User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Season 4 is over! What's in store for season 5 and beyond?
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jesse.chasman
So, let's recap:

Are injuries going to happen this year or not?

Originally posted by The first post, for god's sake
- Figure out the best method to do injuries and implement it for season 6.


Originally posted by jesse.chasman
What has been changed to the vision aspects for offensive players (esp RBs)?

Any changes to the AI on OFF/DEF?


Originally posted by Again, the first post
- At the end of this season, I started working some more on the elusive juking problems. Getting closer to a good solution, I think. I'm combining some of the ideas that have been presented here to help smooth out the movement.

- Some tweaks to fake liklihood on certain things, percentages here and there, some bug fixes, etc. I basically made a bunch of random minor fixes to address some of the stuff that's been posted.


Originally posted by jesse.chasman
Will we be able to design special plays?

Have more plays been added?

Originally posted by More first post goodness

- I want to add some more offensive plays to the playbook. I would like to solicit the community to submit or come up with some that we can put in. This came up before, but it didn't get very far. Maybe I could come up with a play designer... Once we get more plays put in, we can expand the offense AI options.


Originally posted by jesse.chasman
When we talk about needing more depth on teams (bc of energy/injuries), what should we be doing right now to address this?

....you seriously have to ask what to do in regards to needing more depth? Honestly? If you need more depth....ADD MORE DEPTH.
 
Link
 
i think its too early to say if the new training will be good or bad so im keeping an open mind

the energy being at a 100 percent every game is totally fake though. in real life players are often not at a 100 percent when playing. for many many reasons. the game isnt ready to take into account all of those reasons, and gives training/practice all the credit for lack or enough energy, but it was still realistic in the fact that not all players were 100 percent

i think everyone being at a 100 kind of sucks
Last edited Sep 17, 2008 03:54:07
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Some things for sure:

The new training gives us LESS choices, LESS to do and less immediate influence on the player. Training gets LESS short term value, but more long term meaning - for it takes longer to see results.

Intense training is restricted to very few combinations - this making it less useful for a lot of players. If you are one of those players - your choices were restricted from 3 (relaxed, normal, intense) to 1 (normal). Since normal gets you less "bang for the buck", you're screwed eiter way: get less for your cash or train something you don't want.

Since you only see any training having an effect as you train up the whole point, for players training intense it might take 1/4 of the season (5x intense = 20 training points = 10 days) to even get +1 added here and there. You might ask yourself why you need to keep on logging in every day in order to train every second or third day.

The days of split training (i.e. 3x jumping, 1x strength) are gone. No use letting you training rest at 0.85 - you GOT TO train up the whole point to add it to your player. That sure gets frustrating if you "overtrain" quite a bit every time: if you end up close to the whole point, you sure train another time - and end up like 20-30% into another point. So if you don't want to "waste" that, you got to keep on training that attribute - and might get stuck training the same attribute all season while you originally planned to train 3 attributes up.

The importance of depth is reduced. You can waste just one guy to get him max XP. If he ends up at 40 energy - that has no long term effect anymore. As the penalty for playing a tired player is only 50% max, most teams do better running a small roster and leveling the guys perfectly. That might change as the injuries come in, but that's not before season 6.

So the new training might be different and even "better" in some terms...

...but it sure misses the points Bort wanted it to adress!
 
telencephalon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jesse.chasman

So, let's recap:

Are injuries going to happen this year or not?

Originally posted by The first post, for god's sake

- Figure out the best method to do injuries and implement it for season 6.


Originally posted by jesse.chasman

What has been changed to the vision aspects for offensive players (esp RBs)?

Any changes to the AI on OFF/DEF?


Originally posted by Again, the first post

- At the end of this season, I started working some more on the elusive juking problems. Getting closer to a good solution, I think. I'm combining some of the ideas that have been presented here to help smooth out the movement.

- Some tweaks to fake liklihood on certain things, percentages here and there, some bug fixes, etc. I basically made a bunch of random minor fixes to address some of the stuff that's been posted.


Originally posted by jesse.chasman

Will we be able to design special plays?

Have more plays been added?

Originally posted by More first post goodness


- I want to add some more offensive plays to the playbook. I would like to solicit the community to submit or come up with some that we can put in. This came up before, but it didn't get very far. Maybe I could come up with a play designer... Once we get more plays put in, we can expand the offense AI options.


Originally posted by jesse.chasman

When we talk about needing more depth on teams (bc of energy/injuries), what should we be doing right now to address this?

....you seriously have to ask what to do in regards to needing more depth? Honestly? If you need more depth....ADD MORE DEPTH.


Other than, perhaps, the injury issue, you will notice that there are a lot of "I want to..." and "getting closer" statements by Bort here. No real answers here.

