Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
nfratami
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
if you can tell it is working as intended you have more knowledge than we do
obviously you won't have a % on how much more effective it is, how the hell would you come to that anyway? no one is accusing testers of developing statistical conclusions
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
if you can tell it is working as intended you have more knowledge than we do
obviously you won't have a % on how much more effective it is, how the hell would you come to that anyway? no one is accusing testers of developing statistical conclusions
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by quzur
Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
I dress Bort, then he dresses Voltron, then Volt dresses me...that is unless the music stops early.
Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
I dress Bort, then he dresses Voltron, then Volt dresses me...that is unless the music stops early.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 21:58:52
Asheme
offline
offline
Originally posted by quzur
I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning.
I don't know about you, but I can still manage to not walk out of the house naked, no matter how embarrassing my previous night was.
I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning.
I don't know about you, but I can still manage to not walk out of the house naked, no matter how embarrassing my previous night was.
nfratami
offline
offline
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.
They just weren't thinking about it?
Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
people tell secrets even when self preservation should be at its highest (homicide etc)
to think that this wouldn't get out had there not been orders for it not to get out is silly
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.
They just weren't thinking about it?
Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
people tell secrets even when self preservation should be at its highest (homicide etc)
to think that this wouldn't get out had there not been orders for it not to get out is silly
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.
They just weren't thinking about it?
keeping it a secret for so long requires conscious effort. i'm not buying the "in a fit of absence of mind" argument, either.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
okay, so this steers right back into my argument that there isn't a tradition of full disclosure from the admins to the userbase. and this would normally be fine, until our competitors are suddenly on the other side of that disclosure and are now privy to insider information.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.
They just weren't thinking about it?
keeping it a secret for so long requires conscious effort. i'm not buying the "in a fit of absence of mind" argument, either.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
okay, so this steers right back into my argument that there isn't a tradition of full disclosure from the admins to the userbase. and this would normally be fine, until our competitors are suddenly on the other side of that disclosure and are now privy to insider information.
nfratami
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by quzur
Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
I dress Bort, then he dresses Voltron, then Volt dresses me...that is unless the music stops early.
more pro modage
Originally posted by quzur
Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
I dress Bort, then he dresses Voltron, then Volt dresses me...that is unless the music stops early.
more pro modage
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
I've got a guy with 15 head fake....if testing showed that it wasn't working as intended....other then me wasting my flex (money) pumping it....what would be done? And what would that change do to defenders who then cry that I'm deeking them out of their pants?
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
I've got a guy with 15 head fake....if testing showed that it wasn't working as intended....other then me wasting my flex (money) pumping it....what would be done? And what would that change do to defenders who then cry that I'm deeking them out of their pants?
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, at this point i guess these are my views...
► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.
► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.
► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.
solving this is a different freight train of worms.
As a hand picked and selected bunch, it can be supposed that they felt it best not to mention it in case it caused fall-out between themselves and other people who feel that they should be testers. The low number of people initially invited would reinforce the idea of it being a closet clique.
The fact it expanded to 30+ suggests a general broadening of the testing scope and requirements.
but many of the testers are mods... who are easily identifiable already. i'm not buying the "jealousy argument".
And yet we don't know who the testers are, so "many" might be 5 or 6, plus 3 or 4 Admins and 20 other users selected from around GLB.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Koncorde
Ethical considerations I don't think enter into it.
I presume of course that they aren't cloning embryo's or conducting abortions.
what?!?
I think you'll find it's "wat". But good first try.
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, at this point i guess these are my views...
► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.
► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.
► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.
solving this is a different freight train of worms.
As a hand picked and selected bunch, it can be supposed that they felt it best not to mention it in case it caused fall-out between themselves and other people who feel that they should be testers. The low number of people initially invited would reinforce the idea of it being a closet clique.
The fact it expanded to 30+ suggests a general broadening of the testing scope and requirements.
but many of the testers are mods... who are easily identifiable already. i'm not buying the "jealousy argument".
And yet we don't know who the testers are, so "many" might be 5 or 6, plus 3 or 4 Admins and 20 other users selected from around GLB.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Koncorde
Ethical considerations I don't think enter into it.
I presume of course that they aren't cloning embryo's or conducting abortions.
what?!?
I think you'll find it's "wat". But good first try.
Procrustes
offline
offline
i feel the need to quote this again. i don't know whether to laugh or cry.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Koncorde
Ethical considerations I don't think enter into it.
I presume of course that they aren't cloning embryo's or conducting abortions.
what?!?
i laughed.
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Koncorde
Ethical considerations I don't think enter into it.
I presume of course that they aren't cloning embryo's or conducting abortions.
what?!?
i laughed.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by quzur
Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
I dress Bort, then he dresses Voltron, then Volt dresses me...that is unless the music stops early.
...does DD just watch?
Originally posted by quzur
Well a good poitn was just made. what vanilla thunder is doing is trolling. He is no letting people talk about the issue. He is a big part of the problem. It goes like this: Bort-voltron-vanilla. All of them are embarrassing. I don't know how they can dress themselves in the morning. So vanilla thunder you gonna let us talk about the issue now or not?
I dress Bort, then he dresses Voltron, then Volt dresses me...that is unless the music stops early.
...does DD just watch?
Weather
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
Getting two different opinions from you and Darkus.
Darkus said that you guys just tested Team A vs. Team B 20 times or whatever.
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
Getting two different opinions from you and Darkus.
Darkus said that you guys just tested Team A vs. Team B 20 times or whatever.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.
They just weren't thinking about it?
Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
people tell secrets even when self preservation should be at its highest (homicide etc)
to think that this wouldn't get out had there not been orders for it not to get out is silly
Bort told the secret.
Did he commit the murder too?
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.
They just weren't thinking about it?
Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
people tell secrets even when self preservation should be at its highest (homicide etc)
to think that this wouldn't get out had there not been orders for it not to get out is silly
Bort told the secret.
Did he commit the murder too?
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
No, but enough to say "Oh wow, this skill is more effective when this stat it high, and that REALLY makes a big difference" is it not?
Yeah because without testing I would have no idea if 0 in a SA was better or worse than 10 in a SA.
Try using common sense please. The test conditions would not for example tell me that the SP invested in moving the SA were any more or less effective than if they were invested anywhere else, nor will it tell me if it consistently over poweres 'Build type X' etc.
I am posting to help spread some understanding, and ease concerns, as no one else really seemed to want to be the one to take all the stick.
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...
so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)
Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
No, but enough to say "Oh wow, this skill is more effective when this stat it high, and that REALLY makes a big difference" is it not?
Yeah because without testing I would have no idea if 0 in a SA was better or worse than 10 in a SA.
Try using common sense please. The test conditions would not for example tell me that the SP invested in moving the SA were any more or less effective than if they were invested anywhere else, nor will it tell me if it consistently over poweres 'Build type X' etc.
I am posting to help spread some understanding, and ease concerns, as no one else really seemed to want to be the one to take all the stick.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
And yet we don't know who the testers are, so "many" might be 5 or 6, plus 3 or 4 Admins and 20 other users selected from around GLB.
actually we do know the numbers. i think it was tpat that told us.
Originally posted by Koncorde
I think you'll find it's "wat". But good first try.
you'll find i don't speak /b/ for a reason.
And yet we don't know who the testers are, so "many" might be 5 or 6, plus 3 or 4 Admins and 20 other users selected from around GLB.
actually we do know the numbers. i think it was tpat that told us.
Originally posted by Koncorde
I think you'll find it's "wat". But good first try.
you'll find i don't speak /b/ for a reason.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























