User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
arcadecowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1
I think Bort's original post is good as a "starting point" and he can see how that works, then adjust accordingly. Definately a topic I've been thinking about how to approach... ( I've always believed those 300+ lb people should NOT be moving as fast as the 180 lb people - I don't care what their Speed is at) And the training to lower weight idea is a good one as well. Should definately give people an option to lower- thru Agility/Speed training ( or INCREASE-through strength/stamina training) their weight.
GOOD IDEA BORT! + 1000 * Edit* Isn't this an "Epic" suggestion? lol


 
Link
 
Originally posted by arcadecowboy


Physics need to be accounted for. Take two players. One is 170 lbs, the other is 230 lbs. They both have the same speed ratings, strength ratings, etc. In fact, they are identical in every measurement *except size.* If these two meet in a head on collision , and keep in mind everything is equal, including technique and velocity, the 230 lb player should win.




I agree with you that they should win based on physics, but that isn't always true, so there should be a random modifier to your equation, just look at marion barber, that guy has the will to break almost any tackle and never goes down without a fight
(note: I hate the fucking cowboys, but that guy can ball)
 
p52willis
offline
Link
 
That could be cool...
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
I would prefer that a skill's number means what it means and always remains the same.

Having the same numbers mean different things will confuse scouting, matchups, and build strategy. Not to mention the chaos it could bring if implemented in medias res, because of all of the current builds that would suddenly be nerfed or super-powered.

A better option would be to make skills more/less expensive SP-wise based upon position, so (for example) a TE with 68 speed before equipment would pay 5 SP instead of 4 to get one point in Speed, while a C would pay 7 or 8 for that kind of speed. This would create a realistic range of skills by position without completely eliminating unique builds or making numerical values variable.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by robelder

I think that no fast DT should ever be able to compete in a foot race with a fast HB, WR, or CB.


Why? They have very comparable 40 times.


You put up the fastest DT you know and I'll pick 10 WR's and I guarantee that DT will not be close to any of my guys running down the field.

If you were kidding then,
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.

First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this. Really, thats the only position where anyone has an issue with speed/weight and I'm also taking a guess based on your values being focused directly on speed and blocking/block breaking ability. Lets not revamp the entire game to do that, all that will end up happening is you'll make every WR and DB a 160lb. In fact, you may make everyone in the game minus offensive linemen, blocking tight ends and full backs into that, seeing as speed backs and speedy linebackers are hugely popular.

Second, I was liking the idea of making strength an essential attribute to breaking blocks. Not sure how the game was coded but you figure a Defensive Lineman or any other defensive player needs to deal with the fact of an offensive player getting their hands on them when they are within an arms length. I doubt any swim or rip moves would work well for Dwight Freeney if he weren't very strong as well as quick on his feet. Also make it a pancake issue, because when Offensive Linemen get out into the open field, if they can get to a Defensive Back who typically has less strength that guy gets flattened 90% of the time. Granted there's stuff to take into account like the fact that the Offensive Lineman has momentum behind him but that deals with how things are coded and I don't know about that.

If defensive linemen have to increase their strength to be in any way effective, you will effectively slow them down some. The balance is in making sure that the speed rusher is still viable against a slow offensive tackle and that the bull rusher is viable against the weaker offensive tackle. A balanced Offensive Tackle facing either of those guys should have some trouble but not too much and a balanced Offensive Tackle against a balanced Defensive End should be a coin flip if they are built equally well under the system.

Tinkering with things like weight and whatnot.. I don't like it, not when the realism can be put into the attributes that we build our players with.


This makes sense...Bort's idea does sound like a response to the speed mania, which wouldn't have happened if the need for strength was properly applied. Its too easy for a weak guy to throw a block and strength really seems useless in shedding them.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Originally posted by robelder


I think that no fast DT should ever be able to compete in a foot race with a fast HB, WR, or CB.


Why? They have very comparable 40 times.


You put up the fastest DT you know and I'll pick 10 WR's and I guarantee that DT will not be close to any of my guys running down the field.

If you were kidding then,


I suggested quite a while ago perhaps putting a limit on actual speed based on weight - but that sufficienct strength would counter the braking effects of weight.
 
joeflex73
offline
Link
 
One thing I think that could make this work: Skew the soft caps by player weight for str/agi/spd.
 
tperdue
offline
Link
 
make this an epic suggestion!!
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Don't like it.

Add 50 pounds to my 220 pound blocking TE and I might be more open to the idea.

But, as it stands, it just reeks of a way to weaken the performances of players whose up-till-now irrelevant heights & weights don't match the direction their builds have taken.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knick

Maybe have lose/gain weight be a normal training option?

You don't need to be a veteran to go on a diet.


Could certainly be doable.

As for the skill idea, I was actually thinking of having a vet skill where you keep the same weight but are able to have the speed or bonus as one class up/down from your "natural" class.


 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Doesn't help.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Add 50 pounds to my 220 pound blocking TE and I might be more open to the idea.



Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Knick

Maybe have lose/gain weight be a normal training option?


Could certainly be doable.


How does that not help?
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
imo there are better ideas out there right now that should be done first
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tordman
Isn't there more serious issues to focus on, such as offensive and defensive AI's, gutting, realignment, cruise control, I could go on and on.

Suggestions forum = suggestions and ideas.


Tbis thread has started a fairly vicious cycle.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 16:26:32
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.