User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
Fumbles are up, period.


Period? So everyone's fumbles are up? Because mine and a lot of the leading RBs in the league haven't been consistently fumbling. Ever thought maybe it has something to do with your build?

My bet is still on stamina. I have a feeling most of these fumbles are exhausted HBs out of breath who just get hit a little too hard.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by Barnsie

Originally posted by Schaffer05


^^Ok the elusive back on my team has 4 fumbles, but the power backs and my WR have 0. It's all about player build. decide to get a quick agile but weak HB you risk the chance of him fumbling against strong sure tackling defenders.


Why do you assume elusive HBs have no carrying ability? That's not true at all, and if you read the thread, most of the people have carrying above 40, even in level 19-22 range.


I don't assume a HB has no carrying ability, But what I do know is that STR+Carrying=less chance of fumbling. So with an elusive back, they neglect str, as well as carrying to an extent. They may have 48 carrying, but 30 str while a power back may have 70 Str and 40 carrying, he's still going to fumble less.

Ex1--Strength: 70.13+Carrying: 36.59+3Coverup=0 Fumbles on the season
Ex2--Strength: 40.27+Carrying: 32.87 +2Coverup=4 Fumbles on the season
Ex3--Strength: 85.77 + Carrying: 33.3 +2Coverup=0 Fumbles on the season

Those are all against the same competition

Now Just to prove my point even more so I'll go to WRs who generally don't do shit with carrying or Str.
Ex1--Strength: 28.17 + Carrying: 33.94 =0 Fumbles this season
Ex2--Strength: 23 +Carrying: 30.13 = 0 Fumbles
Ex3--Strength: 13 +Carrying: 23.02 = 1 fumble


Again all against the same competition. Bottom line is Elusive backs neglect key components to ball control because it doesn't "fit" in their building plans.


Then this would mean power backs have a significant advantage over elusive backs using your logic? NERF POWER BACKS THEN!! I have 49 carrying, 3 into cover up and have fumbled 6 times this season. Given my strength is only 30, should be irrelevant to elusive backs when considering fumbles. Why should elusive backs have to pump up one extra stat than power backs just to obtain an advantage power backs already start with? Makes no sense to me.
 
peteyskugog
offline
Link
 
Elusive backs should elude the tackle. High agility to avoid taking the full brunt of the hit.
I think somethings changed, I've noticed fumbles are up. Not sure whats changed though.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Of course you're going to need strength as a running back. You're gonna tell me that if some weak guy played HB in the NFL with all the other needed skills, he wouldn't be fumbling? Strength should be a given in something EVERY HB needs...not just power backs. Your statement is kind of like a Power back complaining that he needs speed to break tackles. It should be a given that you need certain skills as a base for any HB. After that, the rest depends on where you put your points and what type of HB you want.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2

Then this would mean power backs have a significant advantage over elusive backs using your logic? NERF POWER BACKS THEN!! I have 49 carrying, 3 into cover up and have fumbled 6 times this season. Given my strength is only 30, should be irrelevant to elusive backs when considering fumbles. Why should elusive backs have to pump up one extra stat than power backs just to obtain an advantage power backs already start with? Makes no sense to me.


Lol with you're logic you're saying Elusive backs should have the advantage over power backs? No power backs don't have an advantage... yes we fumble less because we have more strength so people can't strip the ball. That's how it works, Bort said at the end of season 3 that STR+carrying=LESS FUMBLES... yet elusive backs ignored it. You guys are a different type of back, with your thought process posession receivers should be nerfed because it's not fair that my speed WR drops more passes than a possesion WR because he has less catching. IGNORANT... Morale of the story THINK, KEY, SPEAK.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by peteyskugog
Elusive backs should elude the tackle. High agility to avoid taking the full brunt of the hit.
I think somethings changed, I've noticed fumbles are up. Not sure whats changed though.


Keep thinking that, Bort has said "NOTHING HAS CHANGED" do you think this is some sort of conspiracy against elusive backs? What's changed is defensive players are getting better and stronger since they only need to boost certain skills after a set build and elusive backs are forgetting about str and carrying.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2


Then this would mean power backs have a significant advantage over elusive backs using your logic? NERF POWER BACKS THEN!! I have 49 carrying, 3 into cover up and have fumbled 6 times this season. Given my strength is only 30, should be irrelevant to elusive backs when considering fumbles. Why should elusive backs have to pump up one extra stat than power backs just to obtain an advantage power backs already start with? Makes no sense to me.


