User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Blocking is already too powerful imo. Strength is the attribute that needs a boost. There is no noticeable difference in blocking between strong O-linemen and weak ones to me. No noticeable difference between strong DE's and weak ones either.

If you make blocking more powerful, we'll just have all O-linemen with builds like this:

strength: 60
blocking: 100
agility 60
speed: not needed

every single last one of them.

 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Bort

Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Not really, just people still think 50 agility with 30 speed is going to cut it.


As it should. Speed is relative to beyond three steps. If you look at the plays in the OP, the OT isn't taking one step.

OTs shouldn't need SPEED at all, since they are currently not being used to 'pull' as a lead blocker. SPEED should be completely irrelevant to the whole three-step shuffle that is required for an OT in pass protection.

Taking into account that a DE lines-up with his feet at least two yards downfield from the OTs, and has to go at least two yards further upfield that the OTs, to completely avoid contact, and the OT only has to step about three yards back in total, that means that the DE is travelling well over twice as far upfield, not to mention the step or so involved with getting behind the OT, than the OT should be moving.

SPEED is running. Pass-blocking doesn't require any running at all.



 
Link
 
Originally posted by Talon
Originally posted by Bort

Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


On your first thought, I always thought that was part of blocking. The fundamental problem right now appears to be the stat itself having no apparent counterpart for the defensive players. Meaning, what is 'anti-blocking'? The OP's complaint was that the Speed/Agility DE ran right by him, and people responded he needed more Speed/Agility. So if the LOTs start training Speed and Agility, they neglect Blocking. If a defender concentrates on Speed and Agility, he loses little right now.



shed block is the anti-blocking.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by Bort


Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Not really, just people still think 50 agility with 30 speed is going to cut it.


As it should. Speed is relative to beyond three steps. If you look at the plays in the OP, the OT isn't taking one step.

OTs shouldn't need SPEED at all, since they are currently not being used to 'pull' as a lead blocker. SPEED should be completely irrelevant to the whole three-step shuffle that is required for an OT in pass protection.

Taking into account that a DE lines-up with his feet at least two yards downfield from the OTs, and has to go at least two yards further upfield that the OTs, to completely avoid contact, and the OT only has to step about three yards back in total, that means that the DE is travelling well over twice as far upfield, not to mention the step or so involved with getting behind the OT, than the OT should be moving.

SPEED is running. Pass-blocking doesn't require any running at all.






speed is *not* running. speed = movement.

if you want your guy to move, then he better get speed.

if you want him to just stand there and let the DE go by then keep your low speed.

agility does not move you player!!!!

 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by Voltron


Originally posted by Bort



Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Not really, just people still think 50 agility with 30 speed is going to cut it.


As it should. Speed is relative to beyond three steps. If you look at the plays in the OP, the OT isn't taking one step.

OTs shouldn't need SPEED at all, since they are currently not being used to 'pull' as a lead blocker. SPEED should be completely irrelevant to the whole three-step shuffle that is required for an OT in pass protection.

Taking into account that a DE lines-up with his feet at least two yards downfield from the OTs, and has to go at least two yards further upfield that the OTs, to completely avoid contact, and the OT only has to step about three yards back in total, that means that the DE is travelling well over twice as far upfield, not to mention the step or so involved with getting behind the OT, than the OT should be moving.

SPEED is running. Pass-blocking doesn't require any running at all.






speed is *not* running. speed = movement.

if you want your guy to move, then he better get speed.

if you want him to just stand there and let the DE go by then keep your low speed.

agility does not move you player!!!!



agreed with SI

again here is my post to show what he saying....





http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223987&pbp_id=1410559

*start sarcasm*

now I did get some sacks..but I should had this sack..it is no fair..I should had a 100 sacks this game

end sarcasm

hmm..I know why this Ot blew up my DE...my guy is a speed guy,,,got locked up with a guy that has more strength..hmmm

so the Op wants to cry...well there is proof against his whining and crying

a level 30 OT takeing out a level 36 DE...dam whn you put speed on strength and the guys with speed does what he supposed to..run around the stronger guy..then yea..the ot gets beat

but if the stronger OT gets his hands on the speedy weak de..then well the speedy little De looks foolish like mine did

so now enough with the whining and crying...dam it is getting old...GLB has turn into a cry feast to see who can cry the loudest to get their way...it is supposed to be a challenge.. not well since this is to hard to figuer out..i cry like a 2 year old to get my way....jezzzzz..it is getting old
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Blocking is already too powerful imo. Strength is the attribute that needs a boost. There is no noticeable difference in blocking between strong O-linemen and weak ones to me. No noticeable difference between strong DE's and weak ones either.

