend with power backs, but now they need that much Strength/Carrying to boot?

No reason to build Elusive Backs anymore, if that is the case. Might as well pump up Strength/Carrying from the beginning, and crank up the Power SAs.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JCJayhawk
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Originally posted by Deathblade



Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.


Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


I agree for the most part. New personal tactics are always fun to entertain, though. They add more diversity to player performance, as long as they are balanced well.
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by JCJayhawk

Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


If you need lots of strength to prevent multiple fumbles a game, then there will be no more elusive builds. I guess that's ok if it's what people want, but it's what the result would be.


That's their choice. Why not a balanced build? Its just like CBs that want to be returners putting all their points in speed and agility and neglecting carrying
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Originally posted by lolMurp


Originally posted by JcWildcat



Ohshit, they said something mildly deprecating the defense, call to arms!



I mad.




Ban Murp for trolling please.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Originally posted by lolMurp

Originally posted by JcWildcat

Ohshit, they said something mildly deprecating the defense, call to arms!


Not quite buddy. How long has the O told D to build better whenever there's been a complaint that O is too powerful?
So now that people are building the D players better, you all want to nerf them?
Screw that.


Every time the defensive players have whined (and I've occasionally been one of them), Bort's made an effort to tone down whatever problem there has been. I don't see how the fact that there's been an imbalance in the game in one direction previously justifies an imbalance in the game in the other direction now. Wouldn't balance in both directions be preferable?
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
The main problem is things should change so drastically from season to season, especially this far into the game.

You can't expect Elusive Backs to have as much Strength/Carrying as Power Backs, just to hold on to the ball, otherwise there would be NO point in having an elusive back. Besides, they have to crank up Speed/Agility super high, just to be able to contend with power backs, but now they need that much Strength/Carrying to boot?

No reason to build Elusive Backs anymore, if that is the case. Might as well pump up Strength/Carrying from the beginning, and crank up the Power SAs.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


I much prefer David vs. Goliath to Sure Tackler. I figure if they aren't bigger, and aren't stronger, breaking a tackle isn't really a huge concern....and David vs. Goliath will always trigger when you need it, and allows you to tackle players that would be near impossible to tackle by rerolling.

Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


I saw a suggestion for another running tactic, that might be along those same lines. Where on one side you have "fight out yards, +fumble" and on the other you have "no extra yards, -fumble."

Would anyone take the +fumble one, though? An extra yard or 2 might be worth it, but only if you have the carrying to hang on.


Please don't tough the sim anymore this season, leave it be its fine. Don't let a bunch of little cry baby girls force you to change the sim yet again.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by JCJayhawk
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Originally posted by Deathblade



Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.


Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


You dont understand players with 60 STR and 60 CAR are fumbling a lot.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by JCJayhawk


Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


If you need lots of strength to prevent multiple fumbles a game, then there will be no more elusive builds. I guess that's ok if it's what people want, but it's what the result would be.


Bort said Carrying is more important than Strength...and I don't think it is a sin to have a player whose sole purpose is to carry the football required to invest in a skill that helps them carry the football. More than first capping it obviously.


100% agree.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

This is complete bullshit: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477042

14 fumbles in one game? I don't think we even had 14 fumbles all of last season. If this doesn't get fixed, this will definitely be my last season playing this game.

The three guys who fumbled have over 60 in carrying, and the 2 HBs have over 60 in strength as well. So that's not the problem


Last year fumbles were broken as shit, they never happened! This year fumbles are fun and add to the game so STFU and stop your crying.



If your idea of fun is 14 fumbles a game, so be it. Once again, nobody has said anything about getting rid of fumbles... we just want to tone them down.
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
If it realism you guys are looking for please remember there was only one Barry Sanders. We don't need a server full of em. Not everyone can be super elusive at mid to low levels. That should be reserved for the highest levels of the game
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by JCJayhawk

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Gyuri1



Originally posted by Deathblade




Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.


Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


I agree for the most part. New personal tactics are always fun to entertain, though. They add more diversity to player performance, as long as they are balanced well.


Wouldn't it affect QBs as well? I mean, QBs should fumble really often.

Also, most of ppl are complaining only about returners ability, and seriously, that's their lack of carrying.

Com'on now, I seriously I'd like to get things going this way for this season. You'll notice how ppl will add some carrying (as we did with tackling past seasons) and the problem will disappear.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Originally posted by lolMurp


Originally posted by JcWildcat


Ohshit, they said something mildly deprecating the defense, call to arms!


Not quite buddy. How long has the O told D to build better whenever there's been a complaint that O is too powerful?
So now that people are building the D players better, you all want to nerf them?
Screw that.


Every time the defensive players have whined (and I've occasionally been one of them), Bort's made an effort to tone down whatever problem there has been. I don't see how the fact that there's been an imbalance in the game in one direction previously justifies an imbalance in the game in the other direction now. Wouldn't balance in both directions be preferable?


If my Double capped tackling and close to 100 strength DT can still get the HBs w/squat for carrying and strength to fumble then sure. And yes, there has been an imbalance in the game before.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
If every team isn't having this problem, there is no problem with the sim.

/thread.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.