And, if you'd like to contribute something productive to this discussion, why don't you suggest what good depth would be. I have depth. Everyone has depth. But, no one has the first clue how the new stamina changes will impact things and for what levels. How many DTs should be in the rotation given the new stamina changes? Four? Six? Twenty? Again, this has not been addressed, even though you think all your answers have been given in Bort's first post here.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
If he didn't tell you exact values or timelines or depth levels, he did so for a reason, and the reason wasn't "In hopes jesse.chasman will ask about them".

Figure it out yourself, this is GLB, not "Hand everybody the exact number of everything they need".
 
austin8214
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Some things for sure:

The new training gives us LESS choices, LESS to do and less immediate influence on the player. Training gets LESS short term value, but more long term meaning - for it takes longer to see results.

Intense training is restricted to very few combinations - this making it less useful for a lot of players. If you are one of those players - your choices were restricted from 3 (relaxed, normal, intense) to 1 (normal). Since normal gets you less "bang for the buck", you're screwed eiter way: get less for your cash or train something you don't want.

Since you only see any training having an effect as you train up the whole point, for players training intense it might take 1/4 of the season (5x intense = 20 training points = 10 days) to even get +1 added here and there. You might ask yourself why you need to keep on logging in every day in order to train every second or third day.

The days of split training (i.e. 3x jumping, 1x strength) are gone. No use letting you training rest at 0.85 - you GOT TO train up the whole point to add it to your player. That sure gets frustrating if you "overtrain" quite a bit every time: if you end up close to the whole point, you sure train another time - and end up like 20-30% into another point. So if you don't want to "waste" that, you got to keep on training that attribute - and might get stuck training the same attribute all season while you originally planned to train 3 attributes up.

The importance of depth is reduced. You can waste just one guy to get him max XP. If he ends up at 40 energy - that has no long term effect anymore. As the penalty for playing a tired player is only 50% max, most teams do better running a small roster and leveling the guys perfectly. That might change as the injuries come in, but that's not before season 6.

So the new training might be different and even "better" in some terms...

...but it sure misses the points Bort wanted it to adress!


+1 to this post I am a bit disappointed with the new training system it seems somewhat limited when it comes to the intense training. It would be a lot nicer if you were able to train two attributes of your choice rather than one you want to train and another you are forced to train. Is there any reason we cannot have two drop down menus when we select intense training?
 
Minaras
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by austin8214
Originally posted by RAPB

Some things for sure:

The new training gives us LESS choices, LESS to do and less immediate influence on the player. Training gets LESS short term value, but more long term meaning - for it takes longer to see results.

Intense training is restricted to very few combinations - this making it less useful for a lot of players. If you are one of those players - your choices were restricted from 3 (relaxed, normal, intense) to 1 (normal). Since normal gets you less "bang for the buck", you're screwed eiter way: get less for your cash or train something you don't want.

Since you only see any training having an effect as you train up the whole point, for players training intense it might take 1/4 of the season (5x intense = 20 training points = 10 days) to even get +1 added here and there. You might ask yourself why you need to keep on logging in every day in order to train every second or third day.

The days of split training (i.e. 3x jumping, 1x strength) are gone. No use letting you training rest at 0.85 - you GOT TO train up the whole point to add it to your player. That sure gets frustrating if you "overtrain" quite a bit every time: if you end up close to the whole point, you sure train another time - and end up like 20-30% into another point. So if you don't want to "waste" that, you got to keep on training that attribute - and might get stuck training the same attribute all season while you originally planned to train 3 attributes up.

The importance of depth is reduced. You can waste just one guy to get him max XP. If he ends up at 40 energy - that has no long term effect anymore. As the penalty for playing a tired player is only 50% max, most teams do better running a small roster and leveling the guys perfectly. That might change as the injuries come in, but that's not before season 6.

So the new training might be different and even "better" in some terms...

...but it sure misses the points Bort wanted it to adress!


+1 to this post I am a bit disappointed with the new training system it seems somewhat limited when it comes to the intense training. It would be a lot nicer if you were able to train two attributes of your choice rather than one you want to train and another you are forced to train. Is there any reason we cannot have two drop down menus when we select intense training?


Probably to get more balanced builds, instead of the "whoring 1 or 2 stats and complain when it doesnt work like in season 2" approach. Not saying you or anyone else specific is doing it like that, but might be the thought behind it.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Minaras
Originally posted by austin8214

Originally posted by RAPB


Some things for sure:

The new training gives us LESS choices, LESS to do and less immediate influence on the player. Training gets LESS short term value, but more long term meaning - for it takes longer to see results.

Intense training is restricted to very few combinations - this making it less useful for a lot of players. If you are one of those players - your choices were restricted from 3 (relaxed, normal, intense) to 1 (normal). Since normal gets you less "bang for the buck", you're screwed eiter way: get less for your cash or train something you don't want.

