User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Mr_Victor
offline
Link
 
I've quit complaining about it and just jumped on the bandwagon. Just saw our scrambling QB go from a 53% season completion % to 91% in the last scrimmage using the screen against a higher level defence. Lovely, truely not overpowered....

Makes gameplanning really easy too you just need the WR screen and a few runs out of single back. Can't set up the AI to defend both very well since the WR screen needs basically an extra man because the CBs drop back rather than play up like they should on close cover. (Allowing bump and run would probably fix this whole issue).

So really maybe all the guys are right, the WR screen is not broken. Defences probably are in the fact they can't bump the WRs at the line which would be a perfect fix.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 15:13:31
 
Link
 
Here's what happened when the opposing team tried to pull the WR screen on us in today's conference championship game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287399&pbp_id=13049869

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287399&pbp_id=13050376

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287399&pbp_id=13049756

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287399&pbp_id=13049621

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=287399&pbp_id=13049567

 
Ccf
offline
Link
 
So now that it benefits you, it shouldn't be changed? Ha, I love GLB......
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Ok, I haven't read every post and I am still kind of new to the game (and have never been an OC so I don't know what settings/plays they can run), so sorry if this is an ignorant comment for whatever reason, but:

Wouldn't allowing the CBs to bump the WRs on the line solve lot of problems? First, it would help this because if the CB is playing right on top of the WR and the QB doesn't realze this, there is a very good chance it is going to be a pick 6. It also doesn't require you to move any other defenders around. This could also be useful for other plays as well, as often times NFL and college teams use this strategy to try to neutralize a fast receiver and not let them get a jump of the line.

Of course there is a gamble involved still. If you don't have help over the top there is a very good chance you will get beat deep if you don't get a good bump on the WR. But this would be a very realistic strategy used in real life games, where on a good receiver you have 1 defender get a bump at the line and then another receiver that will take him over the top.

Another problem I think this could solve is making strength more important for WRs and CBs. I know there has been some complaints about CBs and WRs not needing any strength. Strength could be a very big factor in how likely a CB is to bump a WR (and how good that bump is) and how likely a WR is at shaking off the defender to get open.

Criticize however you like.


So did this post just get completely overpassed or what? Usually even if it sucks there are at least a few people that say so and call me a noob, lol.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ccf
So now that it benefits you, it shouldn't be changed? Ha, I love GLB......

Your sarcasm detector needs fixing.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ccf
So now that it benefits you, it shouldn't be changed? Ha, I love GLB......


No I think the still pathing should be changed cause it's just bad - no way a WR on a screen should cut inside and then do a 180 and fly around the outside. If he's cutting inside he should go up the seam. If he wants to go up the outside then the first move should be a step or two back no inside, and then beat the CB for his gain, IMO. But, I'm just happy I finally managed to stop that damned thing. Teams were pretty even by team bars at least.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Now you got it. Another perfect example of insult-empty bubble-whine!

Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by RAPB


See, you have to add where the text is bold:

Honestly, I still can't tell if you're embarrassing yourself due to an inability to comprehend the distinction or if you actually do get it but are just dishonest enough to pretend otherwise. Regardless of which one it is, your best course of action is to stop. (great job! That was easy, wasn't it?)

The WR and HB screens are both popular because they are effective and require particular game-planning to contain, but neither are remotely as unbalanced as the Strong I Off Tackle runs and corner routes. Neither of those plays will result such a constant, unstoppable gain of yardage where no players even got (an) attempt (to) tackle for no gain or loss if the offensive and defensive players are relatively equal. Neither of those plays feature lineman/LBs or CBs beeing constantly taken out of the play to make it a 100% gainer for first downs. They're challenging but they're not plays where you need to have significantly better players than the opposition just to stop it without devoting an inordinate number of defenders.

I understand that it's a favorite past-time of some people on GLB to do absolutely nothing but bitch at anyone who has a complaint, regardless of what that complaint happens to be, but I would strongly suggest that you at least try to get a life. If you have an actual rebuttal to the complaint and care to explain why you don't believe it's valid, then that's relevant and productive. But if you don't, then why waste anyone's time with your sad attempts at cleverness? I'm moderately curious as to whether you respond the way you do because you really feel like you're doing the staff a favor by sucking up to them and bashing anyone who has a complaint, or if it has nothing to do with them and you're just incredibly bitter by nature.

