User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
You guys go ahead and discuss the OP, and Bort will ignore me or mock my ideas or whatever and instead like ideas that he likes instead that suit his timetable and propensity. It's outta my hands. I can only implore so much. Whatever happens happens.

But this will all come round full circle in time like it did from april/may to now if the result is always still creating disparity instead of lessening disparity. The customization ideas we all have and all ideas around customization thru SAs or other means are essentially fine.

Just to re-iterate tho....200 itself was not an over-haul at all. Nothing changed. All it meant was re-specing everyone. New-SAs WAS an over-haul. And it'd be false to say these ideas in here were NOT a similar overhaul. If admin want to put my new-SA down as being too much programming then it'd be facetious to say this wasnt any different.

Im all for customization, etc. Nothing against Drifter himself, because he's a fine poster/suggestor. I hate repeating myself but i often do because i fall on deaf ears. But I do think it's insincere to "only listen" to Drifter, sticky his threads, and implement his ideas, while many other threads and ideas (mine or others) often get unnoticed, neglected, etc.





I don't think Bort "only" listens to me. I've made a ton of suggestions that Bort has never commented on just like everyone else. However, I've also been in this forum since the very early days of Beta making well thought out suggestions so I've gained a reputation. Anybody else can do the same thing with persistence and good ideas.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Maybe it's because Drifter's ideas are good and yours are not.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Maybe it's because Drifter's ideas are good and yours are not.


Maybe, who cares.

back to idea please
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Just please dont think I dislike you or anything, drifter. You or others like Ken1, 1VBchaos, Xiong Yoshi, turnerhero, etc etc etc. All of you are top people. I love reading all your posts and thoughts. I also like many other newbies out there who bring great suggestions.

To focus on your OP topic....i just think it focuses on and aims to address the experience of the vet player only, and in doing so creates more disparity etc. I LOVE anything about bringing in more customization, removing cookie-cutters, etc etc. I just think the chronology of actions must be 1) noob 2) customization 3) vet.

Meaning...1) level the playing field first before anything, 2) create a whole new degree of customization doesnt matter whose idea it is, it's gonna mean an over-haul of some degree, 3) then look at ways of bringing in bells/whistles for vets.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Just please dont think I dislike you or anything, drifter. You or others like Ken1, 1VBchaos, Xiong Yoshi, turnerhero, etc etc etc. All of you are top people. I love reading all your posts and thoughts. I also like many other newbies out there who bring great suggestions.

To focus on your OP topic....i just think it focuses on and aims to address the experience of the vet player only, and in doing so creates more disparity etc. I LOVE anything about bringing in more customization, removing cookie-cutters, etc etc. I just think the chronology of actions must be 1) noob 2) customization 3) vet.

Meaning...1) level the playing field first before anything, 2) create a whole new degree of customization doesnt matter whose idea it is, it's gonna mean an over-haul of some degree, 3) then look at ways of bringing in bells/whistles for vets.


The reality is that the game needs to retain it's customer base and that is in a lot of danger right now because of stagnation. Any good business works on keeping it's existing customers before it works on gathering new ones because eventually you'll tap out your new customer resources.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I agree with you on every point except one - That's what GLB should be focusing on...

Bort gets to decide what GLB is focusing upon.


The suggestions board is basically customers telling the business how to improve it's business, making suggestions on what it "should" and "should not" be focusing on. That's the dynamic at play here. Im not putting down Bort or anyone ever, honestly. We all love and appreciate Bort and the burdens/tasks he's under etc.

Drifter, on your last comment...retaining customer base is at heart with my implored 200 talk too. No good having 50 rabidly loyal paying people only. The amount of noob people who give up is alarming, more them than the regulars that are leaving and NOT spending more money than they could. It's about trying to turn the thousands that pop into GLB to try-buy into regular spenders and players. GLB's system from day 1 has in fact been always crueling the noob more than the vet. The vet is also being crueled in many ways too, i agree that needs to be addressed (which your idea aims to). But the first step has to be leveling the field.

And the other real big problem with GLB is that true tactics and game-planning has too less a say in game results (and that's partly due to lack of customization, specialization, individualization in player builds), but also to due to the very disparity in player levels. No matter what a level 20 team does, it will get beaten silly by a level 25 team.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 20:55:21
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Others have said it before - and I've come to think that they were right - Bort made a mistake by accepting money for the game.

