User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WolfbattXIX
I never said I wanted to compete against teams my age.


 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WolfbattXIX
I never said I wanted to compete against teams my age.


interesting....
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Some people might question those users who are ragequittign over this


living in a utopia much?
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WolfbattXIX
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC

You never wanted to compete with players your own age before, why would you want to start now?


I never said I wanted to compete against teams my age.


of course not, then you wouldn't have a built in advantage
 
RufusBrutal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
Originally posted by foofighter24

It is funny that boosters build their dots solely for the end game, and expect to beat teams that are designed to win earlier without good gameplanning. lolboosters



Obviously you do not have kids, or if you do they do not play organized sports. My son practices and plays to be the best he can be in the long run. In no way does this mean, that at 8 years old he should play 16 year olds.


With your type of reasoning he won't amount to anything. By your logic if he has the most expensive equipment on the team he should be the best, no questions asked. Who cares about practice and training, he's spent the most money so it's his given right to be the best on the squad.
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Here are the level and equipment differences at the start of each season:

40 age: 4 + 0 eq st
80 age: 6 + 0 eq set
120 age: 11 + 2 eq set
160 age: 13 + 1 eq set
200 age: 16 + 2 eq set
240 age: 19 + 3 eq set
280 age: 22 + 2 eq set

Tack on the bonus from CE that most non-boosters don't have and you'll have 22*5=110 more SP and 6+2*4=14 more EQ points plus the additional bonus from the CE tree and AEQ. This is going to make non-boosters unviable past a couple of seasons unless bort is able to separate them into their own leagues.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RufusBrutal
With your type of reasoning he won't amount to anything. By your logic if he has the most expensive equipment on the team he should be the best, no questions asked. Who cares about practice and training, he's spent the most money so it's his given right to be the best on the squad.


Spending money/Boosting in this game = Hard work and practice irl.

fwiw they are ranked top 10 in Northern California.

Originally posted by RufusBrutal
With your type of reasoning he won't amount to anything. By your logic if he has the most expensive equipment on the team he has the opportunity to be the best, no questions asked. He's spent the most time practicing, and training so it's his teams given right to be the best in the league.


U.S. Club soccer = Best teams = Boosters with great gameplanning

CYSA = Very Good Teams = Mix of boosters with decent gameplanning

AYSO = Let's go out and have fun teams = Non-boosters.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 27, 2010 09:19:49
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 27, 2010 09:19:37
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC


U.S. Club soccer = Best teams = Boosters with great gameplanning = Elite leagues

CYSA = Very Good Teams = Mix of boosters with decent gameplanning = Competitive leagues

AYSO = Let's go out and have fun teams = Non-boosters = Regular leagues


Added a little perspective for you. Looks right on to me.
 
RufusBrutal
offline
Link
 
Seems like we have a lot of Ayn Rand followers in this thread. Not good.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RufusBrutal
Seems like we have a lot of Ayn Rand followers in this thread. Not good.


wat? I've read some of her stuff...not sure how it applies to this thread though...
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Teams promoting from level 4 leagues to level 18 leagues has been an issue for a while. I personally did this last season and there were at least two teams in our league that were loaded with level 22 players before the preseason. They boosted and started out at level 25. So there was a good number of level 14 teams and level 18 teams in the level 18 league with 2 teams starting out at level 25. This is the mess that frustrated a lot of young owners. It was GLB as usual to me since the last time my team went from level 13 BBB to uncapped A.

This is the problem that the new change is addressing. While I agree with the sentiment I disagree with the execution of the solution. The problem with scripting this solution is that the metrics are too rigid to live with. Teams will not have the option to sign older low leveled players to fill their roster. Most uncapped teams that can sign these players probably will not want them. I mean what uncapped team is going to want a 300 day old level 26 player?

These old non or semi-boosters will have to join CPU teams. They will most likely get ran off by owners buying up all the CPU teams and clearing out the rosters. So while there are actually more teams than players there will be a group of players that simply cannot get signed and a group of teams that would like to sign them players but simply can't because of age restrictions.

If anybody has ever dealt with the types of players I speak of. They will already know that these guys log in once a week or worse. They are not ideal for most teams but serve their purpose. I hate to see this group of players pushed out of the game.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
I don't really care about perpetual non-boosters, but I'm very concerned about how this change can happen and still create a positive experience for new players.

Learning a little about the game in D-league is interesting, but you don't really get hooked until you experience success and get drawn into the community. Success in D-leagues is hit or miss. There is no community there, since the best communities reside in team and league forums. And when the player emerges for their second season, they will be the least desirable dots in the game. To have any hope of finding a decent community atmosphere, they will have to retire and rebuild. Given the experience they've had so far, how willing will they be to do that?

I'm not one of those cynics that thinks Bort just did this to ride out the flex as GLB dies. There are too many new changes and too much new development going on to believe that. But I can see how people think it, because this does look like a GLB killer.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
lol...so earlier in this thread you claimed it would be tough for owners to recruit. Now you're saying it will be tough for players to get recruited.

Seems to me both problems can not exist together....
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
lol...so earlier in this thread you claimed it would be tough for owners to recruit. Now you're saying it will be tough for players to get recruited.

Seems to me both problems can not exist together....


A level 26 team cannot sign a 300 day old level 26 player. So it is tough for that team to recruit because a good portion of the FA pool is made up of these types of players. So that is how it will make recruiting harder.

On the flip side these older players that are low leveled will not get signed by the teams that want or need them most and will be forced to sign with teams that don't want or need them. So this will make it hard on them to find teams.

I don't think I am making this hard to grasp.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
But a day 300 team can sign that level 26 player.

You'll be signing players the AGE of your team...not the level now.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.