User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Catullus 16

however, this still leaves wide open the possibility that everyone knew from the start that the situation was ethically shaky.


We've established that not everyone was invited initially.

So everyone from the start is wrong. We've also established from Candless that there is no mention of secrecy on the forum, or in his PM from Bort.


This the whole 30 people testing every hour for 2 weeks, is a load of crap.
30 people with access, most only recently added, some still to this day not logged in once and it also includes Designers, Admins.

Its not like 30 'normal' GLBers were keeping a secret, my best guess, 5 for the first week, 10 for the second.

I wasnt ever told that the exsistence of the Test Server should be a secret.

But what do you think would have happened if I was the one who ran screaming into the forums shouting 'look at me. look at me, I'm Tester!"

It was obvious that the announcement should come from an official source, and if you take a second to think, you know that every single None Admin would have thought exactly the same thing in that situation.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles

There was never a gag order, just a misunderstanding within the limited community by some.


okay, but what was the understanding? it seems like it was at least suggested that the information wasn't supposed to be public knowledge...


I know TWO testers who thought it was be kept quite. I do not know why nor did I ask, but I repeat there is nothing in the PM I received from Bort that gives any appearance of what that those testers believed. It was a simple misunderstanding.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by wombat killer

Question for testers. When you agreed to be a tester did you know if it would be made public that you were a tester?


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


You're actually insane.




What you did there:
[ ]I don't see it
[x]I see it
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quzur
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Originally posted by quzur


What Bort said is not positive. It is actually idiotic.


Take your LVL 30 QB and GTFO then....don't call Bort an idiot when you're playing "his" game for free...



He is an idiot. If he wasn't this wouldn't have happened. You are an idiot for trying to turn this around and make it about my player. Why are you saying I've played his game for free? I have paid money. You are completely lost.


Seriously though, stop calling him an idiot.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by Jacob McCandles



Originally posted by Koncorde




Originally posted by Catullus 16


Sometimes the truth is harder to believe than a lie.


however, this still leaves wide open the possibility that everyone knew from the start that the situation was ethically shaky.


We've established that not everyone was invited initially.

So everyone from the start is wrong. We've also established from Candless that there is no mention of secrecy on the forum, or in his PM from Bort.


For the record, I was invited:

Date Sent:
Feb 10, 2009 15:22:47


gag order on testers lifted i assume?


There was never a gag order, just a misunderstanding within the limited community by some.


haha i like when you talk you make it seem more and more unbelievable

they need you give your gag order back


 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Originally posted by wombat killer

Question for testers. When you agreed to be a tester did you know if it would be made public that you were a tester?


*asks recreational single player user*


Correct.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
well, at this point i guess these are my views...

► since 30+ people were able to keep the test server a secret (in practice) for two weeks, it seems very likely that they were at least given the understanding that their testing was not supposed to be public knowledge.

► given the above, it seems likely that the admins were fully aware of some ethical gray areas with the test server.

► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.

solving this is a different freight train of worms.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by nfratami

Originally posted by wombat killer


Question for testers. When you agreed to be a tester did you know if it would be made public that you were a tester?


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



You're actually insane.




What you did there:
[ ]I don't see it
[x]I see it


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

You're actually a Terrible Mod.


Do you see what I did there:
[ ]I don't see it
[ ]I see it

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Bort clearly knew he was creating a test server.


It's assumed that he, at some point, started to do something and it became a test server that was possibly adapted at a later date for further usage.

Originally posted by GG
created it


Presumably.

Originally posted by GG
and didnt inform the GLB community in any announcement or changelog


The test server was public knowledge. The presence of testers on it wasn't announced, but then it hadn't reached day 0 and/or all the testers had not been invited.

Originally posted by GG
or publicly ask people to request invitation as a tester.


Not that we can see.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Hey Mike...

so the testing for head fake would be done at like 0,1,2--->15 running the same play with the same people over and over? Or the same settings multiple times then averaged?
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by wombat killer



Question for testers. When you agreed to be a tester did you know if it would be made public that you were a tester?


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




You're actually insane.




What you did there:
[ ]I don't see it
[x]I see it


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


You're actually a Terrible Mod.


Do you see what I did there:

[ ]I don't see it
[ ]I see it
[x] you did it wrong


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles

There was never a gag order, just a misunderstanding within the limited community by some.


Such as, presumably, some of the testers still don't want to be outted for fear of recrimination?


This to a true statement based on what other testers have gone though on this forum. I would also add that Bort's PM also does not SAY everyone will know. So perhaps that might have impacted their decision to become a tester based on various reasoning.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

► inviting only honest testers and even policing them is soft justification at best. the fact remains that there are deep ethical concerns with how the testing was accomplished.


my question is how is honesty measured?

never been forum banned = honest?

being a mod = honest?

were lie detector tests given?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Jacob McCandles
There was never a gag order, just a misunderstanding within the limited community by some.

okay, but what was the understanding? it seems like it was at least suggested that the information wasn't supposed to be public knowledge...

I know TWO testers who thought it was be kept quite. I do not know why nor did I ask, but I repeat there is nothing in the PM I received from Bort that gives any appearance of what that those testers believed. It was a simple misunderstanding.


okay, but it's still curious that out of all the possible misunderstandings, that secrecy was the one they ended up with.

i'm not saying there's anything malicious/intentional there... it's just that it casts doubt on how honest the administration has been with the userbase in general.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Question for testers. When you agreed to be a tester did you know if it would be made public that you were a tester?


No
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.