User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > "Missing" Intense Training Combos
Page:
 
kb2120
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigpimpin123
hmmm looks good...nightly processing is exactly what I wanted to see haha


Except some training points would have been nice...
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
The new options:

Hurdle Drills (+jumping, +stamina)
Hill Sprints (+speed, +stamina)
Distance Run (+confidence, +stamina)
Power Running Drills (+strength, +carrying)
Return Drills (+agility, +vision)
Pocket Drills (+throwing, +agility)
Possession Catching (+catching, +jumping)
Football Launcher Drills (+catching, +vision)
Distance Kicking Drills (+kicking, +strength)
Deep Punting Drills (+punting, +strength)
Quick Tackling Drills (+tackling, +agility)
Force Fumble Drills (+tackling, +strength)
Diving Tackle Drills (+tackling, +jumping)

Previous options:

1. Sled Drills (+blocking, +strength)
2. Pass Blocking Drills (+blocking, +agility)
3. Leg Press (+strength, +jumping)
4. Up Downs (+agility, +stamina)
5. Wind Sprints (+speed, +agility)
6. Precision Throwing Drills (+throwing, +vision)
7. Distance Throwing Drills (+throwing, +strength)
8. Study Game Film (+vision, +confidence)
9. Precision Catching Drills (+catching, +carrying)
10. Kicking Drills (+kicking, +vision)
11. Punting Drills (+punting, +vision)
12. Carrying Drills (+carrying, +confidence)
13. Pursuit Drills (+tackling, +speed)
14. Coverage Drills (+jumping, +vision)

so ...

If you want to train ___________, you must also train ___________.

Strength ... Blocking, Jumping, Throwing, Carrying, Kicking, Punting, Tackling
Speed ... Agility, Tackling, Stamina
Agility ... Blocking, Stamina, Speed Vision, Tackling
Jumping ... Strength, Vision, Stamina, Catching, Tackling
Stamina ... Agility, Speed, Jumping, Confidence
Vision ... Throwing, Confidence, Kicking, Punting, Jumping, Agility, Catching
Confidence ... Vision, Carrying, Stamina

Blocking ... Strength, Agility
Tackling ... Speed, Agility, Strength, Jumping
Throwing ... Vision, Strength
Catching ... Carrying, Jumping, Vision
Carrying ... Catching, Confidence, Strength
Kicking ... Vision, Strength
Punting ... Vision, Strength
Last edited Sep 18, 2008 03:58:26
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
List of the new ones: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1056642

Originally posted by turnit643
The new options:


Beat you by 30 seconds, hah! OK, sorry. Yours is better anyways.

Sleepy time.
Last edited Sep 18, 2008 03:50:12
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
List of the new ones: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1056642

Originally posted by turnit643

The new options:


Beat you by 30 seconds, hah! OK, sorry. Yours is better anyways.

Sleepy time.


Yep, time for some sleep.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.


Because otherwise there is NO drawback to intense training at all, and normal becomes completely worthless, since the total points gained is the same. If you want the two dropdowns, intense would have to cost three times as much, or give a smaller bonus or something.

Limited choices for intense means that, beyond adding some realism to training, if you want bonus tokens you have to make a choice between training exactly what you want, or getting the bonus tokens, but you can't have both.



I'm all for risk-reward, pros-cons. The main thing I think is that coming up with combos is too messy and a chore to scroll thru. 14 down one list, 14 down the other. All the combinations in the world in an oyster right there. So, like you say, where's the risk-reward? You're full of great ideas Bort. As are others. Like you said, there could be a higher cost, smaller bonus, etc. Stuff like that would then make it do-able (the drop-downs and giving people the leeway to choose any combination from that).

You also said Normal would become almost useless. But if im not mistaken, only Normal training allows one to use "no activity, slight training bonus", or, "go shopping", or "night on the town, morale boost". And if it's not set up like that, then how about doing that to make it a choice.....do intense and get to train two attributes, or, do normal and train one attribute AND get to shop or hit the town.

You could even add another similar interesting option in Normal for people that makes it as attractive as Intense.

