User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Iktomi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by tmoon

...who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season.


Wow. Nobody said there would be no reward for being the home team. We don't know how it will work exactly, but chances are the home team will still get more than the away team. You say the home team gets 'no reward', but the away team gets "massive revenue". Make up your mind.

If you can make the playoffs with no effort then your league must suck. That will probably change once the gutted team change is implemented.


You are one of the "helpers" right... you post builds and help new players and create playing guides. Did it ever occur to you that you people the "helpers" are really screwing this game up too? You all want everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money... lets sit around and do nothing except follow a recipe that someone else put out and win... come on.

And my statement earlier with the massive rewards... its for not winning, not trying, not doing anything except screwing the players on your team by not making it better. How can you reward failure? How can you even consider rewarding failure? Are you one of the new teachers that are screwing up our kids at school by telling them a freakin C is ok, to not strive for excellence strive for average?

This is not an attack on you, I am trying to make a point and that point is teams that work hard and win should be rewarded, teams that don't should not.

I would like to challenge Bort and the staff to give me a gutted team in any league it doesn't matter which one, with the same restrictions currently in place and the same chemistry grace period, ect... and I will guarantee that in three seasons it will be succesfull enough to win a HOME playoff game. Any takers? If I fail, I will retire every one of my current players and start over. Any takers?

 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tmoon
You are one of the "helpers" right... you post builds and help new players and create playing guides. Did it ever occur to you that you people the "helpers" are really screwing this game up too? You all want everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money... lets sit around and do nothing except follow a recipe that someone else put out and win... come on.

And my statement earlier with the massive rewards... its for not winning, not trying, not doing anything except screwing the players on your team by not making it better. How can you reward failure? How can you even consider rewarding failure? Are you one of the new teachers that are screwing up our kids at school by telling them a freakin C is ok, to not strive for excellence strive for average?


By helping people I'm screwing up the game? I write FAQs and guides so people understand how things work so that they can make an informed choice of how to play. I don't put much opinion, like telling someone that they have to train a certain way. Yes there are some guides on how to build players, etc, that are more opinion based and if people follow them exactly then maybe they will have similar players.

Don't put words into my mouth, I don't want "everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money". I want fun competition. If helping people learn how the game works and revenue sharing in the playoffs does that then that's OK with me.

How is giving something extra to 5-8 seed teams 'rewarding failure'? Some leagues are very competitive, with the difference between getting a home playoff game or not is just a tie breaker or 1 loss. I don't consider being a 5-8 seed a failure.
 
UK Back
offline
Link
 
Bullshit
Top teams earn their money
Middle of the line teams should try it sometime
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Profit sharing is BS IMO...it was really the ONLY advantage to getting a top 4 playoff spot. Now a home game doesn't really mean anything cuz there is no home field advantage in the game.

Hey, why don't we do some Point sharing too..if your team sucks and I'm beating you by 40 in the 4th quarter, maybe Bort will make my team give your team 14 of our points....to make thing fairer even though you didn't earn them...
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 13:28:29
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by tmoon

You are one of the "helpers" right... you post builds and help new players and create playing guides. Did it ever occur to you that you people the "helpers" are really screwing this game up too? You all want everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money... lets sit around and do nothing except follow a recipe that someone else put out and win... come on.

And my statement earlier with the massive rewards... its for not winning, not trying, not doing anything except screwing the players on your team by not making it better. How can you reward failure? How can you even consider rewarding failure? Are you one of the new teachers that are screwing up our kids at school by telling them a freakin C is ok, to not strive for excellence strive for average?


By helping people I'm screwing up the game? I write FAQs and guides so people understand how things work so that they can make an informed choice of how to play. I don't put much opinion, like telling someone that they have to train a certain way. Yes there are some guides on how to build players, etc, that are more opinion based and if people follow them exactly then maybe they will have similar players.

Don't put words into my mouth, I don't want "everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money". I want fun competition. If helping people learn how the game works and revenue sharing in the playoffs does that then that's OK with me.

How is giving something extra to 5-8 seed teams 'rewarding failure'? Some leagues are very competitive, with the difference between getting a home playoff game or not is just a tie breaker or 1 loss. I don't consider being a 5-8 seed a failure.


Nixx, no need to even reply to that crap.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by tmoon

You are one of the "helpers" right... you post builds and help new players and create playing guides. Did it ever occur to you that you people the "helpers" are really screwing this game up too? You all want everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money... lets sit around and do nothing except follow a recipe that someone else put out and win... come on.

And my statement earlier with the massive rewards... its for not winning, not trying, not doing anything except screwing the players on your team by not making it better. How can you reward failure? How can you even consider rewarding failure? Are you one of the new teachers that are screwing up our kids at school by telling them a freakin C is ok, to not strive for excellence strive for average?


By helping people I'm screwing up the game? I write FAQs and guides so people understand how things work so that they can make an informed choice of how to play. I don't put much opinion, like telling someone that they have to train a certain way. Yes there are some guides on how to build players, etc, that are more opinion based and if people follow them exactly then maybe they will have similar players.

Don't put words into my mouth, I don't want "everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money". I want fun competition. If helping people learn how the game works and revenue sharing in the playoffs does that then that's OK with me.

How is giving something extra to 5-8 seed teams 'rewarding failure'? Some leagues are very competitive, with the difference between getting a home playoff game or not is just a tie breaker or 1 loss. I don't consider being a 5-8 seed a failure.


