User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
Dacolts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort


Dunno, all I know is the single if statement I modified, which I posted earlier. It was definitely not as intended as it was.


"Working, but not as intended."




This could be right.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort

Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.



First Off. Lesser the difference in speed settings. If I choose to play close, Medium, or Far to a WR 20 speed faster then me, I should get the results. Don't force me to play off. They have nothing to do with going for interceptions.

Have a setting per each WR they go against the next game be in a drop down. Let them set their coverage style for each one.

Let the "go for int" chances be just a slider 1-100%. and have that be a base +/- to going for Int's and PD's.


You're not going to get that by tomorrow , but good idea nonetheless. Per receiver matchup type stuff is something I've been trying to figure out how to set up.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort

Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.



First Off. Lesser the difference in speed settings. If I choose to play close, Medium, or Far to a WR 20 speed faster then me, I should get the results. Don't force me to play off. They have nothing to do with going for interceptions.

Have a setting per each WR they go against the next game be in a drop down. Let them set their coverage style for each one.

Let the "go for int" chances be just a slider 1-100%. and have that be a base +/- to going for Int's and PD's.


This.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Unless it's a badly thrown ball, coverage distance should indicate whether a DB is in position to get an INT or PBU. Coverage style can then come into play whether the DB goes for the PBU, the INT, INT w/help, or nothing at all and just continues to stick to his man.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:16:39
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.

In RL, if a CB dives in and tries to break up the pass, he could easily fall down or miss it and fly past, etc.


This.

There is a reason for each setting. If one isn't working for you, try something else. There will be a setting for each player that lets him perform at his best.. just take your time,find it, and stop complaining.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY
Originally posted by Dacolts

Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


i like this.


I agree, This idea is better then the slider. Simple and efficient.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Well, if going back to the way it was is not an option, than i vote in favor of a 4th option that behaves exactly like "medium coverage style" before it got changed
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by sirallan

Originally posted by Bort


So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


I think that is your best choice Bort.
Just expect people to whine when they had an easy pick and got a PD instead.


It'd still be possible to get the INT, especially if the WR bobbles it or something.

Maybe I'll try testing a "move close to the receiver" setting for it instead: it could be the same exact code block but just add a couple feet off his outside shoulder as for positioning.


I like the idea and hopefully it will work .
Just make sure that people on close coverage + blanket don't get a PD every time because like you said this would kill the already unbalanced offensive game plans.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by Dacolts


Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


i like this.


I agree, This idea is better then the slider. Simple and efficient.


There needs to be a 4th option there of "stay back no matter what" - sometimes your guy is badly outmatched and you don't want to risk it at all.

Adding a "blanket coverage" option would be the same as "Go for the PD"
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Yeah..

A CB shouldn't be forced to go for the PD every single time.

He should be able to decide, which is the most likely for success - going for the INT, PD, or an easy tackle.

We shouldn't have to have one without the other.

A CB should be able to make a PD on one play, but then attempt to INT the ball on the next.

We shouldn't be held down, to only once choice.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by MRIGUY

Originally posted by Dacolts


Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


i like this.


I agree, This idea is better then the slider. Simple and efficient.


You can incorporate this into the coverage logic:

"Unless it's a badly thrown ball, coverage distance should indicate whether a DB is in position to get an INT or PBU. Coverage style can then come into play whether the DB goes for the PBU, the INT, INT w/help, or nothing at all and just continues to stick to his man."

Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:16:20
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Yeah..

A CB shouldn't be forced to go for the PD every single time.

He should be able to decide, which is the most likely for success - going for the INT, PD, or an easy tackle.

We shouldn't have to have one without the other.

A CB should be able to make a PD on one play, but then attempt to INT the ball on the next.

We shouldn't be held down, to only once choice.


yeah but it would be similar to a qb that can throw a bullet with less ints and comletions to the other end a lob with more ints and completions...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Yeah..

A CB shouldn't be forced to go for the PD every single time.

He should be able to decide, which is the most likely for success - going for the INT, PD, or an easy tackle.

We shouldn't have to have one without the other.

A CB should be able to make a PD on one play, but then attempt to INT the ball on the next.

We shouldn't be held down, to only once choice.


Unforunately you're stuck with the one option at the moment, but I can definitely take that into consideration as I work on future tactical option.

I'd like to maybe do a 1-100% power-elusive slider for running style as well - it'd be very easy as far as the sim code goes.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


There needs to be a 4th option there of "stay back no matter what" - sometimes your guy is badly outmatched and you don't want to risk it at all.


We have that already. It's called "Loose coverage style," and no one uses it because it results in a catch every single time.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Well, if going back to the way it was is not an option, than i vote in favor of a 4th option that behaves exactly like "medium coverage style" before it got changed


Yes...and this at the very least would mean that we did not face a mid-season change to our players...

Might be a very good precedent to not alter the exsiting players when trying to address certain sorts of issues...unless that is truly your intention.

These sorts of things could be addressed by adding an an additional setting for the folks who are struggling, rather than making a change that will affect everyone whether they know it or not, or want it or not.

Obviuosly, some changes will be intended to affect everyone, which would be a different animal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.