If Bort discovered what he thought was an "ideal" design for the game that would be of interest to new and veteran Players, but it required that all current players be "reset".. how do we think that the Agents in the game would respond? There would be mass hysteria because "I spent money on this game!!!! blah blah blah" .. so of course we know that any idea that requires a complete reset is out the window - regardless how perfect the idea might turn out to be.

I suppose it doesn't matter, because the game is what the game is, but it means that idea like the one presented in the thread will be limited in their scope (not to mention the dozens of other ideas, like the 200 idea, floating around). One comment in this thread was to the effect of "If we have some of these new abilities unlocked at level 25 - how do we compensate Players that have already exceeded this level?" The answer is - we really can't.. and since that would cut those Players short, it'd be best to start this idea off of a level that is in front of the Players.. Well there are already plenty of level 31's and 32's... by the end of the season there will probably be some 33's. So does that mean that this new system wouldn't kick in until level 34 or 35?

Accepting money gave an assumed promise to not completely change the game.. regardless how explicitly the Admin has said that changes are coming - those who have spent the most on the game will be the ones least likely to accept changes; and they happen to be the ones who are most likely to spend more in the future as long as they are happy.

Shrug.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Take me as a vet example. Ive been here since mid-season 1. I've spent literally thousands of dollars on GLB. All the way thru tho, I've been gnashing my teeth in frustration at the problems in the game. Not just that, but that the ways to improve and deepen the game havent been always implemented. Band-aids, in other words. But Im still here ONLY because im holding out that in a month or five GLB will eventually become the game i envision it could be. The potential there finally reached. But during all this time, there have been far more thousands of noobs come and go. Due to all those things i've touched on that in the end made them quit and realize it wasnt worth it.

They are more important than me. From the 10,000 new people that join in july, maybe 1,000 become new GG's, willing to spend hundreds of dollars a month. But the system in place is turning those 10,000 or even those 1,000 into quitters after a season or two max. Often far sooner. The regulars are important, but really GLB should be shocked and woken up to appreciate all that lost business. While all that's happening, you NOW have also regulars starting to quit too. I appreciate this also. But really what it all boils down to is that over-hauling/re-doing of stuff has to occur. From the ground up. Starting right from the foundation. No point side-stepping it. It's always gonna come back to haunt. BECAUSE much of the current modules/systems in place are NOT conducive to either noobs or vets. This model wont stand the test of time.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 21:12:23
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Take me as a vet example. Ive been here since mid-season 1. I've spent literally thousands of dollars on GLB. All the way thru tho, I've been gnashing my teeth in frustration at the problems in the game. Not just that, but that the ways to improve and deepen the game havent been always implemented. Band-aids, in other words. But Im still here ONLY because im holding out that in a month or five GLB will eventually become the game i envision it could be. The potential there finally reached. But during all this time, there have been far more thousands of noobs come and go. Due to all those things i've touched on that in the end made them quit and realize it wasnt worth it.

They are more important than me. From the 10,000 new people that join in july, maybe 1,000 become new GG's, willing to spend hundreds of dollars a month. But the system in place is turning those 10,000 or even those 1,000 into quitters after a season or two max. Often far sooner. The regulars are important, but really GLB should be shocked and woken up to appreciate all that lost business. While all that's happening, you NOW have also regulars starting to quit too. I appreciate this also. But really what it all boils down to is that over-hauling/re-doing of stuff has to occur. From the ground up. Starting right from the foundation. No point side-stepping it. It's always gonna come back to haunt.


The number of active players is still going up. One can see that in the lists one sees with "Create a New Player." When the new 1,024 teams were added, those were mostly at High demand. Now, none are. For everyone who's become inactive, more players have become active.

You've hijacked a great thread (and that makes me angry) to call for a restart (which, if it were to happen, would make me very angry, but it won't anyway) that not only won't happen but would lose half the current players if it did.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Anyways, not to cut this little side talk off - cause I agree with a lot of what you are saying - but if the thread was my idea.. I'd get pissed at a couple of spoil sports taking it off subject.

So, in the interest of trying to get back to the discussion about Prestige levels -- I suppose the main considerations should be:

1) At what level do Players start gaining the experience? There is already one level 35 Player in the game and dozens of level 30+ players... if the idea is going to be implemented, this is something that will need to be considered.. especially as time grinds on and more and more level 30+ players appear.

