I do think that a sticky is a good idea for this. This is a subject that needs to be delved deep into.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
jamz
offline
offline
2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.
USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.
Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.
Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.
USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.
Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.
Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
Tito716
offline
offline
Originally posted by papabear
I do think that a sticky is a good idea for this. This is a subject that needs to be delved deep into.
TBH I think the real issue is "What would it take for you to quit GLB?"
Once we establish the boundaries for renovation, then its possible to seek solutions.
I do think that a sticky is a good idea for this. This is a subject that needs to be delved deep into.
TBH I think the real issue is "What would it take for you to quit GLB?"
Once we establish the boundaries for renovation, then its possible to seek solutions.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1
You'll be able to spend it next season for level 32 gear. Which will cost you about 30 million or so to equip your team. Meanwhile Joe team that went 8-8 will have nothing, still desperately trying to build his stadium without tens of millions in playoff income.
And after that? Will we both be able to afford the 120 mil by the time they hit 40? Probably not. That +4 isn't game-changing, it's a tiny difference. Plus, I'm still unsure of why "Joe Team" doesn't have a bigger stadium, did the mismanage their money?
It's not the equipment itself that's a big deal. From a skill point standpoint it's not. However, its the ability to use that as a recruiting tool that's huge.
Huh? So it doesn't matter, but I'm able to trick players into thinking that it does and recruit them? That sounds like your issue is with the gullible players.
Originally posted by
Last season, my team was the 8 seed. We were 9-7. We beat the 1 seed. We lost the following game. guess how much money we got: 300,000. Meanwhile, that 1 seed we beat got about 30 times that amount of money.
That is a classic example of what is wrong with the game economically.
What does that matter, are you paying too much for your players?
Originally posted by
The deck is stacked. Have you looked at free agency threads? Every 'B' quality player or better has countless offers thrown at them. If you settle for lesser players, guess what? You lose! All season. Then relegate and no one wants to be on your team, free agent or otherwise.
It's a vicious cycle.
Yeah, it seems like you might indeed be paying too much for your players. Anything more then the min. required for training and equip is wasting money. If they ask for it, just tell them no.
Sorry Vanilla, but the layered brackets are confusing me. Let me just repond.
Part 1 -
You can't mismanage your money if you never have any. Blame that on the nature of fan support gains and losses. It's a system once again, geared for teams to dominate, win 8-10 in a row. If a team goes 9-7, they essentially gain ZERO fans. In fact depending on when the losses are, they may actually lose fans. For a winning season.
Moreover, it's not about tricking players. What's so hard to understand about this example:
level 32 CB is available. Great build.
Team A: with a 9-7 record, offers X salary but because they havent been blessed with a sky high fan base thanks to being dominant, and havent been blessed with playoff home game incomes, can only afford to offer this player 100k in signing bonus.
Team B: with a 14-2 record, offers the same salary, but has 50 million bucks laying around from being dominant and milking playoff incomes. They can offer the player 800k for all his level 32 upgrades.
Seriously, who would you sign with, not knowing either owner and having a 'neutral' opinion on them?
Part 2 - No, look at my roster. I am paying the minimum. But players want equipment, and truth is, I want to give them equipment. They deserve it. I'm not overpaying anything. I've built as much of my stadium as possible each season.
You continually fail to be able to wrap your head around this concept that high level players want MONEY. Whats worse, there are nowhere near enough competitive players at this level to support the number of teams who NEED them to be anything resembling successful!\
Part 3 - I'm not overpaying players. My own team actually isn't in actual ruin. But I'm not naive enough to see the problems this game has, and the utter befuddlement at people like you who can't seem to wrap your head around why.
Maybe its that 50 million dollar bank balance. Probably
Originally posted by islander1
You'll be able to spend it next season for level 32 gear. Which will cost you about 30 million or so to equip your team. Meanwhile Joe team that went 8-8 will have nothing, still desperately trying to build his stadium without tens of millions in playoff income.
And after that? Will we both be able to afford the 120 mil by the time they hit 40? Probably not. That +4 isn't game-changing, it's a tiny difference. Plus, I'm still unsure of why "Joe Team" doesn't have a bigger stadium, did the mismanage their money?
It's not the equipment itself that's a big deal. From a skill point standpoint it's not. However, its the ability to use that as a recruiting tool that's huge.