Lol with you're logic you're saying Elusive backs should have the advantage over power backs? No power backs don't have an advantage... yes we fumble less because we have more strength so people can't strip the ball. That's how it works, Bort said at the end of season 3 that STR+carrying=LESS FUMBLES... yet elusive backs ignored it. You guys are a different type of back, with your thought process posession receivers should be nerfed because it's not fair that my speed WR drops more passes than a possesion WR because he has less catching. IGNORANT... Morale of the story THINK, KEY, SPEAK.


Did I say that? What you are basically saying is as it stands, Power backs fumble less than Elusive backs. Reasons? Because a PRIMARY stat of a power back, ALSO EFFECTS FUMBLING LESS! Get it now? Elusive backs should have that same advantage. For instance, agility should then effect fumbling for elusive backs...
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 14:15:09
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Yea, guess what we neglect to be a power back though.. Your speed and your Agility. We give up one thing for another, does that make sense to you? So we can't juke our way around a DE that's going to cream us, you can... However when you get caught by him he's going to cream you even more because you're not strong enough to run him over... does that make sense?
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Of course you're going to need strength as a running back. You're gonna tell me that if some weak guy played HB in the NFL with all the other needed skills, he wouldn't be fumbling? Strength should be a given in something EVERY HB needs...not just power backs. Your statement is kind of like a Power back complaining that he needs speed to break tackles. It should be a given that you need certain skills as a base for any HB. After that, the rest depends on where you put your points and what type of HB you want.


But speed for a power back is not the case. See the power back on my team. Guy has 40ish speed and is less than 100 yards to 2k rushing this season.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yea, guess what we neglect to be a power back though.. Your speed and your Agility. We give up one thing for another, does that make sense to you? So we can't juke our way around a DE that's going to cream us, you can... However when you get caught by him he's going to cream you even more because you're not strong enough to run him over... does that make sense?


What do you mean, you mean to tell me there is only one primary stat for a power back? lol...
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Nope, there are two primary stats for a power back Str and carrying, just as there are 2 primary stats for an elusive back... speed and agility. I don't know why you're arguing... just by looking at the SA tree's you can tell a power back will fumble less than an elusive back. My power back has soft capped speed, and slow to soft capped agility, but the carrying and str get most of my attention.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Your argument is almost like saying a DE with nothing but str and tackling should be nerfed because every time he hits someone he causes a fumble, however he only gets 1 tackle every 5 games because he's so damn slow he can never catch anyone. Your logic makes no sense since you chose to build your player that way.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2


Then this would mean power backs have a significant advantage over elusive backs using your logic? NERF POWER BACKS THEN!! I have 49 carrying, 3 into cover up and have fumbled 6 times this season. Given my strength is only 30, should be irrelevant to elusive backs when considering fumbles. Why should elusive backs have to pump up one extra stat than power backs just to obtain an advantage power backs already start with? Makes no sense to me.


Lol with you're logic you're saying Elusive backs should have the advantage over power backs? No power backs don't have an advantage... yes we fumble less because we have more strength so people can't strip the ball. That's how it works, Bort said at the end of season 3 that STR+carrying=LESS FUMBLES... yet elusive backs ignored it. You guys are a different type of back, with your thought process posession receivers should be nerfed because it's not fair that my speed WR drops more passes than a possesion WR because he has less catching. IGNORANT... Morale of the story THINK, KEY, SPEAK.


By the way, your WR receiver example is a horrible example. Catching is primary for both speed and possession receivers.. it is a main component to both builds. STR is not a main component for elusive backs.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Nope, there are two primary stats for a power back Str and carrying, just as there are 2 primary stats for an elusive back... speed and agility. I don't know why you're arguing... just by looking at the SA tree's you can tell a power back will fumble less than an elusive back. My power back has soft capped speed, and slow to soft capped agility, but the carrying and str get most of my attention.


Okay, then there is no clear advantage to building an elusive back then. Why would you do that when you can build a power back, fumble less, and produce just as much if not more. Do you see where I am going with this? Also, that is the first time i have heard anyone say carrying is a primary stat for power backs. It is like catching to a WR, both builds need it.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Of course you're going to need strength as a running back. You're gonna tell me that if some weak guy played HB in the NFL with all the other needed skills, he wouldn't be fumbling? Strength should be a given in something EVERY HB needs...not just power backs. Your statement is kind of like a Power back complaining that he needs speed to break tackles. It should be a given that you need certain skills as a base for any HB. After that, the rest depends on where you put your points and what type of HB you want.


But speed for a power back is not the case. See the power back on my team. Guy has 40ish speed and is less than 100 yards to 2k rushing this season.


Exactly...40ish speed. I'm sure if you had 40ish strength, you'd be fumbling a lot less.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.