User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin

it's 24's playing against 10's that is the problem.
Things don't have to be equal to be fair.
And people winning and losing is part of this game, more than it's a part of life.
This isn't about some losers crying, it's about some losers moving a pro-level team to a new league just so they can dominate and show their shiny trophies to their internet girlfriend.


Nothing in life is fair.

When someone need to move his whole team into a low level league, there should be other ways to take care of this. Some owner do a great job of recruiting brining in some higher level players and a few days later some more. This will not happen anymore, cause some people complains that they are playing in a league where some other are playing with a level way above.



i think what i don't understand is why anyone that wants to play this game the way it is meant to be played(like football) would want a team that only wins because it's levels are so far ahead of everyone else that they can not possibly lose. this is a game of strategy, tactics, and thought, not of might. Fielding a competitive team, and using tactics should be the deciding factor in a win. And this change goes towards that. Now higher levels will have to weigh XP loss over domination. and that's a good motivator for most involved. if a owner is actively looking for players that are 8+ levels higher than the rest of his competition then his players should be gaining less XP. It isn't about fair, unfair, it's about the spirit of football.
In the NFL the talent levels, while no where close to the same with every player, are still within some sort of median of competition. even the patriots can lose, even the dolphins can win.. one.
 
Predian
offline
Link
 
The one and ONLY thing that bothers me about this change is that it penalizes folks who have more than 3 players on any specific team. I have a ton of players because I really enjoy the game. I want to be an ACTIVE player, so I try very hard to consolidate my players across a few teams. That way I have less forums to check, etc etc. As a result, I have 3 teams where I have many players, and I'm trying to make that 4 (slowly eliminating the teams I just have 1 player on).

This new system punishes me for that. And I don't think it's in any way against the spirit of the game or against the spirit of competition.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Predian
The one and ONLY thing that bothers me about this change is that it penalizes folks who have more than 3 players on any specific team. I have a ton of players because I really enjoy the game. I want to be an ACTIVE player, so I try very hard to consolidate my players across a few teams. That way I have less forums to check, etc etc. As a result, I have 3 teams where I have many players, and I'm trying to make that 4 (slowly eliminating the teams I just have 1 player on).

This new system punishes me for that. And I don't think it's in any way against the spirit of the game or against the spirit of competition.


it doesn't punish you until you start dropping your players into FA and then resigning them to another single team.
As long as all yourplayers are on your team, and are there for a long time they will be fine. Also as long as your players are within the median+8 "recommended max level" for your league they will not be affected either.
 
Predian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin
Originally posted by Predian

The one and ONLY thing that bothers me about this change is that it penalizes folks who have more than 3 players on any specific team. I have a ton of players because I really enjoy the game. I want to be an ACTIVE player, so I try very hard to consolidate my players across a few teams. That way I have less forums to check, etc etc. As a result, I have 3 teams where I have many players, and I'm trying to make that 4 (slowly eliminating the teams I just have 1 player on).

This new system punishes me for that. And I don't think it's in any way against the spirit of the game or against the spirit of competition.


it doesn't punish you until you start dropping your players into FA and then resigning them to another single team.
As long as all yourplayers are on your team, and are there for a long time they will be fine. Also as long as your players are within the median+8 "recommended max level" for your league they will not be affected either.


That's not how I read it. You get a bonus to sportsmanship for signing with a team that you have 3 or less players on. You don't get that bonus if you have more than 3 players. Not getting the bonus is the same as being penalized.
 
Predian
offline
Link
 
The other piece is accepting a minimum contract. I always accept the minimum, whether I own/GM the team or not. Why is this considered poor sportsmanship?
 
uncle_wilf
offline
Link
 
Has anybody here actually calculated the median level of their league? I have. BB#9 has a median player level of 12. Therefore the recommended maximum level will be 20. The highest level player is 19. And the median level will certainly go up over the course of the season, thus the maximum level will rise.

