Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by GIEFF
Then maybe you should only suspend people when their actions result in a net degradation in the site experience for all users?
How do you judge that? That is giving even more judgement to the mods. Me disagreeing with you could be considered a net degradation in the site for all users by a mod that dislikes me.
How is you disagreeing with me a negative? I'm talking about things like spam in content-based forums, posting racism or pornography, or out-of-line personal attacks where the recipient actually wants it to stop.
Things that are obviously causing people to be less likely to continue to play the game. Incidentally, over-moderation is another of those things that can make people less likely to continue to play the game, which is really stupid, considering the whole point of it is to do the exact opposite.
Like I said...Giving Mods more room to make judgements = bad idea. Then they can take advantage of grudges.
None of what I posted requires very much judgment at all, and FAR less than is being applied now.
* Spam in content-based forums is very easy to spot.
* Racism is easy to spot.
* Porn is easy to spot.
* Personal attacks do require a bit of judgment, but I really think they should be allowed in non-content-based forums unless someone asks for them to stop.
Any additional rules are doing more harm than good as far as I'm concerned, assuming the whole point of moderation is to improve the site.
Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by GIEFF
Then maybe you should only suspend people when their actions result in a net degradation in the site experience for all users?
How do you judge that? That is giving even more judgement to the mods. Me disagreeing with you could be considered a net degradation in the site for all users by a mod that dislikes me.
How is you disagreeing with me a negative? I'm talking about things like spam in content-based forums, posting racism or pornography, or out-of-line personal attacks where the recipient actually wants it to stop.
Things that are obviously causing people to be less likely to continue to play the game. Incidentally, over-moderation is another of those things that can make people less likely to continue to play the game, which is really stupid, considering the whole point of it is to do the exact opposite.
Like I said...Giving Mods more room to make judgements = bad idea. Then they can take advantage of grudges.
None of what I posted requires very much judgment at all, and FAR less than is being applied now.
* Spam in content-based forums is very easy to spot.
* Racism is easy to spot.
* Porn is easy to spot.
* Personal attacks do require a bit of judgment, but I really think they should be allowed in non-content-based forums unless someone asks for them to stop.
Any additional rules are doing more harm than good as far as I'm concerned, assuming the whole point of moderation is to improve the site.






