Huh? So it doesn't matter, but I'm able to trick players into thinking that it does and recruit them? That sounds like your issue is with the gullible players.
Originally posted by
Last season, my team was the 8 seed. We were 9-7. We beat the 1 seed. We lost the following game. guess how much money we got: 300,000. Meanwhile, that 1 seed we beat got about 30 times that amount of money.
That is a classic example of what is wrong with the game economically.
What does that matter, are you paying too much for your players?
Originally posted by
The deck is stacked. Have you looked at free agency threads? Every 'B' quality player or better has countless offers thrown at them. If you settle for lesser players, guess what? You lose! All season. Then relegate and no one wants to be on your team, free agent or otherwise.
It's a vicious cycle.
Yeah, it seems like you might indeed be paying too much for your players. Anything more then the min. required for training and equip is wasting money. If they ask for it, just tell them no.
Sorry Vanilla, but the layered brackets are confusing me. Let me just repond.
Part 1 -
You can't mismanage your money if you never have any. Blame that on the nature of fan support gains and losses. It's a system once again, geared for teams to dominate, win 8-10 in a row. If a team goes 9-7, they essentially gain ZERO fans. In fact depending on when the losses are, they may actually lose fans. For a winning season.
Moreover, it's not about tricking players. What's so hard to understand about this example:
level 32 CB is available. Great build.
Team A: with a 9-7 record, offers X salary but because they havent been blessed with a sky high fan base thanks to being dominant, and havent been blessed with playoff home game incomes, can only afford to offer this player 100k in signing bonus.
Team B: with a 14-2 record, offers the same salary, but has 50 million bucks laying around from being dominant and milking playoff incomes. They can offer the player 800k for all his level 32 upgrades.
Seriously, who would you sign with, not knowing either owner and having a 'neutral' opinion on them?
Part 2 - No, look at my roster. I am paying the minimum. But players want equipment, and truth is, I want to give them equipment. They deserve it. I'm not overpaying anything. I've built as much of my stadium as possible each season.
You continually fail to be able to wrap your head around this concept that high level players want MONEY. Whats worse, there are nowhere near enough competitive players at this level to support the number of teams who NEED them to be anything resembling successful!\
Part 3 - I'm not overpaying players. My own team actually isn't in actual ruin. But I'm not naive enough to see the problems this game has, and the utter befuddlement at people like you who can't seem to wrap your head around why.
Maybe its that 50 million dollar bank balance. Probably

Last edited Aug 29, 2008 11:43:13
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d
2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.
USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.
Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.
Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.
In other words, when people can't compete right away, some choose not to accept a challenge. Not exactly news.
2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.
USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.
Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.
Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.
In other words, when people can't compete right away, some choose not to accept a challenge. Not exactly news.
papabear
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
so restructing will not fix it. what will?
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
so restructing will not fix it. what will?
Tito716
offline
offline
I still don't understand the problem with restructuring.
Maybe a forced restructuring of the regions every 4 seasons would help.
Not a one time deal, but keep restructuring them...
Maybe a forced restructuring of the regions every 4 seasons would help.
Not a one time deal, but keep restructuring them...
Statbase
offline
offline
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by supp0007
2.) A person should only be allowed to GM for one team
first I saw this and wanted to comment on it without reading any farther. I am a GM of two teams, the first, BLPP is where I cut my teeth and then when a fellow teammate acquired a team I have since went to work for him, but still maintain most of my work with BLPP. Now if I'm doing a job for both teams, why should that not warrant GM status for both? I am spending a lot of my time to help out these guys, and maybe this is their way of saying I'm important.
Please don't get me wrong, I am not suggesting that everyone who is a GM for multiple teams is somehow "cheating". I know this is unpopular for the very reason you posted.
Nevertheless, it is a conflict of interest. For people who play this game for reason other than trying to be competitive, it will be exploited.
Originally posted by supp0007
2.) A person should only be allowed to GM for one team
first I saw this and wanted to comment on it without reading any farther. I am a GM of two teams, the first, BLPP is where I cut my teeth and then when a fellow teammate acquired a team I have since went to work for him, but still maintain most of my work with BLPP. Now if I'm doing a job for both teams, why should that not warrant GM status for both? I am spending a lot of my time to help out these guys, and maybe this is their way of saying I'm important.
Please don't get me wrong, I am not suggesting that everyone who is a GM for multiple teams is somehow "cheating". I know this is unpopular for the very reason you posted.