If you make blocking more powerful, we'll just have all O-linemen with builds like this:

strength: 60
blocking: 100
agility 60
speed: not needed

every single last one of them.



I disagree with quite a bit of this, with the exception of the importance of strength.

I'd not argue really to nerf an attribute completely like you have with speed in this example, but merely to increase blocking's importance. There's absolutely no reason for a Level 1 OG with 20 blocking to have the exact same block radius as a Level 40 OT with 80 blocking. Like a middle schooler wouldn't have the same blocking radius as Jonathan Ogden. That's absurd, really. And it truly does need to be fixed.

Second, of course some people will adapt their builds to what works best in this game. Those agents are the smart ones, the keen ones, the ones who build great players and take pride in what they do. However, not all agents are like that. There are a lot of agents who pile on the points in SAs like there's no tomorrow. Some think that blocking is the end-all for their OT, and they'll go with that. No two builds will be exactly the same.
 
Link
 
Bort-

this is the biggest problem:

people think agility is going to move their player, but it does not.


people think of Barry Sanders or Randle El when they think of agility, but those players are very fast also.

tell them that agility has nothing to do with how fast a player gets from point A to point B and maybe they will stop crying.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
tell them that agility has nothing to do with how fast a player gets from point A to point B and maybe they will stop crying.


In a straight line, this is true.
If a player has to cut/change direction, this is false.

 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by Voltron


Originally posted by Bort



Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Not really, just people still think 50 agility with 30 speed is going to cut it.


As it should. Speed is relative to beyond three steps. If you look at the plays in the OP, the OT isn't taking one step.

OTs shouldn't need SPEED at all, since they are currently not being used to 'pull' as a lead blocker. SPEED should be completely irrelevant to the whole three-step shuffle that is required for an OT in pass protection.

Taking into account that a DE lines-up with his feet at least two yards downfield from the OTs, and has to go at least two yards further upfield that the OTs, to completely avoid contact, and the OT only has to step about three yards back in total, that means that the DE is travelling well over twice as far upfield, not to mention the step or so involved with getting behind the OT, than the OT should be moving.

SPEED is running. Pass-blocking doesn't require any running at all.






speed is *not* running. speed = movement.

if you want your guy to move, then he better get speed.

if you want him to just stand there and let the DE go by then keep your low speed.

agility does not move you player!!!!



Originally posted by Dictionary
ag¡¤ile (aj¡äəl, -¨©l¡ä)

adjective

quick and easy of movement; deft and active


http://www.yourdictionary.com/agility


Originally posted by Dictionary
ag¡¤ile [ ¨¢jj'l ]


adjective

Definition:

1. nimble: able to move quickly and with suppleness, skill, and control


http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_/agility.html

 
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Blocking is already too powerful imo. Strength is the attribute that needs a boost. There is no noticeable difference in blocking between strong O-linemen and weak ones to me. No noticeable difference between strong DE's and weak ones either.

If you make blocking more powerful, we'll just have all O-linemen with builds like this:

strength: 60
blocking: 100
agility 60
speed: not needed

every single last one of them.



I disagree with quite a bit of this, with the exception of the importance of strength.

I'd not argue really to nerf an attribute completely like you have with speed in this example, but merely to increase blocking's importance. There's absolutely no reason for a Level 1 OG with 20 blocking to have the exact same block radius as a Level 40 OT with 80 blocking. Like a middle schooler wouldn't have the same blocking radius as Jonathan Ogden. That's absurd, really. And it truly does need to be fixed.

