User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Padre
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


Why does there need to be a solution? If you choose to trust these guys and have them help you out then that is the way it is.

No matter what the issue is people are going to try and continue to push you around. People who want to push the envelope as far as they can for any number of reasons.

 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


I don't have a problem with them continuing to play, I just think that their advantage should be known publicly.
 
VietCampo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by naki
Originally posted by oppco80

It is a freaking game! It is nothing more --- yet the outrage at a game being tested before going live is hilarious. If you all are this upset at the prospect of a game being tested by REAL PEOPLE you need to work on improving something else in your life.



I did my tax return a few days ago. I Was outraged that I have to pay back the stimulus check from last year when I was told I wouldnt have to.

I guess if you are truly outraged at this you probably have been raped by the government enough yet. Or you are some college kid or younger who hasnt bene in the real world enough.


lolgovernment
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by cbarge


Originally posted by wombat killer



Originally posted by tpaterniti




It is fair. If you have a question, ask me. If I know, I'll tell you no matter who you are. Seems pretty simple.


Wow. You really don't see the problem?


Did you read anything he said besides "Seems pretty simple?"


Did you pay attention to the problem at hand? The problem is Testers gaining advantages over other users, tpat basically said they do but it's ok, he'll tell you about it. What about the things other testers find and how will we know if he told us everyting? I am not trying to call tpat a liar but who knows?



That's not what he was addressing! All he said was that he would field all questions. There's no need to jump on people for no reason.



Thats the problem. Someone with more information than the rest of us is giving it out to a very small group of people.
 
Keiichi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


Yes end of controversy really.

I'm on a team I just signed with that some have already called out in this thread. Don't see any inside info published, doubt they do, but I'd rather not have that hanging over anything our team does.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viet
-Dump DigitalDaggers


i'm obviously not adding that.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Bort

So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


Agreed.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


At Least it balances things out. Even if they didnt quit playing at least have them keep open builds on all accounts?

If were given a list of 5 guys im going to be pissed but a full list of anyone involved would be nice.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by oppco80

It is a freaking game! It is nothing more --- yet the outrage at a game being tested before going live is hilarious.


No what's hilarious is that there are still people who believe this game is in beta.


Is it really worth getting that worked up over? With everything else the world has to offer and all the other problems society has we whine for hours over the prospect of a tester group?
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Republicans: Understand whats going on, game needs testers
Democrats: ITS NOT FAIR TO ME...THEY HAVE MORE INFO...EVERYONE IS EQUAL
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JHight
I've been on test servers before for two different mainstream MMORPGs and I hate to break it to you guys, but they aren't all that they are cracked up to be. You may think that you can get an advantage by testing builds, but remember, the builds are only for current or near current coding, far away from what will be effective in the 4+ months it takes to actually create the build you want.

As for listing names and the like, no, it shouldn't happen. I had my guild/kin/group outed as being on a test server and everyone thought our accomplishments were tainted. What they didn't know was that we often were testing redundant things just to make sure no bugs occurred, not even getting a set strategy down.

You guys just need to calm down. This is a NECCESSARY part of MMOs. It happens in EVERY GAME. They are trying to get rid of the bugs in coding before it comes to live, not trying to get a leg up on anyone. Yes, there are those that attempt that, but for the most part, they fail because the coding is so different.


Coming out and making it transparent certainly will help with the "misunderstanding" of the test server by the public. But keeping the secrecy will create a lot of question marks.
 
tycoon34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


I think that would diminish any worries.

We want many testers on this game...we want it to get better. We just want to get rid of as many disadvantegous as possible.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall
Originally posted by Catullus 16
potential solutions
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers
- hire paid testers (that aren't also players)
- screenshots/details of testing interface

add what dpell and PierreThomas stated and I think you'll have it.


i think i've made myself dizzy... link?

if i've missed people's solutions, please let me know.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. It would just make them bigger targets when their teams won. When suddenly they have a DE putting up 50 sacks a season when last season he didn't put up 20. Your point above is part of the solution, but not ALL of it. I'd like to know who the testers are, but we also need transparency into what's going on. As we've said like 1000 times, we're worried they gain information on builds and tactics from the testing that give them an advantage over us.

That's why I like my nominated tester idea. Make the testers responsible to the people who nominate them to get the information out. If keeping the information secret is bad then make it something the testers want to get out. Give them some free FP. Let their leagues nominate them. If too much information is available then maybe we'll all see this really is nothing but boring SIM watching like you want it to be.
 
Link
 
Best Solution:

Give everyone tester access so we can learn what everyone else is learning. This is the only fair thing to do.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.