2) What will the relative importance be of this, compared to the current leveling scheme. Will a L40P22 Player be the equiv of a L50 Player? L60 Player? L45 Player?

3) There is always the possibility that this system is tied in with the FAME system. I don't know that I like this because this system is very straight forward and does not lend itself to being abused.. if the Fame Points were used instead of these Prestige points - then all of the considerations on owners rewarding their own players with fat contracts/play time to get more fame.. winning teams getting more fame, leading FA's to only sign with winning teams.. etc etc.. if we introduce all of this to the Prestige system - then chances are good that the Prestige system will turn into another layer of rich get richer.

4) Maybe Prestige abilities should not be active for games played outside of PRO league games?

5) Then of course, everyone's favorite - come up with lists of prestige abilities, and possible abilities/skills/stats/other that might be required to unlock them.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Anyways, not to cut this little side talk off - cause I agree with a lot of what you are saying - but if the thread was my idea.. I'd get pissed at a couple of spoil sports taking it off subject.

So, in the interest of trying to get back to the discussion about Prestige levels -- I suppose the main considerations should be:

1) At what level do Players start gaining the experience? There is already one level 35 Player in the game and dozens of level 30+ players... if the idea is going to be implemented, this is something that will need to be considered.. especially as time grinds on and more and more level 30+ players appear.

2) What will the relative importance be of this, compared to the current leveling scheme. Will a L40P22 Player be the equiv of a L50 Player? L60 Player? L45 Player?

3) There is always the possibility that this system is tied in with the FAME system. I don't know that I like this because this system is very straight forward and does not lend itself to being abused.. if the Fame Points were used instead of these Prestige points - then all of the considerations on owners rewarding their own players with fat contracts/play time to get more fame.. winning teams getting more fame, leading FA's to only sign with winning teams.. etc etc.. if we introduce all of this to the Prestige system - then chances are good that the Prestige system will turn into another layer of rich get richer.

4) Maybe Prestige abilities should not be active for games played outside of PRO league games?

5) Then of course, everyone's favorite - come up with lists of prestige abilities, and possible abilities/skills/stats/other that might be required to unlock them.


1) You have two options. 1 - Everybody above level 31 starts accruing VP at teh same time when it is implemented. 2 - You retroactively give VP to players past level 31 based on what they would have earned.

2) I don't think you can really make that comparison since VP levels won't give you points for your actual attributes or SAs.

3) Not quite following you. It might be tied in that you can spend your VP pts on a "perk" that increases your fame, but otherwise they wouldn't have anything to do with each other under what I outlined.

4) Why?

5) That's what's supposed to be happening in here right now.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Anyways, not to cut this little side talk off - cause I agree with a lot of what you are saying - but if the thread was my idea.. I'd get pissed at a couple of spoil sports taking it off subject.

So, in the interest of trying to get back to the discussion about Prestige levels -- I suppose the main considerations should be:

1) At what level do Players start gaining the experience? There is already one level 35 Player in the game and dozens of level 30+ players... if the idea is going to be implemented, this is something that will need to be considered.. especially as time grinds on and more and more level 30+ players appear.

2) What will the relative importance be of this, compared to the current leveling scheme. Will a L40P22 Player be the equiv of a L50 Player? L60 Player? L45 Player?

3) There is always the possibility that this system is tied in with the FAME system. I don't know that I like this because this system is very straight forward and does not lend itself to being abused.. if the Fame Points were used instead of these Prestige points - then all of the considerations on owners rewarding their own players with fat contracts/play time to get more fame.. winning teams getting more fame, leading FA's to only sign with winning teams.. etc etc.. if we introduce all of this to the Prestige system - then chances are good that the Prestige system will turn into another layer of rich get richer.

4) Maybe Prestige abilities should not be active for games played outside of PRO league games?

5) Then of course, everyone's favorite - come up with lists of prestige abilities, and possible abilities/skills/stats/other that might be required to unlock them.


1) You have two options. 1 - Everybody above level 31 starts accruing VP at teh same time when it is implemented. 2 - You retroactively give VP to players past level 31 based on what they would have earned.

2) I don't think you can really make that comparison since VP levels won't give you points for your actual attributes or SAs.

3) Not quite following you. It might be tied in that you can spend your VP pts on a "perk" that increases your fame, but otherwise they wouldn't have anything to do with each other under what I outlined.

4) Why?

5) That's what's supposed to be happening in here right now.