Second, of course some people will adapt their builds to what works best in this game. Those agents are the smart ones, the keen ones, the ones who build great players and take pride in what they do. However, not all agents are like that. There are a lot of agents who pile on the points in SAs like there's no tomorrow. Some think that blocking is the end-all for their OT, and they'll go with that. No two builds will be exactly the same.



why are you so against taking speed out of the OT/DE game?

It's like you want to play want to play rock, paper, scissors.......with only rock and paper.


The easy way to get the OT to expand his radius is to get his fat ass moving faster (speed).



[sarcasm]

Why not just have 1 attribute for O-linemen and call it "blocking" and get rid of speed and strength all together?

[/sarcasm]


P.S. The Middle school analogy was a poor one. I have no idea what your point was. Size and speed are the 2 things things that determine a OT's blocking radius, not the hands techniques they learn. The hand techniques/blocking only come into play when their LEGS shuffle them over to the appropriate spot to engage the DE.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by Voltron



Originally posted by Bort




Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Not really, just people still think 50 agility with 30 speed is going to cut it.


As it should. Speed is relative to beyond three steps. If you look at the plays in the OP, the OT isn't taking one step.

OTs shouldn't need SPEED at all, since they are currently not being used to 'pull' as a lead blocker. SPEED should be completely irrelevant to the whole three-step shuffle that is required for an OT in pass protection.

Taking into account that a DE lines-up with his feet at least two yards downfield from the OTs, and has to go at least two yards further upfield that the OTs, to completely avoid contact, and the OT only has to step about three yards back in total, that means that the DE is travelling well over twice as far upfield, not to mention the step or so involved with getting behind the OT, than the OT should be moving.

SPEED is running. Pass-blocking doesn't require any running at all.






speed is *not* running. speed = movement.

if you want your guy to move, then he better get speed.

if you want him to just stand there and let the DE go by then keep your low speed.

agility does not move you player!!!!



Originally posted by Dictionary

ag¡¤ile (aj¡äəl, -¨©l¡ä)

adjective

quick and easy of movement; deft and active


http://www.yourdictionary.com/agility


Originally posted by Dictionary

ag¡¤ile [ ¨¢jj'l ]


adjective

Definition:

1. nimble: able to move quickly and with suppleness, skill, and control


http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_/agility.html




that is exactly my point. in this game agility is not defined the same as in real life.


In real life agility = agility + speed


In GLB, agility = ability to turn/cut quickly - SPEED NOT INVOLVED


See my example a few pages back.

 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

why are you so against taking speed out of the OT/DE game?

It's like you want to play want to play rock, paper, scissors.......with only rock and paper.


The easy way to get the OT to expand his radius is to get his fat ass moving faster (speed).



[sarcasm]

Why not just have 1 attribute for O-linemen and call it "blocking" and get rid of speed and strength all together?

[/sarcasm]


P.S. The Middle school analogy was a poor one. I have no idea what your point was. Size and speed are the 2 things things that determine a OT's blocking radius, not the hands techniques they learn. The hand techniques/blocking only come into play when their LEGS shuffle them over to the appropriate spot to engage the DE.


If you'd care to look back a few pages, Bort explicitly stated that every player has the same block radius. I paraphrase, but this is true. I'm not against speed, and if you find where I said I was, I'll wire you $500 right now. I think it has a crucial role for offensive linemen if used correctly. But this pretty much shoots your whole argument to shreds.

And that's what I based my middle-schooler analogy on. It's called allegory.
 
Blacksheep
offline
Link
 
Agility

How fast your player can adjust their movement. If you want to dodge a tackle or head past a blocker you'll want high agility. Important for any player who needs to turn quickly...Lineman as well as speedsters. Agility also determines acceleration. You can have all the speed in the world, but without agility, you won't ever reach that top speed.
 
Link
 
defining agility is what is throwing people off

if people understood agility, then they would build their OT's better.
 
TheRooster
offline
Link
 
Some of us have figured out how to build guys that can stop speed/agi DE's. We fix our players, rather than whining about why our 30 speed, 50 agility OT can't stop a 70 speed, 90 agility DE with 11 points in Tunnel Vision.

"But I have a million points in blocking!"

Yeah, lot of good that does you when you can't get out of your own way. Speed and agility go together, one is no good without the other.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.