Let's face it. Very few people will be affected by this change.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 06:02:12
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Predian
The other piece is accepting a minimum contract. I always accept the minimum, whether I own/GM the team or not. Why is this considered poor sportsmanship?


it's only considered poor sportsmanship if you are moving a pro-level team to a newly created league to dominate, as is all of this.
While yes it might be that your sportsmanship score could go down if you move your players into and out of Free Agency. As long as those players are within the Median+8 recommended max level, then you don't even have to start worrying about losing XP. the sportsmanship score only affects you if you are above the recommended level, and then only determines how far above you have to be before you start losing XP, and at what % you will lose it.
 
uncle_wilf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=3069

This asshat has signed 2 players, both level 1. That is going to throw off the league.

No. If he signs 100 level 1 players, that might bring the median down by one. But if that were the case, signing 100 players a 1 level below the median would do the same thing.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by uncle_wilf
Originally posted by czman

http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=3069

This asshat has signed 2 players, both level 1. That is going to throw off the league.

No. If he signs 100 level 1 players, that might bring the median down by one. But if that were the case, signing 100 players a 1 level below the median would do the same thing.



also, while bort hasn't said anything about the recommended max level and how it is determined, i hope it's recalculated every night during training time, to take into account daily boosts and game leveling.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
it is he did say it would be updated daily right?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
it is he did say it would be updated daily right?


BORT: The median levels will be computed daily...


yes, yes he did, thank you for making me find that...
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 06:19:19
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
The types of things that improve or reset sportsmanship to the max:
- Signing with a team where you are at or under the recommended level
- Signing with a team where you are one of only 1-3 players above the recommended level (mentoring)
- Playing a game with your team (sticking with the team)
- Resigning with a team (limits per season apply)
- Boosting
- Being one of 3 or less players on the team owned by the same agent

Can someone explain this, will I be affected if I have 4 players on a team, maybe I am just tired.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Will the 'Max Level' accomodate boosting?

Also, what if you were on a team to start the season and then changes on other teams happen to bump you out to the point where you would be too high? When you signed you were OK. Also, folks that level up during he season, again were fine (and by the end of the season they might be fine again with all the late season boosters finally boosting)

Additionally, what about players who were fine until you processed the 'Demotions' and new teams came into the league, were gutted, players quit, etc. They were fine _before_ bu because of demotions/promotions the league Median changed and now players who were fine before are now screwed.

I'm for this idea.. I think its a good one, but I think some kinks/exceptions need to be ironed out as deciding to play on the same team for a whole career should be encouraged and not penalised.

-G

EDIT - I think this idea would work best if you also do more promotions/demotions at the end of the season. The top four teams in a league should go up, the bottom 8 teams should move down.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 06:25:17
 
xnahog
offline
Link
 
Check out my team and then get back to me. I spent a lot of time recruiting and making trades for high level players. So when I start next season and guys boost they're going to be penalized because they're over the medium. This is a waste of money for me.

IF YOU'RE REALLY OUT TO GET THE GUYS THAT TAKE ADVANTAGE THEN DO IT CASE BY CASE. IT'S NOT THAT HARD TO SPOT.

Here's the main point that I don't get. If a team is "THAT GOOD" they'll move up to the next league. Am I not correct on this? I don't understand why rules are changes (especially the day before the season starts and I've spent all this time building a great roster for BBB) because people don't like getting beat. Not everyone can win a championship. That's why I went and got players who I think can. Now their abilities will be dumbed down and some other team's players will be equal to them although THEY"RE NOT!

I think socialism in a video game is quite humorous. Everybody needs to be equal so the teams getting beat don't get sad. Sheesh.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
i have to agree from both sides, i mean i don't really have a stacked roster but i have a few level 16,17s on my BBB4 team. thing that makes me the most made is i would say about 5 or so agents make up the bulk of the team, and while the most one of us has is 6 players on board and the least is 3 I dont see why we'll have to get penalized by not getting a the same bonus although we're all signed long term for fair contracts. some of the players are even just backups like the QB, or the kicker, i mean come on its not like we have 10 high profile level 20+ players on the same squad.

i think borts ideas are great in principle but need to become more targeted to those that are ruining parity too much not those that are doing a great job at ownership or in the free agency market.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.