User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
ugk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by Tim Harper

Alright where to begin a long winded thread like so.....

TestGate - Why it is good and bad for the game
I have known about the TestGate scandal for a couple of days now. I actually inquired about gaining a position within the test due to past history as an alpha tester. I didn't decide to try to get myself in the door for my own personal gain, since I feel I have a pretty good grasp on the game now. I wanted it to show/fix what I felt was needed without lobbying in a suggestion forum that goes unnoticed. I consider myself to be someone that can read between the lines when it comes to this game. I have always been able to see the big picture in builds and go from there. Some of you may remember early on the "Ask a Vet Thread" that was around for a good 3 seasons. The main reason for that thread was to not only educate players on my own information found out from my testing process, but to help people understand the fundamentals behind the attributes and how they relate within the sim. All this info that I provided in my thread was not only used in a ton of player guides still used to this day, but was one of the many reasons behind the speed nerf. It was guides and info like this that lead to the game having to get tweaked. The game was initially built to have players go with very balanced players, that was how Bort had coded the game. When people like myself, Flames and many other power builders out there started to stack certain attributes to the roof did balance issues come into play. The game is continually evolving if you notice it or not. Builds are strictly kept secretive by some people including myself, due to the time and research it took to dig up what works within this game. With tweaks here and there, finding the new gem of a build is making people go crazy. Not only is their hard work going down the tubes when a nerf to their key skill is implemented, they are thus forced to find an alternative which at a higher level takes some time. These nerfs are a product of the game still only being a year old. The nerfs are a product of our own creation of player builds. The Test Servers is yet another product produced to help balance out the game due to our ability to "break" the game.

Now enough of the back story, here is why I feel the test server was beneficial.
Reasons why I believe hidden testing is crucial

Bort doesn't understand his own game
Yes, I know Bort is the one that has coded game, that is common knowledge. But without experience as an agent, he doesn't understand how the math reacts on a game by game basis. When you have 20 or so players, some multiple positions, you soon start to see patterns in production between them. Which ones are doing better, which ones are doing worse and then tweaking builds constantly to see which attribute combinations are yielding the highest statistical output with in the game. Bort hasn't put in the hundreds of hours some of have in trying to figure out the game with the game. He looks at it purely as a mathematical function, that insight is what holds him back as a game creator. Without playing, he has to rely on testers to point him in the right direction.

Testers allow Bort to focus his time on balance issues
With a good core of active testers(active is the key), they should be able to help Bort focus his time a bit. If the testers are active and I will assume they are, they will figure out the balance issues much faster then Bort can. Not only do they have a better grasp on the game mechanics which I mentioned earlier, they can point him in the right direction on what is or isn't working correctly. There is only so many hours in the day and with the short season turnarounds, he needs people to help him work out the kinks in updates.

Reasons I believe testing isn't beneficial(The Secret Testing One)

It Undermines the Customer Base
Plenty of people have put hundreds of dollars within the game, including myself. When we are kept in the dark about something of this magnitude, we feel cheated. Not only have we kept your game afloat, but we are the reason for a ton of referrals to grow your business. We are as much owners of this game as you are. A game of this size doesn't finance itself, yet we feel betrayed when loyal users weren't invited to help improve the game. When people are under the impression we are paying for a "Beta" game, we assume that everyone is on equal footing as for knowledge that can be collected from playing the game. People feel cheated due to testers getting an extra outlet of knowledge, that other paying customers aren't receiving.

More Testers can bring better results
Yes this somewhat contradicts a past point I brought up, but I tend to like to tread water on both sides of the argument. When I hear about secret testing and only a small group of 20 people, I have always thought that wasn't enough. Does anyone not remember Season 1 and the issues that were found? Not only did we have 50 Alpha Testers for a good 2-3 months before the launch to find issues, once the huge fan base came in tons more issues were brought to light. Why is that? More people + More Actions = More Bugs. That is just a fact of how things work. The more times things are tested and used, the more glaring even the smallest bugs come to light. Why limit it to such a small group? Why not just allow the entire community to such a project like this, there are plenty of people with a ton of free time looking to help the game they build.

Final Thoughts
That is pretty much my thoughts on the TestGate scandal. I usually like to look at things from both perspectives to figure out what side of the tracks I may lean. Hopefully I have given you guys some insight on what I see from an independent standpoint. I have been on as an alpha tester, a mod, a disgruntled employee of GLB, an outcast, a trouble maker and a scapegoat. I have been in every position within the game and have always been honest with people when asked a question about how the game works.

Hopefully I am able to shed some light on how the community has shaped the game a bit and lead us to the point of how we have a TestGate Scandal. Also I hope that you guys understand that Bort has tried to used the extra help with the testing as a positive for the game and not always a negative. Now with the recent actions of the admins/mods on the issue, both sides then to bleed together from time to time. I think everyone just needs to calm down and await a statement from Bort after everything cools down.

Tim Harper



The greatness makes a great post
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.


