Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, at this point i guess these are my views...
► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.
► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.
► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.
solving this is a different freight train of worms.
Exactly. They can dance and spindoctor it how they want. The fact is, it was created and fostered in secrecy and to deceive the customer base. Yet again another scandal of this kind (cheating, exploitation, abusing the customer base).
well, at this point i guess these are my views...
► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.
► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.
► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.
solving this is a different freight train of worms.
Exactly. They can dance and spindoctor it how they want. The fact is, it was created and fostered in secrecy and to deceive the customer base. Yet again another scandal of this kind (cheating, exploitation, abusing the customer base).




....buddy 5 day isn't really helping with his answers IMO....
