Last edited Sep 18, 2008 04:52:22
 
JefT@nk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
How about just half the time on one drill and half the time on another to get any combination of 2 abilities? Do we really need to sit here and come up with 196 exercises that will cover all possible combinations? I'm sure if we tried hard enough we could, but is it really necessary?

Can't we just replace the current "selection regimen" combo box with two combo boxes (1 for 1st attribute trained and 1 for 2nd attribute trained)?


This looks like the option that satisfies everyone.
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
The new options:

Hurdle Drills (+jumping, +stamina)
Hill Sprints (+speed, +stamina)
Distance Run (+confidence, +stamina)
Power Running Drills (+strength, +carrying)
Return Drills (+agility, +vision)
Pocket Drills (+throwing, +agility)
Possession Catching (+catching, +jumping)
Football Launcher Drills (+catching, +vision)
Distance Kicking Drills (+kicking, +strength)
Deep Punting Drills (+punting, +strength)
Quick Tackling Drills (+tackling, +agility)
Force Fumble Drills (+tackling, +strength)
Diving Tackle Drills (+tackling, +jumping)

Previous options:

1. Sled Drills (+blocking, +strength)
2. Pass Blocking Drills (+blocking, +agility)
3. Leg Press (+strength, +jumping)
4. Up Downs (+agility, +stamina)
5. Wind Sprints (+speed, +agility)
6. Precision Throwing Drills (+throwing, +vision)
7. Distance Throwing Drills (+throwing, +strength)
8. Study Game Film (+vision, +confidence)
9. Precision Catching Drills (+catching, +carrying)
10. Kicking Drills (+kicking, +vision)
11. Punting Drills (+punting, +vision)
12. Carrying Drills (+carrying, +confidence)
13. Pursuit Drills (+tackling, +speed)
14. Coverage Drills (+jumping, +vision)

so ...

If you want to train ___________, you must also train ___________.

Strength ... Blocking, Jumping, Throwing, Carrying, Kicking, Punting, Tackling
Speed ... Agility, Tackling, Stamina
Agility ... Blocking, Stamina, Speed Vision, Tackling
Jumping ... Strength, Vision, Stamina, Catching, Tackling
Stamina ... Agility, Speed, Jumping, Confidence
Vision ... Throwing, Confidence, Kicking, Punting, Jumping, Agility, Catching
Confidence ... Vision, Carrying, Stamina

Blocking ... Strength, Agility
Tackling ... Speed, Agility, Strength, Jumping
Throwing ... Vision, Strength
Catching ... Carrying, Jumping, Vision
Carrying ... Catching, Confidence, Strength
Kicking ... Vision, Strength
Punting ... Vision, Strength


Actually, I'm pretty happy with this list. It gives a good number of options, there's fairly ideal combos for every position, there's still some limit to intense, and you can still train to a variety of builds.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.


Because otherwise there is NO drawback to intense training at all, and normal becomes completely worthless, since the total points gained is the same. If you want the two dropdowns, intense would have to cost three times as much, or give a smaller bonus or something.

Limited choices for intense means that, beyond adding some realism to training, if you want bonus tokens you have to make a choice between training exactly what you want, or getting the bonus tokens, but you can't have both.


I did propose a solution with drop down menus that could open up every possible combination, including the same attribute twice, with the primary always training at approximately 25% bonus and the 2nd attribute training at anywhere between -25% normal to 25% bonus, depending on the pairing.

For example...

Training the same attribute twice (Primary 125%, Secondary 75%) = 200% over 2.5 days. Normal can train at 250% over 2.5 days, more if you use "no activity, small training bonus".

Training a combo you aren't fond of (Primary 125%, Secondary 100%) = 225% over 2.5 days. Still a 25% minimum gain on normal.

Training one of the "preferred combos" (Primary 125%, Secondary 125%) = 250% over 2.5 days. Equal to normal unless they use "no activity".

This would allow the flexibility people want for building their toon how they choose to build their toon. But for that flexibility, there is a cost depending on the pairing.

And might I add that with the new training bar system, are you considering allowing people to train special abilities? One thought here - make that only available on normal (no training 2 abilities at once, keep it simple and offer normal a bonus to offset the proposed opening of all training options on intense as per above). The training bar system opens that option up completely in my opinion, and again adds variety to build choices.