Nevertheless, it is a conflict of interest. For people who play this game for reason other than trying to be competitive, it will be exploited.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d
2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.
USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.
Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.
Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.
In other words, when people can't compete right away, some choose not to accept a challenge. Not exactly news.
when they see a game that is economically working against them - where the rich keep getting richer - they ask themselves what's the point?
What's the point of busting your ass to finish with a 11-5 record, finish seventh, win two games in the playoffs, and still have NOTHING to show for it financially?
Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d
2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.
USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.
Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.
Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.
In other words, when people can't compete right away, some choose not to accept a challenge. Not exactly news.
when they see a game that is economically working against them - where the rich keep getting richer - they ask themselves what's the point?
What's the point of busting your ass to finish with a 11-5 record, finish seventh, win two games in the playoffs, and still have NOTHING to show for it financially?
drifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
That's why it has to be combined with a way of dealing with gutted/inactive teams where they are automatically relegated to the bottom tier at the end of the season and the best teams from the lower tiers move up.
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
That's why it has to be combined with a way of dealing with gutted/inactive teams where they are automatically relegated to the bottom tier at the end of the season and the best teams from the lower tiers move up.
Colin Mochrie
offline
offline
There should be a boost league and a free league. The free league should only have agents, whose players retire after one season then they can decide if they want to join the pay league. Now I know this would lead to multiple accounts, since users would continue to create new players on new accounts to play the free league again. Either have some crazy IP checking software or let it happen. Since these cheap asses only get to experience about a tenth of GLB. It cannot be that much of a server load?
Outlaw Dogs
offline
offline
Originally posted by papabear
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
so restructing will not fix it. what will?
Demoting the the gutted teams at seasons end.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
so restructing will not fix it. what will?
Demoting the the gutted teams at seasons end.
drifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by supp0007
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by supp0007
2.) A person should only be allowed to GM for one team
first I saw this and wanted to comment on it without reading any farther. I am a GM of two teams, the first, BLPP is where I cut my teeth and then when a fellow teammate acquired a team I have since went to work for him, but still maintain most of my work with BLPP. Now if I'm doing a job for both teams, why should that not warrant GM status for both? I am spending a lot of my time to help out these guys, and maybe this is their way of saying I'm important.
Please don't get me wrong, I am not suggesting that everyone who is a GM for multiple teams is somehow "cheating". I know this is unpopular for the very reason you posted.
Nevertheless, it is a conflict of interest. For people who play this game for reason other than trying to be competitive, it will be exploited.
How is it a conflict of interest yet owning players on multiple teams is not? That doesn't make sense. If I have a player on a team, I want to contribute to the team and often that means being a GM for it.
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by supp0007
2.) A person should only be allowed to GM for one team
first I saw this and wanted to comment on it without reading any farther. I am a GM of two teams, the first, BLPP is where I cut my teeth and then when a fellow teammate acquired a team I have since went to work for him, but still maintain most of my work with BLPP. Now if I'm doing a job for both teams, why should that not warrant GM status for both? I am spending a lot of my time to help out these guys, and maybe this is their way of saying I'm important.
Please don't get me wrong, I am not suggesting that everyone who is a GM for multiple teams is somehow "cheating". I know this is unpopular for the very reason you posted.
Nevertheless, it is a conflict of interest. For people who play this game for reason other than trying to be competitive, it will be exploited.
How is it a conflict of interest yet owning players on multiple teams is not? That doesn't make sense. If I have a player on a team, I want to contribute to the team and often that means being a GM for it.
drifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by papabear
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
so restructing will not fix it. what will?
Demoting the the gutted teams at seasons end.
That's only half the solution. Things are too imabalanced right now to only implement half a solution.
Originally posted by papabear
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:
League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.
Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.
Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.
The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.
Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?
There are far too many variables here.
You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
You know as well as I do it won't work that way. As soon as you do the shake up you have these problems start all over again. In a league of the 32 best teams in the region, you'll still have teams that "can't compete" and will start the "going inactive" cycle all over.
Then, it's only a matter of time until "We need to restructure the leagues again".
so restructing will not fix it. what will?
Demoting the the gutted teams at seasons end.
That's only half the solution. Things are too imabalanced right now to only implement half a solution.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























