User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to help with low down GM's trading away players
Page:
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Voicing an opinion is not trolling. That's what helps identify good ideas and bad ideas.


I don't like it. If you are going to have the owner have to sign off on trades why not have the GM just PM the trade and have the owner send it out.


has someone said you're trolling yet?

Ok, makin sure they're still using the exact same argument.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Not sure if there are any ingenious solutions to owners who expect GM's to build their teams for them and then complaining when they do something they don't like.

My suggestion would be once your team is built - take those trade privledges back.

If you give your teenage son the keys to the car and tell him to go to the store and bring back a gallon of milk - you haven't given him the car - when he comes back you get your keys back because he doesn't need them anymore.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 09:28:18
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
What is the argument against just sending the proposed trade to the Owner and having him send it out?
 
Link
 
imo that is part of being an owner! finding a gm u can trust! if u hire soemeone u cant trust and give them powers to screw u then that is ur fault for not doing ur homework on the person b4 hiring them! so be careful who and what powers u give out till u know the person!!!!
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
What is the argument against just sending the proposed trade to the Owner and having him send it out?


No argument here - I just offered up a different solution than the one they have spent 14 pages complaining about (don't give GM privledges).
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
Originally posted by Kcirdor

Bottom line to all the arguing. Rather than saying how stupid an idea is. Offer something that can improve the idea. Don't say this is how you avoid it. It doesn't matter HOW to avoid it. You can take all the precautions in the world to not get cancer but guess what, it can still happen to you. If you don't like the idea ignore it and move along.


i dont think canadians can get cancer sorry. i win.


You're right. Instead they just die because their "free" health care doesn't do anything if you are truly sick.
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by wombat killer

What is the argument against just sending the proposed trade to the Owner and having him send it out?


No argument here - I just offered up a different solution than the one they have spent 14 pages complaining about (don't give GM privledges).


Teams are always being built and upgraded.

 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Kcirdor

Originally posted by oldskool


What you're suggesting is that owners get the benefits of letting other people do the grunt work for their team while eliminating the risk that comes along with it.


yay, you understand.


OK, I want to be able to have any player leave their contract whenever they want. I mean, that way they get the benefits of game XP without the risks that usually come with signing onto a team. Let's suggest that.

Oh and I want 100% flex refund because risk is bad. And I should never lose a game ever because I'm a paying customer so I matter.

If you want somebody else to run your team, then you run the RISK of having them run it in a way you disapprove of, and having to deal with the ramifications of that.
If you want your team run in such a way that nothing happens without your knowledge and approval, there is a way to do that and it's called "Do everything yourself".

If you can't be bothered/find the time to do it all yourself and you don't want to trust someone else to run your financial investment for you, don't make the investment in the first place.


Let's not give GMs OC priveleges, they might punt every down! Lets not give GMs DC privledges, they might all out blitz every down! Lets not give GMs the abilty to sign players and adjust the depth chart, they might sign and start all CPU players! Wait, lets not have GMs at all! That's the solution! Wheeeeeeee! People bore me.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 09:47:37
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
What happens when the scumbag GM makes the trade proposal 5 minutes before rollover?
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
What happens when the scumbag GM makes the trade proposal 5 minutes before rollover?


That would have to be coordinated and the checks and balances I am proposing would make it much much more difficult for a GM to screw your team through mass trades.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Originally posted by greengoose

Originally posted by wombat killer


What is the argument against just sending the proposed trade to the Owner and having him send it out?


No argument here - I just offered up a different solution than the one they have spent 14 pages complaining about (don't give GM privledges).


Teams are always being built and upgraded.



We understand that - but whats the functional difference between a GM working out the details of a potential trade and having him PM the owner to send out the offer and the GM just making the offer himself?

There is none - not if you expect the Owner to have veto power. You'd be better off making sure the loophole isn't there to push a trade through in the first place by not giving him trade rights to begin with.

 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by greengoose


Originally posted by wombat killer



What is the argument against just sending the proposed trade to the Owner and having him send it out?


No argument here - I just offered up a different solution than the one they have spent 14 pages complaining about (don't give GM privledges).


Teams are always being built and upgraded.



We understand that - but whats the functional difference between a GM working out the details of a potential trade and having him PM the owner to send out the offer and the GM just making the offer himself?

There is none - not if you expect the Owner to have veto power. You'd be better off making sure the loophole isn't there to push a trade through in the first place by not giving him trade rights to begin with.



There is a BIG BIG difference

During a trade there are many teams trying to get the player sometimes. If the GM finds the trade at 8:00 AM, pm's the owner, the owner gets on at 6:00 PM, by that time it is probably too late to get the player.

With my checks and balances the GM makes the trade owner gets on at 6:00 PM and sees a good trade approves it and boom you get the player you needed with little risk when it comes to handing out trade powers.
 
Rumble Bee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Now you're talking sense. In the dreaded "real life" the owner always has the final say on things, right? I don't think that would be a terrible addition. The owner (just one now, since Fight Club folded ) I GM for trusts me, but just in case he disagrees with me (as often happens between two individuals who trust each other), maybe he ought to be able to modify my dealings.


I like this idea! But I'm a newbie....AZ
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Hehe, you really think people are gonna wait 14 hours for you to come on-line to approve a trade?

Now put yourself in the GM's shoes - do you really want to have to go through all that bullshit just to do your job?

You have trade partner in sight, work out a deal, then hope the owner hasn't went to Tupelo for the weekend..... 12 hours later you get a PM back from the trade partner - Umm, I couldn't wait any longer, sorry I've traded him already.

In the mean time, you have spent 12 hours doing nothing to get that OT you really need because you already have a trade "pending" only to find out you got to start the process all over again. Meanwhile still no peep from the owner.....

Would you want to GM for that owner in the future?
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Hehe, you really think people are gonna wait 14 hours for you to come on-line to approve a trade?

Now put yourself in the GM's shoes - do you really want to have to go through all that bullshit just to do your job?

You have trade partner in sight, work out a deal, then hope the owner hasn't went to Tupelo for the weekend..... 12 hours later you get a PM back from the trade partner - Umm, I couldn't wait any longer, sorry I've traded him already.

In the mean time, you have spent 12 hours doing nothing to get that OT you really need because you already have a trade "pending" only to find out you got to start the process all over again. Meanwhile still no peep from the owner.....

Would you want to GM for that owner in the future?


The trade IS approved, the teams owner though has the power to veto the trade.

Your scenario is a good reason FOR my proposal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.