To do what with?
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Cerneo

Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.


To do what with?


to cry about
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Cerneo

Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.


To do what with?


See the full extent of the advantage, if any, gained next season.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf


to cry about


No one is crying, we are having a discussion here.
 
ugk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Cerneo


Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.


To do what with?


See the full extent of the advantage, if any, gained next season.


And ofcourse being able to see all the test data :s
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Cerneo


Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.


To do what with?


See the full extent of the advantage, if any, gained next season.


So you think this is a new thing?

How about this, TPat, admitted to being a tester, go check his team out this season and the previous season just to.....

See the full extent of the perceived advantage.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Cerneo

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Cerneo



Tims post was very good.

But we still need the names.


To do what with?


See the full extent of the advantage, if any, gained next season.


So you think this is a new thing?

How about this, TPat, admitted to being a tester, go check his team out this season and the previous season just to.....

See the full extent of the perceived advantage.


The testing started on Feb 1st. That was during the playoffs its impossible to know if it helped anyone with out names.

Get your facts right.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
The testing for the D play creator started on Feb 1st.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
"Advantages" will be used to the fullest extent with smarter owners.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
From TPAT, makes a TON of sense.

Originally posted by tpaterniti
Also I want to briefly address the scenario some people have mentioned of testing what a player would look like with this or that build. First of all, I know it sounds like a simple thing to say, what if my player had 15 more confidence, what would that do? But think about what you would really have to do to set this up. You could make that character easy enough, but to test what he would do? Against who? Against what? You would have to set up a whole team to test it out against. For example, let's say you want to test what your QB could do with 15 more confidence. Well what type of team are you playing? We have absolutely no ability to rip teams from the game to test against so you would have to set up a team yourself. What kind of team would they be? Pass rushing? Fast CBs? Run stopping? In other words what is a "typical" team you would test against or is there even any such thing as a "typical" team? Most teams on GLB right now are a blend of agents and builds, some very good, some average, some below average and many teams are quite different from each other. Then for your own team, how do you set them up? Consider the possibility that you could make your own offense too good because the real issue would be how to interpret your test results? What if your QB plays great? What does that mean? Was that simply due to adding 15 confidence to him? Did you make your D too bad, or your O too good? And if you learn that 15 confidence makes your QB better against the team you played, does that translate to GLB? What is the likelihood that any teams are similar to the one you made? Well surely some will be similar, but not all and not all in the same way. You could play a SA based team and still not have enough confidence. Then again, and this is the real point, did you really learn anything about confidence from your test? I think everyone would concede that since confidence is a major attribute for QBs, adding 15 more of it would make him play better. But exactly how much better did he play? And how did he play better? Did he seem to deteriorate less over the game, or did he throw farther, avoid sacks better, etc etc etc. What does your test tell you about confidence for a QB that you didn't really know already that would give you a huge advantage over anyone else?

I hope this case study is helpful. My point is that while it seems like a simple matter to say, Well a tester could just "preview" his next boost to see what is most effective, this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do, and I would seriously question the quality of any results you would get from that because of huge problems interpreting your results.

Quotes from TPAT,

Tell me what advantage there is there, please.
 
Elway
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
Originally posted by Elway

Originally posted by weather999


Originally posted by TehKyou



Originally posted by weather999




Originally posted by TehKyou





Originally posted by weather999






Fancy title = big bucks i bet


It will be when I get out, but in a few years (and a few more college credits) I'll also qualify to be a pilot.


Sweet. U.S. i assume?


Yup, good ol U.S. of A.


Nice. I'm Canadian, but it's always glad to hear people wanting to serve their countries.


So who is the hottie in your avatar?


Bar Refaeli. SI Swimsuit cover model.

and Scientist, im getting a .gif to show da body


Thanks for the info.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Yep.
Lemme just say leo di caprio is a fucking lucky dude.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by AgentTBC

Well, yeah, obviously at this point the most necessary thing is transparency: People need to know exactly what these testers can do. Specifically, the following:

1) Can testers see the builds of other players in the game?
2) Can testers create players with whatever stats they want and test them in games?
3) Can testers set up scrimmage games with existing GLB teams, modify the offense/defensive tactics, and see the results?

Those three things are critical knowledge. Any of them are just begging for abuse; all of them would be disastrous from a PR standpoint.

this imo. i don't care who the testers were. i just want to know IF they're truly being given an unfair advantage or not.


1. No, absolutely not.
2. Yes wouldn't be much of a test site otherwise
3. No, absolutely not.


Testers are some mods who are interested in it and some other users who have demonstrated their altruistic interest in testing for the benefit of the game and not for their own personal gain. If a tester is found to have been disseminating knowledge from the game to get his team an unfair advantage he will not be a tester for long. Having testers know a lot about the game is unavoidable. That is why you try to find guys who are genuinely concerned about others. For example all my player builds are open. I would not do that if I was only concerned about "dominating".


---

And thats Tpats other post wbout them making player builds.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.