User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by nfratami




Originally posted by wombat killer





Question for testers. When you agreed to be a tester did you know if it would be made public that you were a tester?


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder






You're actually insane.




What you did there:
[ ]I don't see it
[x]I see it


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




You're actually a Terrible Mod.


Do you see what I did there:
[ ]I don't see it
[x]I see it



Clever mis-use of quotes sir.


Clever
mis-use of mod status, sir

This word isn't necessary
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, at this point i guess these are my views...

► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.

► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.

► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.

solving this is a different freight train of worms.


As a hand picked and selected bunch, it can be supposed that they felt it best not to mention it in case it caused fall-out between themselves and other people who feel that they should be testers. The low number of people initially invited would reinforce the idea of it being a closet clique.

The fact it expanded to 30+ suggests a general broadening of the testing scope and requirements.

Ethical considerations I don't think enter into it.

I presume of course that they aren't cloning embryo's or conducting abortions.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by GG

Exactly. They can dance and spindoctor it how they want. The fact is, it was created and fostered in secrecy and to deceive the customer base. Yet again another scandal of this kind (cheating, exploitation, abusing the customer base).

That's giving entirely too much credit.

Any sins committed in this endeavor were ones of omission, no commission.


Clearly I am.

Next step in plan of action: Give everyone 12 flex so they forget this happened, leave for 3 weeks.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Holy balls, did I not quote the correct post. One moment:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Where's a mod when we need one?

Vanilla Thunder continues to troll, bait and name call.

Er, wait...never mind.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
lol 12 flex....
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by GG
Exactly. They can dance and spindoctor it how they want. The fact is, it was created and fostered in secrecy and to deceive the customer base. Yet again another scandal of this kind (cheating, exploitation, abusing the customer base).

That's giving entirely too much credit.
Any sins committed in this endeavor were ones of omission, no commission.


i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.

can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Apparently, it isn't unusual for Bort to not post or communicate with anyone affiliated with GLB for upwards of 2 weeks and, when he doesn't, the rest of the staff is incompetent.

You might be on to something.


Clearly I am.

Etc. etc.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Apparently, it isn't unusual for Bort to not post or communicate with anyone affiliated with GLB for upwards of 2 weeks and, when he doesn't, the rest of the staff is incompetent.

You might be on to something.


Absence of Bort is not required for incompetency.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Hey Mike...

so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?


Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)

Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Apparently, it isn't unusual for Bort to not post or communicate with anyone affiliated with GLB for upwards of 2 weeks and, when he doesn't, the rest of the staff is incompetent.

You might be on to something.


Absence of Bort is not required for incompetency.


Maybe not. Certainly seems to guarantee it.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Hey Mike...

so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2....;15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?


Basically something like 0 a few times, 1 a few times, then 15 a few times. (Maybe 10 as well to see if the Sim can handle +15 in a SA correctly.)

Enough to know the difference, and confirm its working as intended, not enough to break it down entirely and let a Tester say "Ahh each level makes it X% more effective" for example.


No, but enough to say "Oh wow, this skill is more effective when this stat it high, and that REALLY makes a big difference" is it not?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, at this point i guess these are my views...
► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.
► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.
► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.
solving this is a different freight train of worms.

As a hand picked and selected bunch, it can be supposed that they felt it best not to mention it in case it caused fall-out between themselves and other people who feel that they should be testers. The low number of people initially invited would reinforce the idea of it being a closet clique.
The fact it expanded to 30+ suggests a general broadening of the testing scope and requirements.


but many of the testers are mods... who are easily identifiable already. i'm not buying the "jealousy argument".

Originally posted by Koncorde
Ethical considerations I don't think enter into it.
I presume of course that they aren't cloning embryo's or conducting abortions.


what?!?
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i don't see too many ways to bridge the gap to "it was a secret in practice" without assuming that the administration knew there some ethical issues.

They just weren't thinking about it?

Originally posted by Catullus 16
can you think of any other reason why 30+ people kept it a secret for two weeks?

Self-preservation? If an admin approaches a user and asks them to test something, most would feel secrecy is an implicit part of the agreement, unless explicitly told otherwise, I'd imagine.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
The other point here is, this whole "but it's hard to keep things a secret, people can abuse their power, policing them is hard" etc is all further proof why you have transparent open test servers to all the customer base. It's quite moronic to say....."we created a test server, for the greater good of GLB and YOU, but it needs to be kept secret, and yet because we cant trust people to keep things secret is a reason why it had to be kept secret".


Actualy, I thought the guys selected were to be used as a "Control Group" for testing bugs.

Nothing yet demonstrated suggests secrecy or otherwise, barring the initial response to a blasé mentioning of the "secret" testing going on by Bort himself.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.