User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by Nuge20

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


I would think RB's, WR's and QB's would always end up being the MVP's?


and this is different from real life?


This isn't real life. We don't have to be ignorant like the media.


which is true but the higher flex player should get a MUCH better chance at winning an ENDO
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nthomas
Originally posted by smizzy

- strip the old ones away
- compensate the guys who have been stripped of the ones they got
- rerun the script to double the amount of endorsements per league ( 32 per conference , 64 per league)
- limit the teams to 5 Endorsements per team ( 2-offensive, 2 defensive,1 ST)
- limit it to 5 endorsements can be active at once
- Minimum of 2 endorsements per team ( Random)
- No player can get endorsements in back2back seasons
- You can't trade/ release a player with an endorsement unless he is willing to waive his endorsement

Instead of making things more complicated Bort, why not just simplify it and make more of them?


There is a lot of sense in this. Not perfect, but good.


I find it amusing there are 16 teams in each conference and 32 teams per league and we are still talking about giving out 16 per league.

What a joke. 16 endorsements for 1280 players??
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 20:53:28
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JugheadASFN
Bort - Is it possible to run the MVP calculations only if the teams have players that average within the "Permitted Player Levels" (exp: Lv 25-100) and if the MVP candidate is within the "Suggested" levels?

This would do two things:

Take out those CPU and gutted/slowbuild teams from skewing stats

and

discourage those ultra higher level players moving down into the "A" and "BBB" leagues to dominate.


This would be easily possible.
 
Razorthorns
offline
Link
 
Bort if you do the endorsements by east and west division instead of by the entire league then you don't have to worry about gutted teams since players in the same division/conference,such as, AAA #1 east and west. East and West pretty much play the same teams within their east or within their west so just throw out the out of division games when calculating the mvps and you instantly have fair mvps. You would end up handing more of them out but hey at least then each division is getting an equal amount so it keeps that balanced too minus the teams getting promoted.

I also think that if any player wins two or more trophies then it should be an automatic endorsement.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 20:54:41
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Hikariu

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Capaneus



Originally posted by Bort





You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Sounds great, and I'd love to see the results.


I'll have to set something up. I doubt it will be hard to set up. The formula will be the hard part.


For the MVP award what are you thoughts about just letting the playoff team owners vote like a poll. One vote for O/D/ST per playoff team owner after the championship game and one Superbowl MVP award based on raw stats in that game.


I am wary of any purely vote based systems. They are likely to be gamed and campaigned for.

However, what if votes were included as part of weighting of an MVP calculation?


I think it opens too many doors for shadeyness, i.e. say i own a team and my guy is in the MVP running and i say to another owner "get your team to vote for me, and ill release some of my players ,you sign them and then i'll pay you max cash for them."

I think a vote would be cool but there is just too much possibility for unethical stuff to come as a result.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
Originally posted by JugheadASFN

Bort - Is it possible to run the MVP calculations only if the teams have players that average within the "Permitted Player Levels" (exp: Lv 25-100) and if the MVP candidate is within the "Suggested" levels?

This would do two things:

Take out those CPU and gutted/slowbuild teams from skewing stats

and

discourage those ultra higher level players moving down into the "A" and "BBB" leagues to dominate.


This would be easily possible.


I like this
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by Nuge20

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


I would think RB's, WR's and QB's would always end up being the MVP's?


and this is different from real life?


This isn't real life. We don't have to be ignorant like the media.


+1
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Bort


However, what if votes were included as part of weighting of an MVP calculation?


I'm not reflexively opposed to it, but I agree that it will likely just skew things; I mean heck, just look at real life all star games.


That's my general feeling as well. We've seen how the best stories always rise to the top on Digg, right?

The hive mind isn't always right, especially if the hive is very small.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 

Obvious problem needing addressed is one or two teams stacking up on the endorsements and them not spreading around.

Take the current endorsements handed out, shrink that number to 2-5 and hand those out based on fame. Each fame is granted a number of 'balls' and they are tossed together, similar to the NBA style where Portland got lucky with Oden. HOWEVER, do not make it such a huge difference like 100 and 75. Make fame have some effect, but not one where a guy is nearly granted the endorsement.

Create 'Significant Endorsements' and replace the current endorsements with these. Give out a handful of these, maybe low 20s. You can use the same formula above, but make fame a little less significant.

Create 'Smaller Endorsements' which would warrant a small cash amount with lesser attribute boosts.

Create 'Mini Endorsements' which would warrant little cash with little attribute boosts.

Both of the Smaller and Mini could be given out in greater number, with no discretion of to who.

Why couldn't a player get 2? It should be possible.

However, if a player receives the top endorsement, then that will be the end of his endorsements. For everyone else, allow a maximum of 2 but not in the same category [no player getting 2 significant]. ---- Or this could be taken out


edit: With an idea like this, it keeps the top players happy along with the other guys who are rewarded with something and the people who received them today.
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
LOL at MVP calculations being the answer when you can't even get fame right and it's been around for 2 seasons. what makes you think you can hit a home run with the MVP script?
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Originally posted by Nuge20


Originally posted by Mightyhalo



I would think RB's, WR's and QB's would always end up being the MVP's?


and this is different from real life?


This isn't real life. We don't have to be ignorant like the media.


which is true but the higher flex player should get a MUCH better chance at winning an ENDO


 
justnzane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13
I think also, higher rated leagues should have more endorsements than lower level leagues...in other words, a team in Pro should be able to have 8-10 endorsements whereas a team in BBB should only have 3-5. Maybe keep the idea of local ones and then have the national ones and have more national ones as the tier goes up. Something to the effect of

1-2 national in BBB
2-3 nationals in A
3-4 in AA
4-5 in AAA
5-6 in Pro


This just makes a ton of sense


Originally posted by nthomas
Originally posted by smizzy

- strip the old ones away
- compensate the guys who have been stripped of the ones they got
- rerun the script to double the amount of endorsements per league ( 32 per conference , 64 per league)
- limit the teams to 5 Endorsements per team ( 2-offensive, 2 defensive,1 ST)
- limit it to 5 endorsements can be active at once
- Minimum of 2 endorsements per team ( Random)
- No player can get endorsements in back2back seasons
- You can't trade/ release a player with an endorsement unless he is willing to waive his endorsement

Instead of making things more complicated Bort, why not just simplify it and make more of them?


There is a lot of sense in this. Not perfect, but good.


Smizzy as always has great ideas.

Now the thing the bugs the hell out of me, is why would backup players get endorsements? There should be some requirement of number of games started or % of snaps played, imo
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
LOL at MVP calculations being the answer when you can't even get fame right and it's been around for 2 seasons. what makes you think you can hit a home run with the MVP script?


I think he's actually going to test the calculations this time.........
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Can anyone give even a half ass reason why a player that currently has an endorsement shouldn't just keep it?


You can link your inactive player or the guy with a billion trophies who got screwed but at the end of the day taking these away is completely pointless. Some teams overall got an advantage but if you just do it right and spread move LOVE (not hate) to other teams nobody would even care right now.

The problem can be solved without alienating or depressing people who were just on cloud 9.


Fail
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
LOL at MVP calculations being the answer when you can't even get fame right and it's been around for 2 seasons. what makes you think you can hit a home run with the MVP script?

100% agree. Not a chance in hell.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.