User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by PP

Originally posted by Bort




So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


I cry BS again....there have been numerous, awesome suggestions on how things can be tested. You just choose to ignore them and backdoor your paying customers. I'll grant you that you most likely weren't purposefully trying to screw them, but you just did, anyway you look at it.



well in borts defense, this thread was already at like page 112 before he even saw it lol, I doubt he had time to read all 1800+ posts to get the suggestions


I meant in the suggestions forum
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by The Duff Man


Originally posted by tpaterniti





If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.


You have just said you do the very thing that everyone is afraid that testers are doing! Unless this info is available on a public forum, you have just given someone an unfair advantage over everyone else.



Time to panic?


Yikes. This is exactly what most are bitching about and tp just verified it after bort assured us this wouldn't happen.


 
Club America
offline
Link
 
I feel like i payed for pron and then discovered its the same broad photoshopped with red, blond and brunette hair

this is pretty fuckedup.

really.

I feel stupid for paying for this game.

 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by atingwald

Originally posted by Catullus 16


Originally posted by atingwald



Originally posted by Bort



So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?

you don't have a computer program that can run sims for you???


he would still have to watch the sims...


a computer program would be able to point out the anomalies... and then he could address them



easier said than done


maybe, but it would not compromise the integrity of the game like humans do...
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Catullus 16

i'm wondering if we're to the point of reaching a consensus on solutions. so far i've seen...
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers

any others? that's not that many...


Yes, that's all I really want to find.


Any solution that stops short of full disclosure stops short of retaining my business tbh. I'm sure you won't miss me but I figure you deserve the frank and direct feedback anyway.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Hambos
The idea of the testers sharing info will not solve the problem because nobody trusts the testers.

The bottom line is nobody should be testing AND playing. If GLB can't afford to hire testers then maybe some of the testers will volunteer to quit playing an just test. I mean, Bort said most of them aren't that interested in playing anymore and just want to make the game better...


I like this.. Give up owning players, teams, GM status for 40 days (1 season) to be a tester and then come back..

Works for me..
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Club America
1. you cannot allow mods with these alliances to play the game with the paying public

2. you cannot allow testors to play with the paying public.

3. you need to hire a fucking pr guy.

Mods cannot play this game.

paying public must be separated from any insiders testing with you.

simple.

ffs


Be realistic. Unless he pays people good money, if they aren't interested in the game they won't Mod or test or whatever.

The "tester's blog" seems like a workable compromise. And if you don't trust TPat alone to write it, let Bort nominate some non-testers who can have read only access to builds and games, elect some percentage of those he nominates, and let them add to it as well (maybe he nominates 12, and the people elect 3 they trust, or something like that).
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


Bort, you have a 130 page thread that was started 2 hours ago filled with complaints. Can the testers being publicly known and their builds remaining open really be that much more trouble?

You have been trying to make us feel better by saying the testers can't really and kinda wont abuse the system and Thorn has told us there have been plenty of "safeguards" in place but the reason you don't want to open it up to the public is because it is too easy to abuse.

I think there need to be several rules in place.
1) Testers can not own teams.
2) Testers must have player builds open.
3) Testers can not give build advice publicly or privately.
4) Each tester must be checked for multi's.


I think out of the thousands of players on this game you can find a few dozen that not only would volunteer under these circumstances but they would be well known trustworthy agents. I know a couple off hand that would drop what they are doing to help out.

I think this would solve all your problems both on the trust end with your customers, the testers and be financially prudent.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Yes, that's all I really want to find.


i'll try to keep tracking them... here's all i've got so far:

potential solutions
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers
- hire paid testers (that aren't also players)
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 


Originally posted by tpaterniti

If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.




yes - THIS IS EXACTLY THE PROBLEM.

Bort - do you consider this an information leak that is inappropriate???


because if tpat is doing it...then i'd bet my left nut all testers are
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man


Originally posted by tpaterniti


If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.


You have just said you do the very thing that everyone is afraid that testers are doing! Unless this info is available on a public forum, you have just given someone an unfair advantage over everyone else.




 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Catullus 16

i'm wondering if we're to the point of reaching a consensus on solutions. so far i've seen...
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- hide specific builds from testers

any others? that's not that many...


Yes, that's all I really want to find.


The big one that everyone has been asking for is a professional customer service person.... Most mods and even Thorn have fueled this fire instead of putting it out... you need someone whos responsibility it is to make customers happy not piss them off...
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hambos
The idea of the testers sharing info will not solve the problem because nobody trusts the testers.

The bottom line is nobody should be testing AND playing. If GLB can't afford to hire testers then maybe some of the testers will volunteer to quit playing an just test. I mean, Bort said most of them aren't that interested in playing anymore and just want to make the game better...


I'd quit playing in a heartbeat to test...hell, the only reason I even play the game is to test. Look at the majority of my builds.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Any solution that stops short of full disclosure stops short of retaining my business tbh. I'm sure you won't miss me but I figure you deserve the frank and direct feedback anyway.


What, in your opinion is full disclosure?
 
Link
 
Those solutions seem very good. I know that they will never implement it thoguh. They are dictators and don't care about what we think. The only reason they are making us talk abotu this in one thread is so that they can control us.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.