Originally posted by TreMetal
RAPB, you clearly have no understanding of what the bug is.
The bug is that the ball is moving faster than the SIM is able to update the game status. So, at the end of one tick it is too far away to catch, but the next tick takes so long that the ball has "hit the ground". If there were intermediate updates to the game state the WR would make a play on the ball.
Edit:
For example, imagine someone is throwing a football to you, but you can only open your eyes for 1 second every 3 seconds. More often than not the ball is going to bounce off of your face (assuming that is where it is aimed).1. Look at this replay (first one in the OP):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=192589&pbp_id=15698202. Let's just watch the 3 "ticks" before the play is over in the film. There might be more the SIM calculates, but it even shows some of them.
3. On the first of those ticks, the ball is about 2-3 yards away from the WR and represented above the CB spot. On the second tick, the ball is about 1 yard away from the WR, on the third the ball is represented above the WR spot. Looks like it calculates the ball roughly about every 2 yards.
4. Now ask yourself: If you shoot a picture of a deep football pass at the time the ball is one yard away from the WR - what height should it have? And will it hit the ground one yard later? What travelling height would the ball have if it was to hit the ground 2 yards later?
5. I still state that those are very, very bad passes - poorly underthrown. I'm all for the "increased granularity proximity check" as soon as the ball is close to the WR. Great jumping catches do happen! But a team and his QB shouldn't rely on those rare occasions.
So it's more like:
- someone is throwing a football to you, but you can only open your eyes for 0.1 seconds every 0.3 seconds; at the same time, it rules the ball caught if you just get your hands somewhere near the ball within that 0.1 seconds
- but it's MUCH easier to get your hands near a very low pass if it checks every 0.025 seconds if your hand is somewhere near - but it's more unrealistic too
- last season, a QB with less strength had to throw it higher since he couldn't fire a bullet (not enough strength to do so). This season he fires the bullet - but too low. He got the power, but not accuracy needed.