Since you only see any training having an effect as you train up the whole point, for players training intense it might take 1/4 of the season (5x intense = 20 training points = 10 days) to even get +1 added here and there. You might ask yourself why you need to keep on logging in every day in order to train every second or third day.

The days of split training (i.e. 3x jumping, 1x strength) are gone. No use letting you training rest at 0.85 - you GOT TO train up the whole point to add it to your player. That sure gets frustrating if you "overtrain" quite a bit every time: if you end up close to the whole point, you sure train another time - and end up like 20-30% into another point. So if you don't want to "waste" that, you got to keep on training that attribute - and might get stuck training the same attribute all season while you originally planned to train 3 attributes up.

The importance of depth is reduced. You can waste just one guy to get him max XP. If he ends up at 40 energy - that has no long term effect anymore. As the penalty for playing a tired player is only 50% max, most teams do better running a small roster and leveling the guys perfectly. That might change as the injuries come in, but that's not before season 6.

So the new training might be different and even "better" in some terms...

...but it sure misses the points Bort wanted it to adress!


+1 to this post I am a bit disappointed with the new training system it seems somewhat limited when it comes to the intense training. It would be a lot nicer if you were able to train two attributes of your choice rather than one you want to train and another you are forced to train. Is there any reason we cannot have two drop down menus when we select intense training?


Probably to get more balanced builds, instead of the "whoring 1 or 2 stats and complain when it doesnt work like in season 2" approach. Not saying you or anyone else specific is doing it like that, but might be the thought behind it.


In other words everyones builds will be exactly the same... It's going to be boring in GLB if that becomes the case.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Minaras
...

Probably to get more balanced builds, instead of the "whoring 1 or 2 stats and complain when it doesnt work like in season 2" approach. Not saying you or anyone else specific is doing it like that, but might be the thought behind it.


Think first!

If there are limited combinations of what you are allowed to train intense... and if there is an advantage of training intense... what would people most likely do?

YES!

People will leave one of those combinations to train on it all the time. They will build players according to the situation and never spend a skill point into the combination they are forced to train.

They really should remove that

"Train your player from the ground up to be the type of player you want"

into

"Train your player from the ground up in certain preferred combinations to be the type of player we suggest."

At least, that'll be honest!

 
austin8214
offline
Link
 
All I am getting at is if I want to train confidence and stamina on my QB I should be able to do so. The choices are far too limited when training on intense in my opinion. By limiting the choices Bort is steering builds into the direction he prefers.
 
telencephalon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
If he didn't tell you exact values or timelines or depth levels, he did so for a reason, and the reason wasn't "In hopes jesse.chasman will ask about them".

Figure it out yourself, this is GLB, not "Hand everybody the exact number of everything they need".


Right. Thanks for the contribution, even though you are not really getting what it is so many of us are looking for.

Be that as it may, I don't think it's much to ask that there is equal time spent communicating on-the-field changes as there has been this whole Dungeons & Dragons piece, which has been spelled out in excruciating detail.


Last edited Sep 17, 2008 08:59:02
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Strength: Jumping, Blocking, Throwing
Speed : Agility, Tackling, Stamina
Agility : Speed, Blocking, Confidence
Jumping : Strength, Tackling, Vision
Stamina : Speed, Carrying, Confidence
Vision : Jumping, Throwing, Kicking, Punting
Confidence : Agility, Catching, Stamina

Blocking : Strength, Agility
Tackling : Speed, Jumping
Throwing : Strength, Vision
Catching : Confidence, Carrying
Carrying : Stamina, Catching
Kicking : Vision, Punting
Punting : Vision, Kicking



I'm gonna post again to request that Bort change the Intensive list to this list. It adds a few more options (and removes a couple) - but the big change is that this list is a lot more balanced in available options. It won't give the obviously desirable combinations that people want - but it does provide balance.
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by austin8214
All I am getting at is if I want to train confidence and stamina on my QB I should be able to do so. The choices are far too limited when training on intense in my opinion. By limiting the choices Bort is steering builds into the direction he prefers.


IF you want to train those 2 train them on normal! If you want to go "intense" then use the available choices!!!!!


 
DirtyMouse
offline
Link
 
I would like to see training points available on the main screen like SP available if this is not going to happen already.
 
austin8214
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rocomo
Originally posted by austin8214

All I am getting at is if I want to train confidence and stamina on my QB I should be able to do so. The choices are far too limited when training on intense in my opinion. By limiting the choices Bort is steering builds into the direction he prefers.


IF you want to train those 2 train them on normal! If you want to go "intense" then use the available choices!!!!!




Sure but then I will never have the opportunity to get a bonus token. No bonus tokens then you will not get the chance to buy advanced equipment. The whole problem could be solved if there were two drop down menus for intense training. That would give everyone the chance to select whatever they want.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.