(You extended the standart-whine by another insult at the end. Of course that makes the whiner look even more stupid. You might think this over, for usually whiners like to think as of themselfes having a legit issue.)


Great process of learning!

Now as you have shown to be able to learn, go fix your tactics or CB builds. I know you can do it. Otherwise shoot me a PM and I'll drop you some hints.


Damn RAPB you look like a fool trying to sound intelligent after jdbolick thoroughly owned you. At least he can put together a thoughtful and intelligent complaint, or suggestion, while you just deliver childish one liners with nothing to back them up.

Sometimes your kind needs to learn when to shut the fuck up.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 15:37:12
 
Ccf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Ccf

So now that it benefits you, it shouldn't be changed? Ha, I love GLB......

Your sarcasm detector needs fixing.


It's hard to tell when someone's being sarcastic on the internet, I can't hear their voice.
 
ozzfan1317
offline
Link
 
The Wr Screen Is Fine if thats the Only Pass play your Offense is running then It doesnt take a Genius to stop it. A Smart OC will mix it with some other Passes and Runs (Not openly admitting what kinds..lol) To make his offense into a beast.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
...

Damn RAPB you look like a fool trying to sound intelligent after jdbolick thoroughly owned you. At least he can put together a thoughtful and intelligent complaint, or suggestion, while you just deliver childish one liners with nothing to back them up.

Sometimes your kind needs to learn when to shut the fuck up.


Is it so hard to admit you screwed up?

If you got your CBs build right - no problem.
If you got your FS build right, no problem too.

If you got none of the above - you got to field a defense working around the problem. And NO, it's not just a LB shift. Guys have shown A LOT of examples - fact!

This is just a whine of guys that don't want to do anything, but have the SIM do all the work. Now if any play can be shut down by inappropriate builds and "regular" defense, where's the point of scouting and setting up an offensive gameplan?

You see the very same problem for the inside rushes. You'll suck badly if your line and LBs are not build to stop it.

Same problem, same whine.

So stop complaining, start adressing it. You CAN'T be great at everything and you shouldn't. You want to stop the WR screen? You can do so. You don't have the CB builds but still don't want to sell out on the run - you can't and will suck.

Oh... and as soon as you learned to shut down the WR screen it becomes immediately useless, for opponents won't call that play anymore. That's just the nature of the game.

 
Mr_Victor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Ccf

So now that it benefits you, it shouldn't be changed? Ha, I love GLB......

Your sarcasm detector needs fixing.


+1
 
Mr_Victor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

...

Damn RAPB you look like a fool trying to sound intelligent after jdbolick thoroughly owned you. At least he can put together a thoughtful and intelligent complaint, or suggestion, while you just deliver childish one liners with nothing to back them up.

Sometimes your kind needs to learn when to shut the fuck up.


Is it so hard to admit you screwed up?

If you got your CBs build right - no problem.
If you got your FS build right, no problem too.

If you got none of the above - you got to field a defense working around the problem. And NO, it's not just a LB shift. Guys have shown A LOT of examples - fact!

This is just a whine of guys that don't want to do anything, but have the SIM do all the work. Now if any play can be shut down by inappropriate builds and "regular" defense, where's the point of scouting and setting up an offensive gameplan?

You see the very same problem for the inside rushes. You'll suck badly if your line and LBs are not build to stop it.

Same problem, same whine.

So stop complaining, start adressing it. You CAN'T be great at everything and you shouldn't. You want to stop the WR screen? You can do so. You don't have the CB builds but still don't want to sell out on the run - you can't and will suck.

Oh... and as soon as you learned to shut down the WR screen it becomes immediately useless, for opponents won't call that play anymore. That's just the nature of the game.



Oh great someone whining about the whiners
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr_Victor
Oh great someone whining about the whiners


Damn... you're right! I'll shut up.

 
Mr_Victor
offline
Link
 
lol
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Is it so hard to admit you screwed up?

Seriously, stop embarrassing yourself. You've been running your mouth for quite a while now, saying things that have already been disproven. Stopping the WR screen is not a schematic issue. You must have CBs are have superior agility to the WRs or you're screwed if the WR takes that immediate outside path. There is no play in the game nearly that unbalanced.

But you know all that already. You are a troll that has no purpose in life but to irritate anyone who has a complaint. You're not explaining anything to anyone or even addressing the problem, you're just babbling and making an ass of yourself hassling anyone who criticizes the game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.