Nixx, I'm not sure why that comment was made. You a great person and the help you have given me and others when we didn't no where to find answers is incredibly valuable. I disagree with you, but respect you and your opinion on this issue.

Actually, I'm fine with more money for 5-8, but not making changes after teams that expected to win built their stadium with playoff projections. Also, one problem is that say a #1 has 10,000 more seats than a #2. Seed 8 will get more money than seed 7. Not fair. Also, in the NFL stadium are ruffly the same size. In our league it could be double, triple or quadruple the size of another. Those teams should never benefit from the sacrifice of other teams. This idea needs more ironing out and I know we don't know the specifics yet, but this was a quick decision that should have been given to everyone to talk through first. And I know it has been discussed, but not by Bort with a statement saying we are going to make changes. That is the key.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UK Back
Bullshit
Top teams earn their money
Middle of the line teams should try it sometime


Middle of the line should do a better job of winning. Go recruit better and get better at your AI and earn the prize.
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
Really we should just go ahead and give some free money to non-playoff teams too. Why stop with playoff teams? I surely don't mind busting my ass all season to get a good record only to give away the reward to teams that didn't.

Goddam this is a horrible idea. Bad, bad, bad.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Profit sharing is BS IMO...it was really the ONLY advantage to getting a top 4 playoff spot. Now a home game doesn't really mean anything cuz there is no home field advantage in the game.

Hey, why don't we do some Point sharing too..if your team sucks and I'm beating you by 40 in the 4th quarter, maybe Bort will make my team give your team 14 of our points....to make thing fairer even though you didn't earn them...


There is still an advantage to getting the home game, just not as much. 5 million versus 100K is a little unbalanced don't you think?

There is something like "point sharing", it's cruise control. It kicks in if a team is winning by 35 points.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tmoon
Originally posted by Nixx

Originally posted by tmoon


...who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season.


Wow. Nobody said there would be no reward for being the home team. We don't know how it will work exactly, but chances are the home team will still get more than the away team. You say the home team gets 'no reward', but the away team gets "massive revenue". Make up your mind.

If you can make the playoffs with no effort then your league must suck. That will probably change once the gutted team change is implemented.


You are one of the "helpers" right... you post builds and help new players and create playing guides. Did it ever occur to you that you people the "helpers" are really screwing this game up too? You all want everyone to be equal, have equal builds, have equal money... lets sit around and do nothing except follow a recipe that someone else put out and win... come on.

And my statement earlier with the massive rewards... its for not winning, not trying, not doing anything except screwing the players on your team by not making it better. How can you reward failure? How can you even consider rewarding failure? Are you one of the new teachers that are screwing up our kids at school by telling them a freakin C is ok, to not strive for excellence strive for average?

This is not an attack on you, I am trying to make a point and that point is teams that work hard and win should be rewarded, teams that don't should not.

I would like to challenge Bort and the staff to give me a gutted team in any league it doesn't matter which one, with the same restrictions currently in place and the same chemistry grace period, ect... and I will guarantee that in three seasons it will be succesfull enough to win a HOME playoff game. Any takers? If I fail, I will retire every one of my current players and start over. Any takers?



Helping people understand and enjoy the game is screwing it up??
Secondly, working your ass off and doing everyting right DOESN"T guarantee you a 1-4 seed! You act like its automatic and that anyone who doesn't make a 1-4 seed is just not trying at all. And really the point is not who worked harder or is better financially or in any regard. Its about promoting a FAIR system that gives everyone the same opportunities to improve. No one here has stated that it should be 50/50 (or 1/16th x 16) and for you to insinuate that is incorrect and skewing the whole subject. EVERY team should be able to reap the benefits of their work. At the very least, playoff teams should get much more than 100k for making the playoffs. Your stance is obviously taken with the goal of keeping others down. This is NOT about you, its about the game and everyone involved. Get over the self righteous aspect of your argument. You work no harder than many owners whether you have a better record/team/stadium or a better anything.
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
Maybe we can all just hold hands and sing songs instead of playing this game.

I mean really, a game shouldn't have "winners" and "losers", everybody is a big winner! Let's not even keep track of the score anymore. Who cares right? Let's all go 8-8 and share the wins too! Maybe give some of those yards your HB got to a struggling HB so he has good stats!






 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
chriscuster, how about some useful suggestions or arguments instead of just sarcasm?
 
Iktomi
offline
Link
 
I guess by me not saying this is not a personal attack it wasn't good enough. Nixx you are a good person for helping people. Taking your free time and dedicating it to others is an admirable thing.

So me having an opinion is crap... man that communist mentality is spreading. Lets all freakin burn the red white and blue, read some Marx and share, share everything.

When you quoted me you took only part of the text and none of the previous comments about people wanting playoff teams to share their money with EVERYONE in the league including gutted and completely worthless teams. The couple of hours I put into this everyday shouldn't be equal to a guy who does nothing and wants the same reward... i.e. revenue sharing. Communist, pure and simple communist.

Social Welfare comes to GLB... that should be the next GLB radio broadcast.

 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Because people that don't have a real argument rely on sarcasm to distract from the real point.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by canes30
Originally posted by Stephenthegreat

Profit sharing for the playoffs is the stupidest thing I've heard of.....

Why should barely active owners with a team full of cpus or farm teams get the money we need for upgrades on the stadium and equipment?



Those teams don't make it to the playoffs.


Oh I see. So we share with the bottom four teams playoff teams.... Nah they should earn it like everybody else.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.