I think that to be fair, as to Question 1, you have to retroactively give VP's based on what would have been accrued.

As to Question 3, I think some people have suggested VA's (veteran attributes) that would make fame easier to gain. So, that's the tie in.

As to Question 4, Xiong and I both tend to want to incentivize those pplayers who can to play in higher leagues without forcing it on them. So Xiong might be thinking of it as a way to incentivize it. If this were used as an incentive, I think it would just have to be more VP's earned the higher the league, nothing more.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
1) You have two options. 1 - Everybody above level 31 starts accruing VP at teh same time when it is implemented. 2 - You retroactively give VP to players past level 31 based on what they would have earned.

2) I don't think you can really make that comparison since VP levels won't give you points for your actual attributes or SAs.

3) Not quite following you. It might be tied in that you can spend your VP pts on a "perk" that increases your fame, but otherwise they wouldn't have anything to do with each other under what I outlined.

4) Why?

5) That's what's supposed to be happening in here right now.



Well, in a lot of ways - the "issues" I mention were more for Bort's consideration than purely for direct answers. For example - I tend to agree with your first answer to the first question.. everyone just starts collecting, if they are eligiable, on the day the system goes into effect.. exactly as if all those players had just boosted to get to their current level. Makes sense to me.

But for your number 2 - of course they can be compared... but Bort would have to be the one to compare them with an outcome already in mind. If you took a level 33 Player, cloned him, boosted the clone to level 35. Then spent all of the VP which the level 33 has, but didn't spend the VP which the 35 has - which Player would be better? Either one of them would be better than the other, or they'd be about the same.. simple to compare - but more importantly, Bort would need to decide how important the VPs are relative to gaining traditional levels.

As for the third question.. You might not have intended VP system to be connected with the Fame system - but that doesn't mean that Bort isn't looking at them as being similar. Right now we can probably be sure that a portion of Bort's attention is on designing the Fame system for next season. It isn't too hard to imagine him thinking about it, stumbling on your idea, and immediately seeing it as a partial answer to something he was wondering about with Fame - namely, how are the fame points accumulated.. or maybe, what are the fame points spent on? Just because you don't intend there to be a connection, does not mean that Bort sees it the same way. I was just trying to generate a bit of discussion about comparing/contrasting the ideas to see how they would interact/relate to each other.

Fourth point - why not let Prestige Abilities into lower than Pro games? Primarily because it would be a huge incentive for the highest level Players to want to Play in Pro.. it isn't as though those players are going to be at a disadvantage when playing in AAA without these Prestige Abilities.. no one else will have them either. Mostly it's to encourage those with Prestige Abilities to want to play in Pro. Beyond that though - as pointed out by GG, giving new abilities to high level players will further increase the power divide between high and low level Players. Minimizing that divide in leagues below PRO should be a priority.

and yea, the last bit was designed to try and get the discussion back on topic.
 
Phaedron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Veter[a]n backup - reduces the number of snaps needed for full exp when playing in a non-stater role on the depth chart.

Special teams expert - similar to above but for special team


I'm a big fan of adding these to the "official list"... there's enough backups out there that deserve to be able to level at the same rate as starters. Sure you can have 2 RBs who get similar carry numbers, but what if your team wants to have a decent backup QB for games that turn into massive shoot-outs?

Especially once injuries are implemented, I think these will be helpful.
 
Phaedron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG

And the other real big problem with GLB is that true tactics and game-planning has too less a say in game results (and that's partly due to lack of customization, specialization, individualization in player builds), but also to due to the very disparity in player levels. No matter what a level 20 team does, it will get beaten silly by a level 25 team.


I think you have a problem with the game of Football, not with GLB.

No matter how hard the Detroit Lions play, if all they have is rookies and 50-yr old QBs, they aren't going to beat the Patriots, Cowboys, and other elite teams in the NFL. If your team is a bunch of rookies, it's always going to be a rebuilding season.

Actually, GLB does handle this pretty well by slowing down player leveling at least somewhat at the higher levels... that, combined with what Bort is already planning on doing with sending gutted teams down to the minor leagues, pretty much takes care of the player level disparity.

I hate to use myself as an example all the time, but the L-OT I have on the Pushovers started out about 3-4 levels lower than all the other players on the team. He's since caught up a bit in levels, but more importantly, his build and the Pushovers' tactics have always kept him competitive in the league.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.