User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Say Beta like the Brits and it doesn't seem so harsh:

"BEE-TUH"
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Next time try to read the whole thing before making idiotic remarks.


How is pointing out the fact that this is BETA (see emphasis) to those that dont seem to grasp the idea, idiotic?

Seems idiotic to complain about changes while IN a BETA to me.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
What is beta, but just a word?
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
gah



head







going



to







explo........
 
Rexxor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
Bottom line. If you don't like something, complain out the ass. It will get changed sooner or later as long as you have a valid point of what you're complaining about. If you just sit there and expect things to work themselves out, nothing will be done unless others are complaining about the same thing that troubles you.

My personal opinion is that too much is being changed at once. If builds are a problem, change those and get those worked out. If game settings are a problem, change those and get those worked out. Changing the both together is only making it harder to see what the real problems are.


Sorry to catch up late with this - but you make an excellent point. Part of the issue is figuring what variables are affecting the players performance and the sim performance. Changing too many variables too quickly leads to radical systemic problems, basic experimental design - if you have too many variables changing you cannot have a valid result or put another way, you can't see what the real problems are/whats really going on. Again, for future changes, multiple, smaller incremental changes would be better and/or adjusting with a longer public test period (more scrimmages). It would give more test data and allow you a longer time to debug Bort. Again, making some suggestions - take em or leave em as you like.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.


you keep doing what you are doing bort , i honestly believe you are making changes to help better the sim and this game , and for that reason i keep staying, and far as the passing game it is working for me so far and run game works also if you have some good o-line there are a few bugs here and there but we'll overcome them in time , keep up the hard work
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
THIS GAME IS IN BETA

For those thats never been involved in open beta TESTING, there will be changes, daily, multiple times a day, sometimes servers are taken down for hours/days at a time to fix some bugs.

THIS IS BETA

THIS SHOULD BE EXPECTED

THIS IS THE ENTIRE POINT OF OPEN BETA


I'VE BETA TESTED A DOZEN GAMES INCLUDING TWO MMORPGS. NO OTHER BETA IN THE HISTORY OF VIDEO GAME DEVELOPMENT CHARGED THE BETA TESTERS HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS A MONTH FOR THE PRIVILEGE OF BETA TESTING. THAT'S BECAUSE THE BETA TESTERS ARE THE ONES PROVIDING THE SERVICE, NOT THE GAME DEVELOPER.

I understand why Bort is charging money for FP. Bort needs to understand that the fact that he is charging money for FP changes the rules on what it means to be BETA.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
I don't buy the "It's a beta, therefore it can be a dysfunctional game."

I'm not bashing Bort or anything...he's doing a great job. But you expect a certain level of service (which I feel Customer Support / the mods in general lack) and a game which is 95-99% bug free.

I'd say this game is 85% bug free.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jebby69
I get so frustrated every time a new game sims this season because it is just another installment of a disaster. I am the GM of a team and we had built a successful team based on the "OLD" rules of the game. We had built players that were successful in the specific aspect of the game they were asked to perform.


So, you had players that pushed the all important speed... I need to ask you though, do you honestly think the game would have been better to just continue like it was, where high speed "broke" the need for agility to accelerate? Actually hell, where you didn't even need agility to do anything because speed was THE stat. Do you honestly believe the game was better then?

Originally posted by
I am all for making the game better, but how can you (Bort) make such drastic changes midway into something that completely breaks everything. I know everyone is going to bitch about us having bad builds, but they werent according to the rules we used to have to follow and I would argue that they still aren't.


How do you make the game 'better' if you don't address issues that are not working correctly?

Originally posted by
Now the rules change and we are all in the mid 20's level wise and there just isn't any way to try to react, we level about every 5 games and obviously we need a bunch of some magic skill to make us better. Changes seem to be made on the hour to try to compensate, but it just feels like we are trying to adjust to a moving target which is no good since once skill points are allocated there is no getting them back. While all of these changes are going on would there be something wrong with allowing people to reallocate their skills say once a season??


This might be a good point. Since this is a BETA, I'm not sure it wouldn't be a decent idea to just refund the skill points on players and let them re-allocate them. I think Bort has a record of the skills points you've used to level up, maybe he could set up a script that would allow you to redo them. I don't know if it is honestly worth the time it would take to code something like that though. I can't imagine it would be real easy. I also shudder to think what teams will look like if they get a chance to redo everyone.

Originally posted by
I know I am not alone in this frustration because I have spoken to several other successful owners whose teams have been brought to their knees this season. The problem is the majority of the players out there that do all the talking are the ones who were saved by these changes and all of the people who were screwed are scrambling to try to find a quick solution to be competitive again.


Not me, Last season my Marauders won their conference, and got promoted. This year our first game sucked, but since we have kind of gotten a handle on the changes.

