User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > An Admin-Selected Suggestion Screener
Page:
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
It seems like we need this now more than ever...I added re-rolling to the moratorium list. It's a mess in here
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Pancakes
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Latest reiteration of OP (10/7 13:46 CDT)

This thread suggests the creation of an Admin-appointed "custodian of suggestions" whose ultimate function is to pare down the hundreds of suggestions to the few pertinent ones to be relayed to the Admins.

This could be accomplished by:
- A moderator who locks/removes poor suggestion threads to ease Admins' browsing
- A liaison who screens the threads and directly submits them to the Admins
- Revising moderators' responsibilities to specific forums
- An extended sub-forum structure
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moderator/Admin opinions:
Originally posted by Jed

I don't know if Bort's going to do it, but there was some talk on the Mod forum for there to be an Announcements-style forum as a Suggestions sub-forum for the really good ones any Mod or Admin finds. No threads could be started there, only posted to, and it would give an easier place for Bort to see the ones which Mods/other Admins have already found and thought were good.



 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
BigT was all over that draft thread. Excellent work, big guy.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
BigT was all over that draft thread. Excellent work, big guy.


Big T is the Shiz that's why.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Wish he'd kill off the re-roll thread, too...
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Voting system might help improve thread quality by knocking out crappy threads. A sort-by-rating function would help greatly, as well.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Check out Ken1's idea of a karma system. I think its pretty fair
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Latest reiteration of OP (10/7 13:46 CDT)

This thread suggests the creation of an Admin-appointed "custodian of suggestions" whose ultimate function is to pare down the hundreds of suggestions to the few pertinent ones to be relayed to the Admins.

This could be accomplished by:
- A moderator who locks/removes poor suggestion threads to ease Admins' browsing
- A liaison who screens the threads and directly submits them to the Admins
- Revising moderators' responsibilities to specific forums
- An extended sub-forum structure
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moderator/Admin opinions:
Originally posted by Jed

I don't know if Bort's going to do it, but there was some talk on the Mod forum for there to be an Announcements-style forum as a Suggestions sub-forum for the really good ones any Mod or Admin finds. No threads could be started there, only posted to, and it would give an easier place for Bort to see the ones which Mods/other Admins have already found and thought were good.


 
trendon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I imagine that the 5 admins are busy fellas, and that they're fairly occupied with the programming and maintenance of the game and with their personal lives.


If they made less rules, they'd have less work. It is their own self-fulfilling prophecy. They spend more time and bandwidth on moderating these forums - and complaining about wayward posts - than they do working on a search engine.

That's moderated forums for ya, though. It allows any idiot to post and any idiot to moderate. It requires no thought and, ultimately, implodes under its own restrictions because it restricts the ability of the users to properly communicate all in the name of tidiness.

Last edited Oct 9, 2008 21:23:05
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trendon
Originally posted by dmfa41

I imagine that the 5 admins are busy fellas, and that they're fairly occupied with the programming and maintenance of the game and with their personal lives.


If they made less rules, they'd have less work. It is their own self-fulfilling prophecy.



Wrong, this isn't about rules...it's about stupid people continuing to bring up stupid threads, since they can't read.
 
trendon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Originally posted by trendon

Originally posted by dmfa41


I imagine that the 5 admins are busy fellas, and that they're fairly occupied with the programming and maintenance of the game and with their personal lives.


If they made less rules, they'd have less work. It is their own self-fulfilling prophecy.



Wrong, this isn't about rules...it's about stupid people continuing to bring up stupid threads, since they can't read.


Ignore them.

What did you people do before moderated forums? Cry on your keyboard? Not allowed to use the computer at that time?

Last edited Oct 9, 2008 21:23:48
 
trendon
offline
Link
 
Trendon's Two Point Plan to Fixing Forum Problems

1. Fix the search engine.
2. Ignore stupid posts/threads.

That's it.

I bet you guys waste an entire server on people bitching about stupid posts and moderators coming in and announcing they've locked the thread. And, ironically, it not only creates more clutter but ensures the stupid thread will get more airtime on the first page.

I might be old at a ripe age of 29, but shit if I don't weep for the internet. It once was visited by people with common sense and a pair of eyes.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trendon

Ignore them.

What did you people do before moderated forums? Cry on your keyboard? Not allowed to use the computer at that time?



Really have you ever tried ignoring them? Because I have and the only thing that ever happens is they get others to go "oh man sweet yeah this is awesome" or bump their thread forever.

And yes i was totally sitting in a dark room crying on my keyboard before an understaffed mod team got here. Don't be an idiot.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trendon

1. Fix the search engine.
2. Ignore stupid posts/threads.


That's your brilliant plan?

neato lets do it right now. GO!

have you fixed it yet?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.