I don't think I'm the only one that likes this idea
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Two other things Bort:

1st - great idea from rbedgood for preseason:

Originally posted by rbedgood
To play with the training camp idea what if we were each given 4 points per day during the pre-season. It would encourage people to get on and use their training points, and additionally it would be like "two-a-days" for training camp. Keeping team forums alive during the offseason/pre-season is about impossible. Fortunately I was only recruiting for 1 position this offseason, but man it would've sucked to be recruiting for much more.


2nd - can you explain how the current changes encourage people logging in every day? Unless I'm mistaken on how the new training system works, I still only need to log in to check game results and set tactics. Since I can save up to 10 training points, there is no need for me to spend them right away. Since we use a training bar vs. increasing an attribute marginally each day through training, I won't see a result in my player for multiple days, or I can save my training points and do my training all at once to ensure I see a "growth". I think others are a bit stumped on this as well, since one of the goals here (I think) was to get people more interested and involved from the player side, and I'm worried this will actually have people choosing to log in less often (unless they are GLB addicts like me).
 
head1
offline
Link
 
nm
Last edited Sep 18, 2008 10:28:36
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Two other things Bort:

1st - great idea from rbedgood for preseason:

Originally posted by rbedgood

To play with the training camp idea what if we were each given 4 points per day during the pre-season. It would encourage people to get on and use their training points, and additionally it would be like "two-a-days" for training camp. Keeping team forums alive during the offseason/pre-season is about impossible. Fortunately I was only recruiting for 1 position this offseason, but man it would've sucked to be recruiting for much more.


2nd - can you explain how the current changes encourage people logging in every day? Unless I'm mistaken on how the new training system works, I still only need to log in to check game results and set tactics. Since I can save up to 10 training points, there is no need for me to spend them right away. Since we use a training bar vs. increasing an attribute marginally each day through training, I won't see a result in my player for multiple days, or I can save my training points and do my training all at once to ensure I see a "growth". I think others are a bit stumped on this as well, since one of the goals here (I think) was to get people more interested and involved from the player side, and I'm worried this will actually have people choosing to log in less often (unless they are GLB addicts like me).


Neither of those belong in this thread.
 
jayzen
offline
Link
 
I think strength and stamina is reasonable and realistic and this combination is probably useful at every position.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Originally posted by SCACE

Two other things Bort:

1st - great idea from rbedgood for preseason:

Originally posted by rbedgood


To play with the training camp idea what if we were each given 4 points per day during the pre-season. It would encourage people to get on and use their training points, and additionally it would be like "two-a-days" for training camp. Keeping team forums alive during the offseason/pre-season is about impossible. Fortunately I was only recruiting for 1 position this offseason, but man it would've sucked to be recruiting for much more.


2nd - can you explain how the current changes encourage people logging in every day? Unless I'm mistaken on how the new training system works, I still only need to log in to check game results and set tactics. Since I can save up to 10 training points, there is no need for me to spend them right away. Since we use a training bar vs. increasing an attribute marginally each day through training, I won't see a result in my player for multiple days, or I can save my training points and do my training all at once to ensure I see a "growth". I think others are a bit stumped on this as well, since one of the goals here (I think) was to get people more interested and involved from the player side, and I'm worried this will actually have people choosing to log in less often (unless they are GLB addicts like me).


Neither of those belong in this thread.


I'll post what I feel like in this thread as long as it has to do with the new options, but thanks for your concern.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Step back, SCACE the Internet tough guy coming through.

This thread is about the combinations that are/were missing from the current implementation, not how to changing the implementation. I am sorry that is difficult for you to comprehend, but hopefully you understand now.

I get that you want to soap box on a stickied thread, but no one is listening and you are just making people wade through garbage posts (which actually would make decent suggestions in their own thread).
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Step back, SCACE the Internet tough guy coming through.

This thread is about the combinations that are/were missing from the current implementation, not how to changing the implementation. I am sorry that is difficult for you to comprehend, but hopefully you understand now.

I get that you want to soap box on a stickied thread, but no one is listening and you are just making people wade through garbage posts (which actually would make decent suggestions in their own thread).


LOL - I know what YOU started the thread for. Don't worry, the good suggestions are also posted in other areas discussing the same subjects.

Have a good day
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.