Originally posted by
At times it feels like the developers of this game want everyone to have "cookie cutter" type builds where everyone is pretty much the same because they are forcing so many skills be at high levels to be even adequate at particuar aspects of the game. What is the fun if everyone is built the same?


Actually, I would maintain that the "Cookie Cutter" builds were prevalent during seasons 2 and 3. Everyone was pushing speed, and not much else. That is pretty much the definition of "cookie cutter"

PinTBC
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
I just like to say that this game has improved A LOT. It is much more fun right now and people spending time to plan their builds and tactics get rewarded. Please don't listen to people whining about the changes made. Those changes were needed and improved the game. Now the players need to understand that they have to adapt too. This might be harder for some, but in the end I'm absolutely sure, we all have more fun - because it's more realistic.

That's what matters i.m.h.o. - instead of keeping yourself winning.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
i agree, I love the changes, hate the whiners
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by deez11010

THIS GAME IS IN BETA

For those thats never been involved in open beta TESTING, there will be changes, daily, multiple times a day, sometimes servers are taken down for hours/days at a time to fix some bugs.

THIS IS BETA

THIS SHOULD BE EXPECTED

THIS IS THE ENTIRE POINT OF OPEN BETA


I'VE BETA TESTED A DOZEN GAMES INCLUDING TWO MMORPGS. NO OTHER BETA IN THE HISTORY OF VIDEO GAME DEVELOPMENT CHARGED THE BETA TESTERS HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS A MONTH FOR THE PRIVILEGE OF BETA TESTING. THAT'S BECAUSE THE BETA TESTERS ARE THE ONES PROVIDING THE SERVICE, NOT THE GAME DEVELOPER.

I understand why Bort is charging money for FP. Bort needs to understand that the fact that he is charging money for FP changes the rules on what it means to be BETA.


+1

Collecting cash, whether you try and call it a "Donation" or not, raises the expectations of the "testers". I'm sorry it just does.

And is anyone here suprised that BORT is NOT the one saying "if you don't like it quit playing?" That attitude hurts the game in two ways. Fewer testers = less ideas & longer for bug fixes. Also, fewer testers = fewer future customers. It is harder to re-capture a lost customer than to get a new customer to try the game out.

One last thing, IMO if Bort was really treating this like a true Beta, you would have flexibility on builds (ie re-allocating SPs) or you would get a FULL SP REFUND on boosts when retiring. The fact that you don't is because the business model is designed to get you to spend money. Not to test the game.

Sorry Bort, the game is good, but I have to call you to the carpet a bit about the for-profit nature of this Beta.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
The only thing I can agree on in this thread is that the customer support system could be better.

Just because other beta games haven't historically charged testers to play doesn't mean this one can't, nor that it isn't a viable business model.

There will be bugs and changes, probably throughout the first "phase" of life for this game (i.e. player decline and retirement). As players have leveled up so far, users find ways to "exploit" the system and make dominant builds. Once we've gone through a full lifespan of the Alpha players, the changes should be minimal after that, assuming a full game engine is in place.

People also complained that other MMORPG's let you keep your "toon" forever, but that doesn't mean every MMORPG has to do that. We'll see how the decline/retirement plays out here.

And for those complaining about speed being nerfed, it is still one of the most useful attributes you can add to your player...you just need to surround it with higher other attributes and you'll be fine. Heck, in the lower leagues, I have a couple guys who are currently mostly speed as I build up each attribute and they are having fine seasons.
 
Link
 
I can't emphasize enough what people have said regarding the reallocation of skill points. When changes are introduced that break builds that have been planned out over 2 seasons we should have a chance to reallocate those sp's. Yeah yeah yeah we are stupid cause we spent all our sp's in "x".

Like a lot of people mentioned above, mmorpg's do this in Beta and on occasion in live releases. Use WoW as an example, when changes are introduced that change the basic play characteristics of a certain class, the class' spent SP's are reset to zero and the player has the opportunity to reallocate the sp's.

I think this a lot more reasonable then saying retire/reroll your player because this is a beta as a number of players are saying here.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BoogerEyeJones
I can't emphasize enough what people have said regarding the reallocation of skill points. When changes are introduced that break builds that have been planned out over 2 seasons we should have a chance to reallocate those sp's. Yeah yeah yeah we are stupid cause we spent all our sp's in "x".

Like a lot of people mentioned above, mmorpg's do this in Beta and on occasion in live releases. Use WoW as an example, when changes are introduced that change the basic play characteristics of a certain class, the class' spent SP's are reset to zero and the player has the opportunity to reallocate the sp's.

I think this a lot more reasonable then saying retire/reroll your player because this is a beta as a number of players are saying here.


I understand your pain, but realistically, why would you think that putting SP into ONE category would be a viable build?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.